Home |
Search |
Today's Posts |
|
UK diy (uk.d-i-y) For the discussion of all topics related to diy (do-it-yourself) in the UK. All levels of experience and proficency are welcome to join in to ask questions or offer solutions. |
Reply |
|
LinkBack | Thread Tools | Display Modes |
|
#1
|
|||
|
|||
Damp problems again!!!
Hi All,
More damp questions - apologies for boring anyone. The background - my living room has damp problems mainly on two walls - it rises up to within a foot of the coving. 1870s house solid walls. I've done all the usual checks. It's not condensation and there is evidence it's been a problem before. Ground level is below both the slate dpc and the silicon DPC. Room 25ft by 10ft. Recently had a quote by a damp company (~£3K) to do the following; - Inject DPC (already has a silicon one and a slate one) - Strip plaster on two walls (total 35ft inc 3 windows and frenchdoors) - Treat the two walls with some sort of waterproofing "stuff" - Replaster two walls - Remove bottom 6" of external render and rerender with bellcast. - Repoint two courses of bricks (35ft) below the DPC. My plan is to get them to do the DPC (and wall treatment???) and I'll do the rest. I appreciate the injected DPCs are not trusted by many but I want to give this work every chance of fixing the problem. For the internal walls; - Should I plaster or use plasterboard with a skim? Damp Company didn't like the idea of plasterboarding as it causes problem with the wall treatment. - If I plaster, what type(s) of plaster should I use? I would get someone in to do this. - If I plasterboard it presumably celotex could be used to aid insulation? - Could I "dot 'n dab" plasterboard direct to the wall? - Should I treat the bare brick in any way prior to this? - Do I need to give the walls time to dry out? - If so roughly how long? For the external walls; -What mix of render? -Any tips with the bellcast beading? How far above the DPCs should it be? -What mix for repointing below the DPC? -What mix for repointing above the DPC? Incidentally, I am getting a few more quotes!! All experiences/advice welcome... Cheers, Martin. |
#2
|
|||
|
|||
"Martin" wrote in message om... Hi All, More damp questions - apologies for boring anyone. The background - my living room has damp problems mainly on two walls - it rises up to within a foot of the coving. 1870s house solid walls. I've done all the usual checks. It's not condensation and there is evidence it's been a problem before. Ground level is below both the slate dpc and the silicon DPC. Room 25ft by 10ft. Recently had a quote by a damp company (~£3K) to do the following; - Inject DPC (already has a silicon one and a slate one) If it has a slate DPC (which usually works or can be made to work) why does it need an injected one (which doesn't) ? |
#3
|
|||
|
|||
"Martin" wrote in message om... Hi All, More damp questions - apologies for boring anyone. The background - my living room has damp problems mainly on two walls - it rises up to within a foot of the coving. 1870s house solid walls. I've done all the usual checks. It's not condensation and there is evidence it's been a problem before. Ground level is below both the slate dpc and the silicon DPC. Room 25ft by 10ft. Recently had a quote by a damp company (~£3K) to do the following; - Inject DPC (already has a silicon one and a slate one) - Strip plaster on two walls (total 35ft inc 3 windows and frenchdoors) - Treat the two walls with some sort of waterproofing "stuff" - Replaster two walls - Remove bottom 6" of external render and rerender with bellcast. - Repoint two courses of bricks (35ft) below the DPC. My plan is to get them to do the DPC (and wall treatment???) and I'll do the rest. I appreciate the injected DPCs are not trusted by many but I want to give this work every chance of fixing the problem. For the internal walls; - Should I plaster or use plasterboard with a skim? Damp Company didn't like the idea of plasterboarding as it causes problem with the wall treatment. - If I plaster, what type(s) of plaster should I use? I would get someone in to do this. - If I plasterboard it presumably celotex could be used to aid insulation? - Could I "dot 'n dab" plasterboard direct to the wall? - Should I treat the bare brick in any way prior to this? - Do I need to give the walls time to dry out? - If so roughly how long? For the external walls; -What mix of render? -Any tips with the bellcast beading? How far above the DPCs should it be? -What mix for repointing below the DPC? -What mix for repointing above the DPC? Incidentally, I am getting a few more quotes!! All experiences/advice welcome... Cheers, Martin. am i right in believing that this is more or less floor to ceiling ? I was always led to believe that rising damp gets about 2 foot up the wall and hacking off to a metre high is the done thing. I would suspect penetrating damp more than rising - are both walls exterior and rendered ? Regards Jeff |
