Home |
Search |
Today's Posts |
|
Home Repair (alt.home.repair) For all homeowners and DIYers with many experienced tradesmen. Solve your toughest home fix-it problems. |
Reply |
|
LinkBack | Thread Tools | Display Modes |
#1
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
Bathroom GFCI with no ground?
Jay-T wrote:
I want to replace an existing 2-prong receptacle in a bathroom with a GFCI receptacle. There is no ground wire going to the existing receptacle and no grounded metal cable or grounded metal outlet box -- just two separate wires, one white and one black. There is also no practical way to run a new ground wire back to the service. In this situation, is it okay to go ahead and install the GFCI receptacle and put the sticker on it that says "No Equipment Ground"? Yes P.S. I "could" run a ground wire from the GFCI receptacle to a cold water pipe and make sure that there is a jumper across the hot water tank in and out pipes and across the water meter. But, I think I read somewhere about that being a bad idea (using the cold water pipe for a ground). That is a bad idea, right? Used to be code compliant up to about 10 years ago. It isn't now since existing metal in the path back to the system ground can be replaced by plastic in the future. -- bud-- |
#2
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
Bathroom GFCI with no ground?
I want to replace an existing 2-prong receptacle in a bathroom with a GFCI
receptacle. There is no ground wire going to the existing receptacle and no grounded metal cable or grounded metal outlet box -- just two separate wires, one white and one black. There is also no practical way to run a new ground wire back to the service. In this situation, is it okay to go ahead and install the GFCI receptacle and put the sticker on it that says "No Equipment Ground"? UP.SO. I "could" run a ground wire from the GFCI receptacle to a cold water pipe and make sure that there is a jumper across the hot water tank in and out pipes and across the water meter. But, I think I read somewhere about that being a bad idea (using the cold water pipe for a ground). That is a bad idea, right? |
#3
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
Bathroom GFCI with no ground?
Oops, "UP.SO." should be "P.S." in my original post.
Jay-T wrote: I want to replace an existing 2-prong receptacle in a bathroom with a GFCI receptacle. There is no ground wire going to the existing receptacle and no grounded metal cable or grounded metal outlet box -- just two separate wires, one white and one black. There is also no practical way to run a new ground wire back to the service. In this situation, is it okay to go ahead and install the GFCI receptacle and put the sticker on it that says "No Equipment Ground"? UP.SO. I "could" run a ground wire from the GFCI receptacle to a cold water pipe and make sure that there is a jumper across the hot water tank in and out pipes and across the water meter. But, I think I read somewhere about that being a bad idea (using the cold water pipe for a ground). That is a bad idea, right? |
#4
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
Bathroom GFCI with no ground?
On Feb 3, 10:06*am, "Jay-T" wrote:
I want to replace an existing 2-prong receptacle in a bathroom with a GFCI receptacle. *There is no ground wire going to the existing receptacle and no grounded metal cable or grounded metal outlet box -- just two separate wires, one white and one black. *There is also no practical way to run a new ground wire back to the service. In this situation, is it okay to go ahead and install the GFCI receptacle and put the sticker on it that says "No Equipment Ground"? UP.SO. *I "could" run a ground wire from the GFCI receptacle to a cold water pipe and make sure that there is a jumper across the hot water tank in and out pipes and across the water meter. *But, I think I read somewhere about that being a bad idea (using the cold water pipe for a ground). *That is a bad idea, right? Yes, it's OK to install a GFCI with no ground and mark it as such. Since it's OK to install a GFCI with no ground, there's no need to answer your second question. UP.SO. BTW...It's a bad idea. |
#5
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
Bathroom GFCI with no ground?
