Plastic or Fabric?
Advice/opinions needed.

Central Minnesota in an area with known with damp/wet
basement problems (4 foot deep split level)

The stone landscaping and plastic has been removed, low
spots filled (not tamped) in with dirt and graded away from
the house with the intent to put the stone back around the
foundation. (about 4ft border)

Neighbor wants to use fabric instead of plastic because he
has "water bugs" and was told this was because the plastic
doesn't let the ground dry out, giving the bugs a place to live.

Will the use of fabric relieve the bug problem?
Will the use of fabric (when graded away from the house) be the
same/more/less effective at reducing the dampness than what could
be expected using plastic?

Thank you.

If you really want to fix the problem permanently, remove dirt 4 feet
down to the footer, put in perfurated drainage hose covered with sock
on the footer all around and downhill to a way out, waterproofing on
the 4 foot outside walls, fille 2 feet with gravel covered on all
sides with the fabric then 2 feet of dirt. Problem and bugs will be
gone forever.



"DaveW" wrote in message
news:RDzZa.115721$uu5.16818@sccrnsc04...
Plastic or Fabric?
Advice/opinions needed.

Central Minnesota in an area with known with damp/wet
basement problems (4 foot deep split level)

The stone landscaping and plastic has been removed, low
spots filled (not tamped) in with dirt and graded away from
the house with the intent to put the stone back around the
foundation. (about 4ft border)

Neighbor wants to use fabric instead of plastic because he
has "water bugs" and was told this was because the plastic
doesn't let the ground dry out, giving the bugs a place to live.

Will the use of fabric relieve the bug problem?
Will the use of fabric (when graded away from the house) be the
same/more/less effective at reducing the dampness than what could
be expected using plastic?

Thank you.

It no doubt would be a better solution but not an option at this time.
Only want to know if using the fabric will create more problems
than what it solves, or if it would be better than using plastic.

I have my opinion on the matter and just want to see who is "all wet".
Thank you.

"Art Begun" wrote in message
ink.net...
If you really want to fix the problem permanently, remove dirt 4 feet
down to the footer, put in perfurated drainage hose covered with sock
on the footer all around and downhill to a way out, waterproofing on
the 4 foot outside walls, fille 2 feet with gravel covered on all
sides with the fabric then 2 feet of dirt. Problem and bugs will be
gone forever.



"DaveW" wrote in message
news:RDzZa.115721$uu5.16818@sccrnsc04...
Plastic or Fabric?
Advice/opinions needed.

Central Minnesota in an area with known with damp/wet
basement problems (4 foot deep split level)

The stone landscaping and plastic has been removed, low
spots filled (not tamped) in with dirt and graded away from
the house with the intent to put the stone back around the
foundation. (about 4ft border)

Neighbor wants to use fabric instead of plastic because he
has "water bugs" and was told this was because the plastic
doesn't let the ground dry out, giving the bugs a place to live.

Will the use of fabric relieve the bug problem?
Will the use of fabric (when graded away from the house) be the
same/more/less effective at reducing the dampness than what could
be expected using plastic?

Thank you.

Could use both if you are digging a little. Use plastic as the lower
layer a foot or 2 down and fabric toward the top.


"DaveW" wrote in message
news:l5EZa.117528$uu5.17474@sccrnsc04...
It no doubt would be a better solution but not an option at this
time.
Only want to know if using the fabric will create more problems
than what it solves, or if it would be better than using plastic.

I have my opinion on the matter and just want to see who is "all
wet".
Thank you.

"Art Begun" wrote in message
ink.net...
If you really want to fix the problem permanently, remove dirt 4
feet
down to the footer, put in perfurated drainage hose covered with
sock
on the footer all around and downhill to a way out, waterproofing
on
the 4 foot outside walls, fille 2 feet with gravel covered on all
sides with the fabric then 2 feet of dirt. Problem and bugs will
be
gone forever.



"DaveW" wrote in message
news:RDzZa.115721$uu5.16818@sccrnsc04...
Plastic or Fabric?
Advice/opinions needed.

Central Minnesota in an area with known with damp/wet
basement problems (4 foot deep split level)

The stone landscaping and plastic has been removed, low
spots filled (not tamped) in with dirt and graded away from
the house with the intent to put the stone back around the
foundation. (about 4ft border)

Neighbor wants to use fabric instead of plastic because he
has "water bugs" and was told this was because the plastic
doesn't let the ground dry out, giving the bugs a place to live.

Will the use of fabric relieve the bug problem?
Will the use of fabric (when graded away from the house) be the
same/more/less effective at reducing the dampness than what
could
be expected using plastic?

Thank you.