#4
|
|||
|
|||
|
#5
|
|||
|
|||
In message , Martin
writes The background - my living room has damp problems mainly on two walls - it rises up to within a foot of the coving. If your wall is damp above about 3ft, IT IS NOT RISING DAMP, and a DPC has nothing to do with it. 1870s house solid walls. I've done all the usual checks. It's not condensation and there is evidence it's been a problem before. Ground level is below both the slate dpc and the silicon DPC. Room 25ft by 10ft. Recently had a quote by a damp company (~£3K) to do the following; - Inject DPC (already has a silicon one and a slate one) - Strip plaster on two walls (total 35ft inc 3 windows and frenchdoors) - Treat the two walls with some sort of waterproofing "stuff" - Replaster two walls - Remove bottom 6" of external render and rerender with bellcast. - Repoint two courses of bricks (35ft) below the DPC. They obviously dont know what they are doing and are relying on your ignorance to RIP YOU OFF!!! The damp could be falling from within a foot of the coving, which suggests that it is coming from above. It could be Gutters, Overflow Pipe, Rotten Window, Shower/Sink/Bath/Central Heating etc. Leaking, and so on - but it is not rising damp!!! Unless your covings are only 4 ft from the floor/ground level. -- Richard Faulkner |
#6
|
|||
|
|||
Martin wrote:
The background - my living room has damp problems mainly on two walls - it rises up to within a foot of the coving. 1870s house solid walls. I've done all the usual checks. It's not condensation and there is evidence it's been a problem before. Check your rendering. Check it again. Look for cracks, tap it to see whether it sounds hollow. See if there are cracks around cills where water could be getting in. Is the render painted? I've had a few similar problems in the past. |
#7
|
|||
|
|||
Chris Bacon wrote: Martin wrote: The background - my living room has damp problems mainly on two walls - it rises up to within a foot of the coving. 1870s house solid walls. I've done all the usual checks. It's not condensation and there is evidence it's been a problem before. The age of your house suggests that it has solid 9'' walls, was the outside rendered to try to cure the problem ? does the damp worsen after bad weather? old or blocked guttering may be overflowing on to the wall side and getting behind the render, we had a simmilar problem with water getting behind paint, once the paint was stripped away there was a damp patch of about 8 square meters on the outside wall, its just about dried out now ,about 7 months later |
#8
|
|||
|
|||
|
#9
|
|||
|
|||
In message , Martin
writes I do have another couple of damp companies coming around to give me a quote - it's going to be interesting to hear what they advise. Make sure that they are members of the BWPDA, (www.bwpda.co.uk). Ask them how damp could rise above 3 ft, when all theory says it cant. It may be worth paying for someone to take a core sample from the brickwork to see if it is damp in the wall, and not just on the surface. Many damp companies dont know what they are doing, and tell you something needs doing when it doesnt. Are you anywhere near Manchester? -- Richard Faulkner |
#10
|
|||
|
|||
Martin wrote: wrote in message roups.com... Chris Bacon wrote: Martin wrote -There is some paint bubbling on the outside when it rains (approx the size of a dinner plate) but this approx 10ft from the worst affected area. The rest of the paint seems to be stuck fast as is the render Martin. on our wall there were a few patches of bubbling paint the majority of it looked fine, once removed though the wall was damp over a large area which had been covered in 'good' paint. one of the problems was the previous owners had used a rubber based paint half way up the wall (to cure the damp) so the water couldn't evaporate once it had got behind the paint, as someone said earlier any paint used should be breathable. Could you scrape a patch of the bubbling paint away to see if the render is damp underneath any water can travel a fair distance before it finds its way in. |
#11
|
|||
|
|||
Hi Martin.