On Feb 3, 1:05*am, bud-- wrote:
Jay-T wrote: I want to replace an existing 2-prong receptacle in a bathroom with a GFCI receptacle. *There is no ground wire going to the existing receptacle and no grounded metal cable or grounded metal outlet box -- just two separate wires, one white and one black. *There is also no practical way to run a new ground wire back to the service. In this situation, is it okay to go ahead and install the GFCI receptacle and put the sticker on it that says "No Equipment Ground"? Yes P.S. *I "could" run a ground wire from the GFCI receptacle to a cold water pipe and make sure that there is a jumper across the hot water tank in and out pipes and across the water meter. *But, I think I read somewhere about that being a bad idea (using the cold water pipe for a ground). *That is a bad idea, right? Used to be code compliant up to about 10 years ago. It isn't now since existing metal in the path back to the system ground can be replaced by plastic in the future. -- bud-- Use GFCI because it operates on the 'difference' in current between live and neutral. If someone did get a contact or drop the hair dryer in the wet metal bath tub any conseuent current likely to trip the GFCI safely. |
#6
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
Bathroom GFCI with no ground?
Use GFCI because it operates on the 'difference' in current between live and neutral. If someone did get a contact or drop the hair dryer in the wet metal bath tub any conseuent current likely to trip the GFCI safely.- - agreed, but will the TEST button still work without a ground? Mark |
#7
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
Bathroom GFCI with no ground?
On 2010-02-03, Mark wrote:
agreed, but will the TEST button still work without a ground? Yes, as I understand it (I haven't tried it). I believe the TEST button in the receptacle allows a small current to pass from the LINE side hot to the LOAD side hot around the current transformer, thereby creating the imbalance that should trip the GFCI. In contrast a plug-in tester will not work, as it relies on the ground connection. Cheers, Wayne |
#8
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
Bathroom GFCI with no ground?
On Feb 3, 3:29*pm, Mark wrote:
Use GFCI because it operates on the 'difference' in current between live and neutral. If someone did get a contact or drop the hair dryer in the wet metal bath tub any conseuent current likely to trip the GFCI safely.- - agreed, but will the TEST button still work without a ground? Mark Yes. The test button does not send any current to ground so no ground is required for it to work. |
#9
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
Bathroom GFCI with no ground?
bud-- wrote:
P.S. I "could" run a ground wire from the GFCI receptacle to a cold water pipe and make sure that there is a jumper across the hot water tank in and out pipes and across the water meter. But, I think I read somewhere about that being a bad idea (using the cold water pipe for a ground). That is a bad idea, right? Used to be code compliant up to about 10 years ago. It isn't now since existing metal in the path back to the system ground can be replaced by plastic in the future. That's interesting. Thanks. I never would have thought of that -- the PEX or plastic replacement in the future. |
#10
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
Bathroom GFCI with no ground?
DerbyDad03 wrote:
On Feb 3, 3:29 pm, Mark wrote: Use GFCI because it operates on the 'difference' in current between live and neutral. If someone did get a contact or drop the hair dryer in the wet metal bath tub any conseuent current likely to trip the GFCI safely.- - agreed, but will the TEST button still work without a ground? Mark Yes. The test button does not send any current to ground so no ground is required for it to work. Thanks. I wondered about that too. Looks like I won't have a problem going ahead with the GFCI even though there is no ground. |
#11
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
Bathroom GFCI with no ground?
On Feb 3, 4:13*pm, "Jay-T" wrote:
DerbyDad03 wrote: On Feb 3, 3:29 pm, Mark wrote: Use GFCI because it operates on the 'difference' in current between live and neutral. If someone did get a contact or drop the hair dryer in the wet metal bath tub any conseuent current likely to trip the GFCI safely.- - agreed, but will the TEST button still work without a ground? Mark Yes. The test button does not send any current to ground so no ground is required for it to work. Thanks. *I wondered about that too. Looks like I won't have a problem going ahead with the GFCI even though there is no ground.- Hide quoted text - - Show quoted text - BTW...not only is it OK to (and you should) replace the ungrounded bathroom receptacle with a GFCI, it is also code compliant to replace any 2 prong, ungrounded receptacle with a 3 pronged receptacle as long as that receptacle is protected by a GFCI and marked as having No Equipment Ground. For example, if you have a circuit full of daisy chained 2 pronged, ungrounded receptacles, replace the first one in the circuit with a GFCI and wire all the downstream 3 prong, yet still ungrounded receptacles off of the load side. It's a fairly common practice and allows for the use of three pronged cords in "older" homes. |
#12
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
Bathroom GFCI with no ground?
