Home |
Search |
Today's Posts |
|
Home Repair (alt.home.repair) For all homeowners and DIYers with many experienced tradesmen. Solve your toughest home fix-it problems. |
Reply |
|
LinkBack | Thread Tools | Display Modes |
|
#1
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
new HVAC not cooling
We recently had a contractor install a new unit (a Bryant Puron 2.5
ton in a 1500sq/ft 3br/2ba home) a couple of months ago. This week we've had some really warm weather with temperatures in the 90s nearing 100 degrees. The problem is the unit is not cooling the house. The unit runs all day and doesn't drop the temperature below 78 degrees. Our older unit never had this problem. We called the contractor that installed the unit out and he said that was normal. He told us that these units won't cool more than 20 degrees below the ambient air temperature. He also said that the fact that our ducts are in the celing makes this problem worse. Something doesn't sound right here. I mean, our old unit cooled the house fine and that unit was smaller (2 ton). What's going on here? Is he correct, ignorant or simply lying? Can you guys educate me on this? Should this unit be capable of cooling the house better than it's doing now? |
#2
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
new HVAC not cooling
On Jun 9, 5:11 pm, wrote:
We recently had a contractor install a new unit (a Bryant Puron 2.5 ton in a 1500sq/ft 3br/2ba home) a couple of months ago. This week we've had some really warm weather with temperatures in the 90s nearing 100 degrees. The problem is the unit is not cooling the house. The unit runs all day and doesn't drop the temperature below 78 degrees. Our older unit never had this problem. We called the contractor that installed the unit out and he said that was normal. He told us that these units won't cool more than 20 degrees below the ambient air temperature. He also said that the fact that our ducts are in the celing makes this problem worse. Something doesn't sound right here. I mean, our old unit cooled the house fine and that unit was smaller (2 ton). What's going on here? Is he correct, ignorant or simply lying? Can you guys educate me on this? Should this unit be capable of cooling the house better than it's doing now? Not expert here, but it sounds like the guy is trying to swat you away, at least for awhile. Exactly how 'cool' does the new unit actually get the house now, vs what your old one got it to? I would wait for some good feedback here and get your ducks in a row before you pressure the AC guy too much more. That way you'll maybe be able see through some of the smoke screen excuses he might be giving you. Good luck. Post how it all gets resolved. Brian |
#3
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
new HVAC not cooling
|
#4
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
new HVAC not cooling
"CJT" wrote in message ... wrote: We recently had a contractor install a new unit (a Bryant Puron 2.5 ton in a 1500sq/ft 3br/2ba home) a couple of months ago. This week we've had some really warm weather with temperatures in the 90s nearing 100 degrees. The problem is the unit is not cooling the house. The unit runs all day and doesn't drop the temperature below 78 degrees. Our older unit never had this problem. We called the contractor that installed the unit out and he said that was normal. He told us that these units won't cool more than 20 degrees below the ambient air temperature. He also said that the fact that our ducts are in the celing makes this problem worse. Something doesn't sound right here. I mean, our old unit cooled the house fine and that unit was smaller (2 ton). What's going on here? Is he correct, ignorant or simply lying? Can you guys educate me on this? Should this unit be capable of cooling the house better than it's doing now? Btu is Btu. If the new unit is larger, it should cool to a lower temperature than the old one. Proper sizing aside, the higher capacity can remove more heat. Proper sizing gets into things like humidity control where to big is no good. If the 2 ton unit was good, the 2.5 ton should be at least as good at reducing the temperature. I'd do a quick check of the basics first. Are the duct leaking? Was something left undone or is airflow blocked? Check the temperature of the air entering and leaving the AC. It should have about a 20 degree drop across the coil. Cooler at night with no sun load? By cooler, I mean the differential between outside and inside temperature. Personally, I think there is a problem and since it is new, get him back to check things, such as the pressures in the unit. There may have been a leak. There is a lower limit, of course. At 100 degrees, a properly sized unit won't get it much more than 20 to 25 degrees cooler than outside, but if the old one did, the new one should. |
#5
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
new HVAC not cooling
On Mon 09 Jun 2008 06:52:50p, Edwin Pawlowski told us...