This is classic stuff, the damp old Victorian house that goes from bad to worse despite all the efforts of dampproofing 'specialists'. And the cause? The fact that all the wrong things are being done. This scenario plays out over and over again, so often its a well known deal. Add to this the twin facts that a) you dont understand how damp is managed in Vic properties, and b) you've made mistakes in your conlcusions, and you cant get to the bottom of it either. First, if you want to understand damp and Vic properties, I'd recommend a good long chat at http://www.periodproperty.co.uk/cgi-...rum2.pl?#43991 Now, whats going on: 1. Vic houses handled damp fine when they wre built, they were not pits of damp. So the basic design is good. 2. Since its damp now, it is what has been changed that has caused it. What has changed? 1. Airtight double glazing stops ventilation 2. Chimney blocked off 3. Maybe draught proofing elsewhere too 4. Gysum plaster and emulsion 5. Cement render and paint 6. shower installed All of these increase the damp levels in the walls, and some properties then begin to fail to deal satisfactorily with the damp. Contrary to your conclusions, the cause is indeed condensation. Why did the dehumidifier not cure it? Primarily because it has been going on for so long that the walls have become soaked, so that it will take many months to dry them out. Also there are other works that will need doing to fix it properly, eg the exterior render will be an ongoing problem. What else needs doing? The first thing to understand is you need to allow the wall to dry out, not trap all that water in it, which is what all your presently considered works are about. No to tanking No to rendering No to painting with water resistant paints No to a 3rd DPC (!!) (slate should last much longer than 130 years) Yes to: Humidistatic dehumidifier Lowering ground levels if theyre at or above the dpc Checking the drain channel drains properly Repoint all failed mortar with lime - but dont remove anything thats stuck hard. Removing all exterior render, and finishing by either cleaning the bricks up, or if theyre too much of a mess, lime render. Remove interior plaster and replaster with lime, painting with lime based paints, not emulsion. Checking ground water drains away from the house, not to the walls. And I would add ventilation to the house for your own health, though this is not necessary re damp until such time as you stop using the dehumidifier. Pay attention to major sources of damp within the house: Install dehumidifier in bathroom, or maybe a fan. And possibly enclose the shower so it doesnt produce as much steam in the room, if practical. And preferably install a cooker hood Understand some basic concepts with these houses: 1. More damp is produced inside by breathing, cooking and showering than comes from outside 2. Thus what is wanted is porosity, to allow the damp out, quite the opposite of sealing. 3. Damp proofing companies do work so they can get your money. 4. If dealt with appropriately, a Vic house with no dpc, no render, no waterprofing treatments etc can be dry and healthy. 5. Also be aware that a 9" wall will take a very long time to dry out, even with the above treatments done. BTW there is one gotcha: the bricks will be very soft, and the cement render hard, and it is _very_ easy to do serious brick damage when removing the render. Proceeed only with serious care on this point. NT |
#13
|
|||
|
|||
This is classic stuff, the damp old Victorian house that goes from bad to worse despite all the efforts of dampproofing 'specialists'. And the cause? The fact that all the wrong things are being done. This scenario plays out over and over again, so often its a well known deal. Add to this the twin facts that a) you dont understand how damp is managed in Vic properties, and b) you've made mistakes in your conlcusions, and you cant get to the bottom of it either. First, if you want to understand damp and Vic properties, I'd recommend a good long chat at http://www.periodproperty.co.uk/cgi-...rum2.pl?#43991 Now, whats going on: 1. Vic houses handled damp fine when they wre built, they were not pits of damp. So the basic design is good. 2. Since its damp now, it is what has been changed that has caused it. What has changed? 