On Wed, 3 Feb 2010 20:35:57 +0000 (UTC), Wayne Whitney wrote:
On 2010-02-03, Mark wrote: agreed, but will the TEST button still work without a ground? Yes, as I understand it (I haven't tried it). I believe the TEST button in the receptacle allows a small current to pass from the LINE side hot to the LOAD side hot around the current transformer, thereby creating the imbalance that should trip the GFCI. In contrast a plug-in tester will not work, as it relies on the ground connection. Cheers, Wayne And without a ground the GFI may not work properly. |
#13
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
Bathroom GFCI with no ground?
On Feb 3, 7:27*pm, Michael Dobony wrote:
On Wed, 3 Feb 2010 20:35:57 +0000 (UTC), Wayne Whitney wrote: On 2010-02-03, Mark wrote: agreed, but will the TEST button still work without a ground? Yes, as I understand it (I haven't tried it). *I believe the TEST button in the receptacle allows a small current to pass from the LINE side hot to the LOAD side hot around the current transformer, thereby creating the imbalance that should trip the GFCI. *In contrast a plug-in tester will not work, as it relies on the ground connection. Cheers, Wayne And without a ground the GFI may not work properly. Please explain. |
#14
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
Bathroom GFCI with no ground?
In ,
Michael Dobony typed: On Wed, 3 Feb 2010 20:35:57 +0000 (UTC), Wayne Whitney wrote: On 2010-02-03, Mark wrote: agreed, but will the TEST button still work without a ground? Yes, as I understand it (I haven't tried it). I believe the TEST button in the receptacle allows a small current to pass from the LINE side hot to the LOAD side hot around the current transformer, thereby creating the imbalance that should trip the GFCI. In contrast a plug-in tester will not work, as it relies on the ground connection. Cheers, Wayne And without a ground the GFI may not work properly. A GFCI will indeed work properly and to specs without a ground. Go read how they work and why/when they trip. Every box and most sites tell you what to do when there is no third wire. The OP had it right. Earth is NOT used in the operation of the GFCI. http://www.doityourself.com/stry/gfci http://wiki.answers.com/Q/How_does_t...ular_appliance or if you're Canadian http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Residual-current_device Google is full of good information HTH, Twayne HTH, Twayne -- -- Newsgroups are great places to get assistance. But always verify important information with other sources to be certain you have a clear understanding of it and that it is accurate. |
#15
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
Bathroom GFCI with no ground?
In ,
DerbyDad03 typed: On Feb 3, 3:29 pm, Mark wrote: Use GFCI because it operates on the 'difference' in current between live and neutral. If someone did get a contact or drop the hair dryer in the wet metal bath tub any conseuent current likely to trip the GFCI safely.- - agreed, but will the TEST button still work without a ground? Mark Yes. The test button does not send any current to ground so no ground is required for it to work. That's correct. The "ground" in the name is NOT meaning current inside the device going to ground; it means power finding an improper path to ground, in general. HTH, Twayne -- -- Newsgroups are great places to get assistance. But always verify important information with other sources to be certain you have a clear understanding of it and that it is accurate. |
#16
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
Bathroom GFCI with no ground?
In ,
Jay-T typed: DerbyDad03 wrote: On Feb 3, 3:29 pm, Mark wrote: Use GFCI because it operates on the 'difference' in current between live and neutral. If someone did get a contact or drop the hair dryer in the wet metal bath tub any conseuent current likely to trip the GFCI safely.- - agreed, but will the TEST button still work without a ground? Mark Yes. The test button does not send any current to ground so no ground is required for it to work. Thanks. I wondered about that too. Looks like I won't have a problem going ahead with the GFCI even though there is no ground. You will be fine. If in doubt, look it up on Google or better yet, read the box sides in the store; the information is usually right on the outside of the containers. HTH, Twayne -- -- Newsgroups are great places to get assistance. But always verify important information with other sources to be certain you have a clear understanding of it and that it is accurate. |
#17
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
Bathroom GFCI with no ground?