"CJT" wrote in message ... wrote: We recently had a contractor install a new unit (a Bryant Puron 2.5 ton in a 1500sq/ft 3br/2ba home) a couple of months ago. This week we've had some really warm weather with temperatures in the 90s nearing 100 degrees. The problem is the unit is not cooling the house. The unit runs all day and doesn't drop the temperature below 78 degrees. Our older unit never had this problem. We called the contractor that installed the unit out and he said that was normal. He told us that these units won't cool more than 20 degrees below the ambient air temperature. He also said that the fact that our ducts are in the celing makes this problem worse. Something doesn't sound right here. I mean, our old unit cooled the house fine and that unit was smaller (2 ton). What's going on here? Is he correct, ignorant or simply lying? Can you guys educate me on this? Should this unit be capable of cooling the house better than it's doing now? Btu is Btu. If the new unit is larger, it should cool to a lower temperature than the old one. Proper sizing aside, the higher capacity can remove more heat. Proper sizing gets into things like humidity control where to big is no good. If the 2 ton unit was good, the 2.5 ton should be at least as good at reducing the temperature. I'd do a quick check of the basics first. Are the duct leaking? Was something left undone or is airflow blocked? Check the temperature of the air entering and leaving the AC. It should have about a 20 degree drop across the coil. Cooler at night with no sun load? By cooler, I mean the differential between outside and inside temperature. Personally, I think there is a problem and since it is new, get him back to check things, such as the pressures in the unit. There may have been a leak. There is a lower limit, of course. At 100 degrees, a properly sized unit won't get it much more than 20 to 25 degrees cooler than outside, but if the old one did, the new one should. The design and sizing of a system is also somewhat dependent on where you live. We live in the Phoenix area. Few people here would be happy with 95 degrees inside on a 120 degree day, a 25 degree differential. We can easily cool our house down to 70 degrees on a 120 degree day, although we usually keep it at 75 degrees. -- Wayne Boatwright ------------------------------------------- Monday, 06(VI)/09(IX)/08(MMVIII) ------------------------------------------- ------------------------------------------- If laughter is the best medicine, shouldn't we be regulating it? ------------------------------------------- |
#6
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
new HVAC not cooling
Wayne,
Your reply makes me curious........how many tons of a/c do you need to be able to get a 50 degree temperature drop for how many square feet of living space? What would be a typical electric bill during the summer months? Thanks, Smarty "Wayne Boatwright" wrote in message 6.120... On Mon 09 Jun 2008 06:52:50p, Edwin Pawlowski told us... "CJT" wrote in message ... wrote: We recently had a contractor install a new unit (a Bryant Puron 2.5 ton in a 1500sq/ft 3br/2ba home) a couple of months ago. This week we've had some really warm weather with temperatures in the 90s nearing 100 degrees. The problem is the unit is not cooling the house. The unit runs all day and doesn't drop the temperature below 78 degrees. Our older unit never had this problem. We called the contractor that installed the unit out and he said that was normal. He told us that these units won't cool more than 20 degrees below the ambient air temperature. He also said that the fact that our ducts are in the celing makes this problem worse. Something doesn't sound right here. I mean, our old unit cooled the house fine and that unit was smaller (2 ton). What's going on here? Is he correct, ignorant or simply lying? Can you guys educate me on this? Should this unit be capable of cooling the house better than it's doing now? Btu is Btu. If the new unit is larger, it should cool to a lower temperature than the old one. Proper sizing aside, the higher capacity can remove more heat. Proper sizing gets into things like humidity control where to big is no good. If the 2 ton unit was good, the 2.5 ton should be at least as good at reducing the temperature. I'd do a quick check of the basics first. Are the duct leaking? Was something left undone or is airflow blocked? Check the temperature of the air entering and leaving the AC. It should have about a 20 degree drop across the coil. Cooler at night with no sun load? By cooler, I mean the differential between outside and inside temperature. Personally, I think there is a problem and since it is new, get him back to check things, such as the pressures in the unit. There may have been a leak. There is a lower limit, of course. At 100 degrees, a properly sized unit won't get it much more than 20 to 25 degrees cooler than outside, but if the old one did, the new one should. The design and sizing of a system is also somewhat dependent on where you live. We live in the Phoenix area. Few people here would be happy with 95 degrees inside on a 120 degree day, a 25 degree differential. We can easily cool our house down to 70 degrees on a 120 degree day, although we usually keep it at 75 degrees. -- Wayne Boatwright ------------------------------------------- Monday, 06(VI)/09(IX)/08(MMVIII) ------------------------------------------- ------------------------------------------- If laughter is the best medicine, shouldn't we be regulating it? ------------------------------------------- |
#8