1. Airtight double glazing stops ventilation 2. Chimney blocked off 3. Maybe draught proofing elsewhere too 4. Gysum plaster and emulsion 5. Cement render and paint 6. shower installed All of these increase the damp levels in the walls, and some properties then begin to fail to deal satisfactorily with the damp. Contrary to your conclusions, the cause is indeed condensation. Why did the dehumidifier not cure it? Primarily because it has been going on for so long that the walls have become soaked, so that it will take many months to dry them out. Also there are other works that will need doing to fix it properly, eg the exterior render will be an ongoing problem. What else needs doing? The first thing to understand is you need to allow the wall to dry out, not trap all that water in it, which is what all your presently considered works are about. No to tanking No to rendering No to painting with water resistant paints No to a 3rd DPC (!!) (slate should last much longer than 130 years) Yes to: Humidistatic dehumidifier Lowering ground levels if theyre at or above the dpc Checking the drain channel drains properly Repoint all failed mortar with lime - but dont remove anything thats stuck hard. Removing all exterior render, and finishing by either cleaning the bricks up, or if theyre too much of a mess, lime render. Remove interior plaster and replaster with lime, painting with lime based paints, not emulsion. Checking ground water drains away from the house, not to the walls. And I would add ventilation to the house for your own health, though this is not necessary re damp until such time as you stop using the dehumidifier. Pay attention to major sources of damp within the house: Install dehumidifier in bathroom, or maybe a fan. And possibly enclose the shower so it doesnt produce as much steam in the room, if practical. And preferably install a cooker hood Understand some basic concepts with these houses: 1. More damp is produced inside by breathing, cooking and showering than comes from outside 2. Thus what is wanted is porosity, to allow the damp out, quite the opposite of sealing. 3. Damp proofing companies do work so they can get your money. 4. If dealt with appropriately, a Vic house with no dpc, no render, no waterprofing treatments etc can be dry and healthy. 5. Also be aware that a 9" wall will take a very long time to dry out, even with the above treatments done. BTW there is one gotcha: the bricks will be very soft, and the cement render hard, and it is _very_ easy to do serious brick damage when removing the render. Proceeed only with serious care on this point. The oracle has spoken! Your condensation theory is blown away when you consider that most of these houses get the same symptoms after a heavy shower in mid summer, when there are insufficient cold surfaces to cause condensation, and the windows are wide open. The idea that a house should allow the passage of any amount of water through the walls and wait for it to dry out is Dickensian, and faintly ridiculous in this day and age. It means houses would effectively be damp for at least 9 months of the year. What has changed to make Victorian properties leak like a sieve, when presumably they didn't originally, is IMO the degradation of the lime mortar. If that powder between the bricks in a 9" wall is all that's protecting you from the elements, then you need look no further. Replacing it with mud would be an improvement. |
#14
|
|||
|
|||
|
#15
|
|||
|
|||
In article ,
Martin wrote: More damp questions - apologies for boring anyone. The background - my living room has damp problems mainly on two walls - it rises up to within a foot of the coving. 1870s house solid walls. I've done all the usual checks. It's not condensation and there is evidence it's been a problem before. Ground level is below both the slate dpc and the silicon DPC. Room 25ft by 10ft. I assume this is a brick built house? If so, the very first thing to do is to check the pointing. And not just visually - for a long way round the effected area 'tap' it to see if it's loose. And I'll bet you'll find problems. Rake out and replace using a lime mortar. Don't be tempted to use a more common sand and cement mix - this will simply crack due to movement. Of course, also check for things like failed gutters allowing the wall to get soaked. Also, on an old house built in this way, if you've removed and sealed up all the fireplaces, and fitted double glazing, without adequate ventilation, and don't keep it warm, you'll get condensation. -- *I am a nobody, and nobody is perfect; therefore I am perfect* Dave Plowman London SW To e-mail, change noise into sound. |
#16
|
|||
|
|||
Martin wrote:
- If I plaster, what type(s) of plaster should I use? I would get someone in to do this. Don't use gypsum plaster on anything that's likely to get damp, incidentally. It will not last. |
#17
|
|||
|
|||
Chris Bacon wrote in message ...