In ,
DerbyDad03 typed: On Feb 3, 4:13 pm, "Jay-T" wrote: DerbyDad03 wrote: On Feb 3, 3:29 pm, Mark wrote: Use GFCI because it operates on the 'difference' in current between live and neutral. If someone did get a contact or drop the hair dryer in the wet metal bath tub any conseuent current likely to trip the GFCI safely.- - agreed, but will the TEST button still work without a ground? Mark Yes. The test button does not send any current to ground so no ground is required for it to work. Thanks. I wondered about that too. Looks like I won't have a problem going ahead with the GFCI even though there is no ground.- Hide quoted text - - Show quoted text - BTW...not only is it OK to (and you should) replace the ungrounded bathroom receptacle with a GFCI, it is also code compliant to replace any 2 prong, ungrounded receptacle with a 3 pronged receptacle as long as that receptacle is protected by a GFCI and marked as having No Equipment Ground. For example, if you have a circuit full of daisy chained 2 pronged, ungrounded receptacles, replace the first one in the circuit with a GFCI and wire all the downstream 3 prong, yet still ungrounded receptacles off of the load side. It's a fairly common practice and allows for the use of three pronged cords in "older" homes. NO, it does NOT "allow" use of 3-wire equipment!! If a 3-wire piece of equipment is plugged into an outlet, the earth ground in that case DOES need to be present. THAT is why the outlets must be labeled as having NO ground! It's to prevent just that kind of accident waiting to happen. HTH, Twayne -- -- Newsgroups are great places to get assistance. But always verify important information with other sources to be certain you have a clear understanding of it and that it is accurate. |
#18
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
Bathroom GFCI with no ground?
On Feb 3, 8:39*pm, "Twayne" wrote:
, DerbyDad03 typed: On Feb 3, 4:13 pm, "Jay-T" wrote: DerbyDad03 wrote: On Feb 3, 3:29 pm, Mark wrote: Use GFCI because it operates on the 'difference' in current between live and neutral. If someone did get a contact or drop the hair dryer in the wet metal bath tub any conseuent current likely to trip the GFCI safely.- - agreed, but will the TEST button still work without a ground? Mark Yes. The test button does not send any current to ground so no ground is required for it to work. Thanks. I wondered about that too. Looks like I won't have a problem going ahead with the GFCI even though there is no ground.- Hide quoted text - - Show quoted text - BTW...not only is it OK to (and you should) replace the ungrounded bathroom receptacle with a GFCI, it is also code compliant to replace any 2 prong, ungrounded receptacle with a 3 pronged receptacle as long as that receptacle is protected by a GFCI and marked as having No Equipment Ground. For example, if you have a circuit full of daisy chained 2 pronged, ungrounded receptacles, replace the first one in the circuit with a GFCI and wire all the downstream 3 prong, yet still ungrounded receptacles off of the load side. It's a fairly common practice and allows for the use of three pronged cords in "older" homes. NO, it does NOT "allow" use of 3-wire equipment!! *If a 3-wire piece of equipment is plugged into an outlet, the earth ground in that case DOES need to be present. THAT is why the outlets must be labeled as having NO ground! It's to prevent just that kind of accident waiting to happen. HTH, Twayne -- -- Newsgroups are great places to get assistance. But always verify important information with other sources to be certain you have a clear understanding of it and that it is accurate. Perhaps we need some clarification here. We are talking about people protection only. We're not discussing whether the absence of a ground will be a detriment to the operation of the equipment. It is my understanding that the GFCI will protect the user should there be current leakage to ground within the device. If there is any type of short to ground within the device then there will be a differential between the current on the hot and the current on neutral and the GFCI will trip and the user will be protected. Why else would the NEC allow for the use of a 3 prong outlet on an ungrounded circuit if they didn't expect you plug a 3 prong cord into it? You'll note that code says it must be labeled as No Equipment Ground, not simply No Ground. For the safety of us all, I won't mind if you correct me. |
#19
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
Bathroom GFCI with no ground?
Mark wrote: but will the TEST button still work without a ground? Yes, since the test circuit is internal to the GFCI and includes an approximately 15,000 ohm resistor that connects between the device's hot and ground leads when the TEST button is pressed. GFCIs pass the hot and neutral AC lines through the center of a transformer coil. Normally the currents in the wires are equal and opposite, resulting in no current flow in the secondary of this transformer, but when a ground fault occurs, the wires will not carry equal current, and that's why GFCI operation does not require a ground connection. In fact GFCIs are required to provide protection even without that ground. |
#20
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
Bathroom GFCI with no ground?
Wayne Whitney wrote: On 2010-02-03, Mark wrote: agreed, but will the TEST button still work without a ground? Yes, as I understand it (I haven't tried it). I believe the TEST button in the receptacle allows a small current to pass from the LINE side hot to the LOAD side hot around the current transformer, thereby creating the imbalance that should trip the GFCI. In contrast a plug-in tester will not work, as it relies on the ground connection. The test button merely connects the hot to the GFCI's ground reference, so no earth ground is needed to test operation. But a plug- in GFCI tester will work, whether or not the GFCI is earthed. Here's National's document for their old LM1851 GFCI chip: www.national.com/ds/LM/LM1851.pdf |
#21
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
Bathroom GFCI with no ground?
Michael Dobony wrote: And without a ground the GFI may not work properly. Absolute nonsense, as GFIs measure only the imbalance of currents in the hot and neutral lines that pass through their current sensing transformers. No GFI can require an earth ground for proper operation and still meet UL standards. |
#23
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
Bathroom GFCI with no ground?
DerbyDad03 wrote:
On Feb 3, 8:39 pm, "Twayne" wrote: , DerbyDad03 typed: On Feb 3, 4:13 pm, "Jay-T" wrote: DerbyDad03 wrote: On Feb 3, 3:29 pm, Mark wrote: Use GFCI because it operates on the 'difference' in current between live and neutral. If someone did get a contact or drop the hair dryer in the wet metal bath tub any conseuent current likely to trip the GFCI safely.- BTW...not only is it OK to (and you should) replace the ungrounded bathroom receptacle with a GFCI, it is also code compliant to replace any 2 prong, ungrounded receptacle with a 3 pronged receptacle as long as that receptacle is protected by a GFCI and marked as having No Equipment Ground. Downstream outlets are also tagged "GFCI protected". Avoid connecting the outlet grounds together on downstream grounded outlets where a ground is not present. For example, if you have a circuit full of daisy chained 2 pronged, ungrounded receptacles, replace the first one in the circuit with a GFCI and wire all the downstream 3 prong, yet still ungrounded receptacles off of the load side. It's a fairly common practice and allows for the use of three pronged cords in "older" homes. NO, it does NOT "allow" use of 3-wire equipment!! If a 3-wire piece of equipment is plugged into an outlet, the earth ground in that case DOES need to be present. THAT is why the outlets must be labeled as having NO ground! It's to prevent just that kind of accident waiting to happen. HTH, Twayne Perhaps we need some clarification here. We are talking about people protection only. We're not discussing whether the absence of a ground will be a detriment to the operation of the equipment. It is my understanding that the GFCI will protect the user should there be current leakage to ground within the device. If there is any type of short to ground within the device then there will be a differential between the current on the hot and the current on neutral and the GFCI will trip and the user will be protected. Why else would the NEC allow for the use of a 3 prong outlet on an ungrounded circuit if they didn't expect you plug a 3 prong cord into it? Seems like that should have been obvious to Twayne. If 3 wire plugs were not allowed the NEC would require a 2 wire GFCI outlet - which it doesn't. The NEC explicitly allows 'grounded outlet' GFCIs on 2 wire circuits, and as you said above, allows the GFCI to protect conventional grounded receptacles downstream. -- bud-- You'll note that code says it must be labeled as No Equipment Ground, not simply No Ground. For the safety of us all, I won't mind if you correct me. |
#24
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
Bathroom GFCI with no ground?