Martin wrote: - If I plaster, what type(s) of plaster should I use? I would get someone in to do this. Don't use gypsum plaster on anything that's likely to get damp, incidentally. It will not last. Check pointing Is the floor dirt - my 1850s semi had carpet on tiles on sand/earth. so even though outside ground level was below the dpc the walls were still damp - this construction is ok but it's not designed to have carpet etc. on it, only bare tiles so that moisture can evaporate. Check ventilation of chimney etc. - are you drying washing inside? Has the house been unoccupied? I put in a small French drain - dug down about 9-12" on outside walls, and about 9" away from walls, and filled the trench with pea shingle, and put old slate floor tiles as a border - looks good. Whilst doing the French drain I also repaired the pointing underground, which was very bad around the bay window (lots of movement that made cracks and the lime mortar had fallen out), and cleaned all the caked on clay from the bricks (which may assist the wicking-up of water into the walls). Can't defiantely say but I think the French drain did quite a lot - it now means that damp wpould have to travel up an extra 12" before it gets inside. I also replaced the floor with an insulated dpc protected concrete floor - diy it and it's quite cheap, and a good workout. There is a side which says that rising damp is not a real problem and damp companies do nothing and are a waste of time. If you want to go down this route you can rent the solutions and pumps, drills etc. quite cheaply and do the whole thing in a weekend for about £100-150 (if you do this do rent/buy a good SDS drill and have a spare 10 mm bit). I'd try the simple things first pointing (above and below ground), French drain, ventilation, put heating on, open a window when drying washing etc. Good luck |
#18
|
|||
|
|||
|
#19
|
|||
|
|||
Any other suggestions? DIY tanking? I've another company paying me a visit on Monday - anyone care to take bets on their being a third different solution to the same problem? The best advice i received when we had our problems was from a painter and decorator, it was a medium sized company, the Boss came round,no reps, he said he sees it all the time, what did impress me was he didnt view it as a 'problem' it was just his job |
#21
|
|||
|
|||
(Martin) wrote in message om...
(nafuk) wrote in message . com... Chris Bacon wrote in message ... Martin wrote: - If I plaster, what type(s) of plaster should I use? I would get someone in to do this. Don't use gypsum plaster on anything that's likely to get damp, incidentally. It will not last. Check pointing Is the floor dirt - my 1850s semi had carpet on tiles on sand/earth. so even though outside ground level was below the dpc the walls were still damp - this construction is ok but it's not designed to have carpet etc. on it, only bare tiles so that moisture can evaporate. Check ventilation of chimney etc. - are you drying washing inside? Has the house been unoccupied? I put in a small French drain - dug down about 9-12" on outside walls, and about 9" away from walls, and filled the trench with pea shingle, and put old slate floor tiles as a border - looks good. Whilst doing the French drain I also repaired the pointing underground, which was very bad around the bay window (lots of movement that made cracks and the lime mortar had fallen out), and cleaned all the caked on clay from the bricks (which may assist the wicking-up of water into the walls). Can't defiantely say but I think the French drain did quite a lot - it now means that damp wpould have to travel up an extra 12" before it gets inside. I also replaced the floor with an insulated dpc protected concrete floor - diy it and it's quite cheap, and a good workout. There is a side which says that rising damp is not a real problem and damp companies do nothing and are a waste of time. If you want to go down this route you can rent the solutions and pumps, drills etc. quite cheaply and do the whole thing in a weekend for about £100-150 (if you do this do rent/buy a good SDS drill and have a spare 10 mm bit). I'd try the simple things first pointing (above and below ground), French drain, ventilation, put heating on, open a window when drying washing etc. Good luck Hi All, Apologies for the lack of reply. Computer packed up but at least that was cheap DIY fix!! Affected wall is painted and rendered. Below the silicon injections, the render does need repair. Still don't know if it's rising damp or penetrating damp. Floor is good with the correct membrane. There is also a draining channel against the wall - half full of shingle. At the moment, I'm getting quite cheesed off with this damp problem. Another company have just paid me a visit. Their recommendation is to tank the walls at a cost of £4k+. Now I'm really unsure of what to do. £4K+ seems *cough* excessive. DIY tanking?? The company's attitude was that on damp solid walls only tanking would fix it. So I assume he believes it's