Jay-T wrote:
bud-- wrote: P.S. I "could" run a ground wire from the GFCI receptacle to a cold water pipe and make sure that there is a jumper across the hot water tank in and out pipes and across the water meter. But, I think I read somewhere about that being a bad idea (using the cold water pipe for a ground). That is a bad idea, right? Used to be code compliant up to about 10 years ago. It isn't now since existing metal in the path back to the system ground can be replaced by plastic in the future. That's interesting. Thanks. I never would have thought of that -- the PEX or plastic replacement in the future. Its them PEX fanatics on this newsgroup that have ruined it for the rest of us. -- bud-- |
#25
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
Bathroom GFCI with no ground?
On 2010-02-04, DerbyDad03 wrote:
Why else would the NEC allow for the use of a 3 prong outlet on an ungrounded circuit if they didn't expect you plug a 3 prong cord into it? Well, 406.3(B) of the 2008 NEC states: "Receptacles and cord connectors that have equipment grounding conductor contacts shall have those contacts connected to an equipment grounding conductor". And 406.3(D), the section that deals with using GFCIs on circuits without equipment ground, does not appear to override 406.3(B). So I agree the situation is confusing and the intent is not clear. Cheers, Wayne |
#26
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
Bathroom GFCI with no ground?
On Feb 4, 12:17*pm, Wayne Whitney wrote:
On 2010-02-04, DerbyDad03 wrote: Why else would the NEC allow for the use of a 3 prong outlet on an ungrounded circuit if they didn't expect you plug a 3 prong cord into it? Well, 406.3(B) of the 2008 NEC states: "Receptacles and cord connectors that have equipment grounding conductor contacts shall have those contacts connected to an equipment grounding conductor". *And 406.3(D), the section that deals with using GFCIs on circuits without equipment ground, does not appear to override 406.3(B). *So I agree the situation is confusing and the intent is not clear. Cheers, Wayne Set Lawyer-Speak Mode = True A 3 prong plug is typically connected to a cord which has an equipment grounding conductor within, therefore the "cord connector" portion of 406.3(B) is satisfied. Once this cord is plugged into a 3 prong receptacle, the receptacle's equipment grounding conductor contact will be connected to the cord's equipment grounding conductor, this satisfiying the receptacle portion of 406.3(B). Prior to the insertion of the plug, the grounding hole in the receptacle is nothing more than an extra hole since it's not attached to anything. If it's not attached to an equipment grounding conductor, it isn't a equipment grounding conductor contact because the code says it isn't. Set Lawyer-Speak Mode = False That clears it up, now, doesn't it? |
#27
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
Bathroom GFCI with no ground?
Wayne Whitney wrote:
On 2010-02-04, DerbyDad03 wrote: Why else would the NEC allow for the use of a 3 prong outlet on an ungrounded circuit if they didn't expect you plug a 3 prong cord into it? Well, 406.3(B) of the 2008 NEC states: "Receptacles and cord connectors that have equipment grounding conductor contacts shall have those contacts connected to an equipment grounding conductor". 406.3-B "...shall have those contacts connected to an equipment grounding conductor." "Exception No. 2: Replacement receptacles as permitted by 406.3-D" 406.3-D replacement of receptacles shall comply with D-1,2,and 3 as applicable 406.3-D-3 "Non-Grounding Type Receptacles. Where attachment to an equipment grounding conductor does not exist in the receptacle enclosure, the installation shall comply with D-3-a, D-3-b, or D-3-c." 406.3-D-3-b allows GFCIs to be used. The GFCI ground terminal is not allowed to be extended to downstream receptacles 406.3-D-3 allows grounding receptacles to be used where downstream from a GFCI. A ground is not allowed to be connected between the receptacles. And 406.3(D), the section that deals with using GFCIs on circuits without equipment ground, does not appear to override 406.3(B). They do not conflict. So I agree the situation is confusing and the intent is not clear. The intent is clear. (A rare miss.) -- bud-- |
#28
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
Bathroom GFCI with no ground?
On 2010-02-04, bud-- wrote:
"Exception No. 2: Replacement receptacles as permitted by 406.3-D" Whoops, I completely missed that. Thanks for the catch. Cheers, Wayne |
#29
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
Bathroom GFCI with no ground?
bud-- wrote: wrote: Wayne Whitney wrote: On 2010-02-03, Mark wrote: The test button merely connects the hot to the GFCI's ground reference, so no earth ground is needed to test operation. Nope. The GFCI outlet circuit makes no connection to "ground". The test button connects a resistor from the hot wire ahead of the current transformer to the neutral downstream from the current transformer (or vice versa) resulting in a current through the transformer only on the neutral wire. But a plug-in GFCI tester will work, whether or not the GFCI is earthed. A plug-in tester connects a resistor from hot to ground. Since ground is not connected to anything a plug-in tester will not work. But I've tried it with a Hubbel (Shock Shield 3-outlet) plug-in GFI with its ground prong retracted and a Sears branded Leviton wall outlet GFI connected to the AC through a 2-wire cheater cord. I believe both used General Instruments GFI chips. |
#30
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
Bathroom GFCI with no ground?
In ,
DerbyDad03 typed: On Feb 3, 8:39 pm, "Twayne" wrote: , DerbyDad03 typed: On Feb 3, 4:13 pm, "Jay-T" wrote: DerbyDad03 wrote: On Feb 3, 3:29 pm, Mark wrote: Use GFCI because it operates on the 'difference' in current between live and neutral. If someone did get a contact or drop the hair dryer in the wet metal bath tub any conseuent current likely to trip the GFCI safely.- - agreed, but will the TEST button still work without a ground? Mark Yes. The test button does not send any current to ground so no ground is required for it to work. Thanks. I wondered about that too. Looks like I won't have a problem going ahead with the GFCI even though there is no ground.- Hide quoted text - - Show quoted text - BTW...not only is it OK to (and you should) replace the ungrounded bathroom receptacle with a GFCI, it is also code compliant to replace any 2 prong, ungrounded receptacle with a 3 pronged receptacle as long as that receptacle is protected by a GFCI and marked as having No Equipment Ground. For example, if you have a circuit full of daisy chained 2 pronged, ungrounded receptacles, replace the first one in the circuit with a GFCI and wire all the downstream 3 prong, yet still ungrounded receptacles off of the load side. It's a fairly common practice and allows for the use of three pronged cords in "older" homes. NO, it does NOT "allow" use of 3-wire equipment!! If a 3-wire piece of equipment is plugged into an outlet, the earth ground in that case DOES need to be present. THAT is why the outlets must be labeled as having NO ground! It's to prevent just that kind of accident waiting to happen. HTH, Twayne -- -- Newsgroups are great places to get assistance. But always verify important information with other sources to be certain you have a clear understanding of it and that it is accurate. Perhaps we need some clarification here. OK; since we're clarifying, lets be a tad more accuate. I only add this for clarification, no other reason. Many homes have a mix of such 2 and 3 wire installations and it's easy to misunderstand some things. We are talking about people protection only. We're not discussing whether the absence of a ground will be a detriment to the operation of the equipment. A GFCI is for "safety", not people. Kind of minor on the surface, but important in the altogether. Also, lack of a ground for equipment that needs it -could- lead to lethal shock situations where under a single fault condition it could lead to anything from shock to fire. It is my understanding that the GFCI will protect the user should there be current leakage to ground within the device. Well, not from "within the device" but from any point in the entire circuit on the Load side of the GFCI; wire, connections, equipments, etc.. Sufficient leakage anywhere will trip the GFCI. It simply measures and compares hot/neutral current, as you said. If there is any type of short to ground within the device then there will be a differential between the current on the hot and the current on neutral and the GFCI will trip and the user will be protected. If there is anything anywhere, not just within the device, that causes a differential, the gfci will trip. Why else would the NEC allow for the use of a 3 prong outlet on an ungrounded circuit if they didn't expect you plug a 3 prong cord into it? NEC definitely recommends AGAINST doing so, and requires the markings. In addition, NEC is not the final word; NEC is only minimum requirements. The local Code Enforcement Office will have the final say on whether a 3-prong outlet can be used without an earth ground connection. Here such 2-wire methods with 3-wire outlets etc. are specifically verboten in the kitchen, bathroom and outbuildings. Many people forget that it's the local codes that must be satisfied; the NEC may be but one component of the electrical requirements. The NEC/local codes would reall only come into the picture if it was new work. e.g. when I added a ckt, all they checked was the ckt, and nothing in the rest of the house. Some localities however insist that if you touch the wiring at all the whole building has to be brought up to code. It varies all over the map. You'll note that code says it must be labeled as No Equipment Ground, not simply No Ground. For the safety of us all, I won't mind if you correct me. Nah, no serious corrections were needed. Just had time to do a little further clarification, so did. Regards, Twayne` -- Newsgroups are great places to get assistance. But always verify important information with other sources to be certain you have a clear understanding of it and that it is accurate. |
#31
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
Bathroom GFCI with no ground?