penetrating damp. However, he then went on about the temperature difference being greater which implies condensation so why should it need tanking? Hmmm... A few answers to previous questions... Q: Is the house occupied? A: Yep. For 15+ years Q: Are the gutters ok? A: Perfect. No leaks, no overflowing. They work fine. Q: Old house now sealed up causing condensation? A: Condensation is definetly not the issue. I ran a dehumidifer for 6 months+ and it made no difference. Plaster was still coming off the wall. Q: What sort of % humidity? A: No idea. Dehumidifer was running and walls were still damp. I don't do anything daft liking drying washing in the house. Q: Check ventilation? A: No obvious ventilation but dehumidifer made no diffence. Solid floor, no air bricks, no vents, no chimney. Strange for a house that used to be a Bakery but I've found no evidence of where a chimney used to be. Any other suggestions? DIY tanking? I've another company paying me a visit on Monday - anyone care to take bets on their being a third different solution to the same problem? Cheers, Martin. If the outside finish is waterproof (as opposed to water-repellant) then your walls can't dry from the outside. All they will eternally do is soak up moisture from the inside air by condensation, particularly if they are single thickness and always colder than the inside. How about stripping any waterproofing from the outside and relacing it with breathable water-repellant. M.K. |
#22
|
|||
|
|||
On 9 Apr 2005 07:57:05 -0700, (markzoom) wrote:
Like others I've had success with French drains. You could also make the inside of the wall breathable so the damp can evaporate into the room. Of course there is a limit to how much water can evaporate and if you have a stream erupting onto the wall, breathability is not going to help, though a French drain would Breathability - remove gypsum plaster, cement render and modern paints from the inside of the ?bricks?. Do not add any tanking, PVA etc. Replaster with lime plaster and paint with limewash. It can't do any harm, is cheap if you do it yourself and might do a lot of good Anna ~~ Anna Kettle, Suffolk, England |""""| ~ Lime plaster repairs / ^^ \ // Freehand modelling in lime: overmantels, pargeting etc |____| www.kettlenet.co.uk 01359 230642 |
#23
|
|||
|
|||
|
#24
|
|||
|
|||
Martin wrote :- Affected wall is painted and rendered. Below the silicon injections, the render does need repair. Still don't know if it's rising damp or penetrating damp. If the render extends below the dampproof membrane then it is bridging the membrane - it needs removing to above the membrane chemical injection is one thing but you also have to take care of the obvious ie make sure nothing can bridge the new DPC outside or inside - I had to remove render outside and have 7" skirting inside There is also a draining channel against the wall - half full of shingle. What exactly is this ? Regards Jeff |
#26
|
|||
|
|||
"Martin" wrote in message m... Affected wall is painted and rendered. Below the silicon injections, the render does need repair. Still don't know if it's rising damp or penetrating damp. Floor is good with the correct membrane. There is also a draining channel against the wall - half full of shingle. So which side of the membrane is this ? Also how old is the house ? Should there be a membrane at all ? In very old houses in a damp location you need the whole floor area to evaporate the moisture. It may be this membrane is pushing all the damp into the walls until they are saturated amd things start to fail. At the moment, I'm getting quite cheesed off with this damp problem. Where are you ? Another company have just paid me a visit. Their recommendation is to tank the walls at a cost of £4k+. Unless it's underground and you've no other way of removing the water I wouldn't. |
#27
|
|||
|
|||
If the outside is already rendered and painted, I'd try a pliolite based
solvent masonry paint. Johnstones do a a product called Stormguard, and most trade paint companies have equivalent brands. These are *vastly* superior to normal masonry paints and aren't that expensive. That should at least eliminate penetrating damp as the cause. Stone sills are also a major source of damp, however sound they look. Water often sits in puddles, and has time to soak into the brickwork and travel through the mortar. In a brick built house rising damp is probably the least likely source. -- I am using the free version of SPAMfighter for private users. It has removed 3144 spam emails to date. Paying users do not have this message in their emails. Try www.SPAMfighter.com for free now! |
Reply |
Thread Tools | Search this Thread |
Display Modes | |
|
|
Similar Threads | ||||
Thread | Forum | |||
Internal damp in stone built house in small room | UK diy | |||
uneven slightly damp sandstone slab floor - levelling compound/tiles/carpet? | UK diy | |||
Damp Chimney Breast | UK diy | |||
Victorian damp and chemical DPC failure | UK diy | |||
More damp testing woes | UK diy |