Twayne wrote:
In , DerbyDad03 typed: Perhaps we need some clarification here. OK; since we're clarifying, lets be a tad more accuate. I only add this for clarification, no other reason. Many homes have a mix of such 2 and 3 wire installations and it's easy to misunderstand some things. We are talking about people protection only. We're not discussing whether the absence of a ground will be a detriment to the operation of the equipment. A GFCI is for "safety", not people. Whatever that means. The 5mA trip level on a GFCI is for people. Some other GFIs (including most AFCIs) trip on a ground fault of 30mA. That is for the protection of equipment or fire. Kind of minor on the surface, but important in the altogether. Also, lack of a ground for equipment that needs it -could- lead to lethal shock situations where under a single fault condition it could lead to anything from shock to fire. That, of curse, is what the GFCI is for. It is my understanding that the GFCI will protect the user should there be current leakage to ground within the device. Well, not from "within the device" but from any point in the entire circuit on the Load side of the GFCI; wire, connections, equipments, etc.. Sufficient leakage anywhere will trip the GFCI. It simply measures and compares hot/neutral current, as you said. If there is any type of short to ground within the device then there will be a differential between the current on the hot and the current on neutral and the GFCI will trip and the user will be protected. If there is anything anywhere, not just within the device, that causes a differential, the gfci will trip. Why else would the NEC allow for the use of a 3 prong outlet on an ungrounded circuit if they didn't expect you plug a 3 prong cord into it? NEC definitely recommends AGAINST doing so, Cite. and requires the markings. In addition, NEC is not the final word; NEC is only minimum requirements. The local Code Enforcement Office will have the final say on whether a 3-prong outlet can be used without an earth ground connection. Here such 2-wire methods with 3-wire outlets etc. are specifically verboten in the kitchen, bathroom and outbuildings. Many people forget that it's the local codes that must be satisfied; the NEC may be but one component of the electrical requirements. The NEC/local codes would reall only come into the picture if it was new work. e.g. when I added a ckt, all they checked was the ckt, and nothing in the rest of the house. Some localities however insist that if you touch the wiring at all the whole building has to be brought up to code. Where. There would be no electrical changes in those locations - extremely counterproductive. It varies all over the map. You'll note that code says it must be labeled as No Equipment Ground, not simply No Ground. For the safety of us all, I won't mind if you correct me. Nah, no serious corrections were needed. Just had time to do a little further clarification, so did. You forgot to clarify that your previous post was wrong and Derby was right. -- bud-- |
Reply |
Thread Tools | Search this Thread |
Display Modes | |
|
|
Similar Threads | ||||
Thread | Forum | |||
UK equivalent of a GFCI (Ground Fault Circuit Interrupter)? | UK diy | |||
Bathroom fan trips GFCI which doesn't protect it | Home Repair | |||
Ungrounded GFCI with ground jumpered to neutral | Home Repair | |||
bathroom and washing machine GFCI question | Home Repair | |||
Adding GFCI to Bathroom, Older House | Home Ownership |