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
new HVAC not cooling
wrote in message ... We recently had a contractor install a new unit (a Bryant Puron 2.5 ton in a 1500sq/ft 3br/2ba home) a couple of months ago. This week we've had some really warm weather with temperatures in the 90s nearing 100 degrees. The problem is the unit is not cooling the house. The unit runs all day and doesn't drop the temperature below 78 degrees. Our older unit never had this problem. We called the contractor that installed the unit out and he said that was normal. He told us that these units won't cool more than 20 degrees below the ambient air temperature. He also said that the fact that our ducts are in the celing makes this problem worse. Something doesn't sound right here. I mean, our old unit cooled the house fine and that unit was smaller (2 ton). What's going on here? Is he correct, ignorant or simply lying? Can you guys educate me on this? Should this unit be capable of cooling the house better than it's doing now? I'd run this question over on alt.hvac Lots of professionals on there, I think you'll get good answer. Mike |
#9
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
new HVAC not cooling
"alt.hvac" ?? is that a website? I'd like to get that level of help for my
problem, too I'd run this question over on alt.hvac Lots of professionals on there, I think you'll get good answer. Mike |
#10
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
new HVAC not cooling
"dm440c" u44157@uwe wrote in news:857011a62794a@uwe:
"alt.hvac" ?? is that a website? I'd like to get that level of help for my problem, too I'd run this question over on alt.hvac Lots of professionals on there, I think you'll get good answer. Mike It's a newsgroup just like this one. "alt." should tell you that. |
#11
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
new HVAC not cooling
Red Green wrote in message ... "dm440c" u44157@uwe wrote in news:857011a62794a@uwe: "alt.hvac" ?? is that a website? I'd like to get that level of help for my problem, too I'd run this question over on alt.hvac Lots of professionals on there, I think you'll get good answer. Mike It's a newsgroup just like this one. "alt." should tell you that. NO, it's not a newsgroup just like this one, though it is a newsgroup. This one has nice, helpful people posting, that one doesn't. Cheri |
#12
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
new HVAC not cooling
Very good point. I've lurked about over there. Those guys are assholes.
s "Cheri" gserviceatinreachdotcom wrote in message . .. NO, it's not a newsgroup just like this one, though it is a newsgroup. This one has nice, helpful people posting, that one doesn't. Cheri |
#13
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
new HVAC not cooling
"Cheri" gserviceatinreachdotcom wrote in
: Red Green wrote in message ... "dm440c" u44157@uwe wrote in news:857011a62794a@uwe: "alt.hvac" ?? is that a website? I'd like to get that level of help for my problem, too I'd run this question over on alt.hvac Lots of professionals on there, I think you'll get good answer. Mike It's a newsgroup just like this one. "alt." should tell you that. NO, it's not a newsgroup just like this one, though it is a newsgroup. This one has nice, helpful people posting, that one doesn't. Cheri Oh, thanks for the clarification Cheri. That was nice & helpful :-) |
#14
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
new HVAC not cooling
"Cheri" gserviceatinreachdotcom wrote in message . .. Red Green wrote in message ... "dm440c" u44157@uwe wrote in news:857011a62794a@uwe: "alt.hvac" ?? is that a website? I'd like to get that level of help for my problem, too I'd run this question over on alt.hvac Lots of professionals on there, I think you'll get good answer. Mike It's a newsgroup just like this one. "alt." should tell you that. NO, it's not a newsgroup just like this one, though it is a newsgroup. This one has nice, helpful people posting, that one doesn't. Cheri Hi Cheri, I probably should have posted a warning (it did cross my mind). I still think they would get him a good answer. It's like like much of Usenet, a bunch of good people and then a couple that seem to get their self esteem by calling other people names and ridiculing them for not knowing the answer to their question. Thanks, Mike Mike |
#15
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
new HVAC not cooling
dm440c wrote in message 857011a62794a@uwe... "alt.hvac" ?? is that a website? I'd like to get that level of help for my problem, too I'd run this question over on alt.hvac Lots of professionals on there, I think you'll get good answer. Mike Don't do it, unless you like to be abused. :-) Cheri |
#16
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
new HVAC not cooling
"dm440c" u44157@uwe wrote in message news:857011a62794a@uwe... "alt.hvac" ?? is that a website? I'd like to get that level of help for my problem, too I'd run this question over on alt.hvac Lots of professionals on there, I think you'll get good answer. Mike It's a newsgroup, just like this one. Mike |
#17
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
new HVAC not cooling
amdx wrote:
wrote in message ... We recently had a contractor install a new unit (a Bryant Puron 2.5 ton in a 1500sq/ft 3br/2ba home) a couple of months ago. This week we've had some really warm weather with temperatures in the 90s nearing 100 degrees. The problem is the unit is not cooling the house. The unit runs all day and doesn't drop the temperature below 78 degrees. Our older unit never had this problem. We called the contractor that installed the unit out and he said that was normal. He told us that these units won't cool more than 20 degrees below the ambient air temperature. He also said that the fact that our ducts are in the celing makes this problem worse. Something doesn't sound right here. I mean, our old unit cooled the house fine and that unit was smaller (2 ton). What's going on here? Is he correct, ignorant or simply lying? Can you guys educate me on this? Should this unit be capable of cooling the house better than it's doing now? I'd run this question over on alt.hvac Lots of professionals on there, I think you'll get good answer. Mike Don't waste your time with alt.hvac; it's a newsgroup filled with also-rans who take out their frustrations on "homemoaners" I haven't visited hvac-talk.com in quite a while but the following forum there, frequented by HVAC pros helpful to homeowners, likely would be a good source of info: http://hvac-talk.com/vbb/forumdisplay.php?forumid=1 |
#18
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
new HVAC not cooling
"Erma1ina" wrote in message ... amdx wrote: wrote in message ... We recently had a contractor install a new unit (a Bryant Puron 2.5 ton in a 1500sq/ft 3br/2ba home) a couple of months ago. This week we've had some really warm weather with temperatures in the 90s nearing 100 degrees. The problem is the unit is not cooling the house. The unit runs all day and doesn't drop the temperature below 78 degrees. Our older unit never had this problem. We called the contractor that installed the unit out and he said that was normal. He told us that these units won't cool more than 20 degrees below the ambient air temperature. He also said that the fact that our ducts are in the celing makes this problem worse. Something doesn't sound right here. I mean, our old unit cooled the house fine and that unit was smaller (2 ton). What's going on here? Is he correct, ignorant or simply lying? Can you guys educate me on this? Should this unit be capable of cooling the house better than it's doing now? I'd run this question over on alt.hvac Lots of professionals on there, I think you'll get good answer. Mike Don't waste your time with alt.hvac; it's a newsgroup filled with also-rans who take out their frustrations on "homemoaners" I haven't visited hvac-talk.com in quite a while but the following forum there, frequented by HVAC pros helpful to homeowners, likely would be a good source of info: http://hvac-talk.com/vbb/forumdisplay.php?forumid=1 |
#19
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
new HVAC not cooling
I'd run this question over on alt.hvac Lots of professionals on there, I think you'll get good answer. Mike Don't waste your time with alt.hvac; it's a newsgroup filled with also-rans who take out their frustrations on "homemoaners" I haven't visited hvac-talk.com in quite a while but the following forum there, frequented by HVAC pros helpful to homeowners, likely would be a good source of info: http://hvac-talk.com/vbb/forumdisplay.php?forumid=1 I think his questions is good for aly.hvac. The pros don't like it when another one does a poor installation. They will tell him what needs to be done. Mike |
#21
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
new HVAC not cooling
2.5 ton is not big enough for 1500 sq. ft. Unless you have very high dollar
windows and are super insulated with 6" walls. Should have been 3 or even 3.5 ton. s wrote in message ... We recently had a contractor install a new unit (a Bryant Puron 2.5 ton in a 1500sq/ft 3br/2ba home) a couple of months ago. This week we've had some really warm weather with temperatures in the 90s nearing 100 degrees. The problem is the unit is not cooling the house. The unit runs all day and doesn't drop the temperature below 78 degrees. Our older unit never had this problem. We called the contractor that installed the unit out and he said that was normal. He told us that these units won't cool more than 20 degrees below the ambient air temperature. He also said that the fact that our ducts are in the celing makes this problem worse. Something doesn't sound right here. I mean, our old unit cooled the house fine and that unit was smaller (2 ton). What's going on here? Is he correct, ignorant or simply lying? Can you guys educate me on this? Should this unit be capable of cooling the house better than it's doing now? |
#22
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
new HVAC not cooling
"S. Barker" wrote in message ... 2.5 ton is not big enough for 1500 sq. ft. Unless you have very high dollar windows and are super insulated with 6" walls. Should have been 3 or even 3.5 ton. s wrote in message ... I mean, our old unit cooled the house fine and that unit was smaller (2 ton). But a 2 ton did the job before. I do my 2000 sq. ft. house with 2 1/2 ton no problem. |
#23
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
new HVAC not cooling
I totally missed that input point. Strike my reply as non-valid.
steve "Edwin Pawlowski" wrote in message news "S. Barker" wrote in message ... 2.5 ton is not big enough for 1500 sq. ft. Unless you have very high dollar windows and are super insulated with 6" walls. Should have been 3 or even 3.5 ton. s wrote in message ... I mean, our old unit cooled the house fine and that unit was smaller (2 ton). But a 2 ton did the job before. I do my 2000 sq. ft. house with 2 1/2 ton no problem. |
#24
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
new HVAC not cooling
On Jun 9, 6:32*pm, "S. Barker" wrote:
2.5 ton is not big enough for 1500 sq. ft. *Unless you have very high dollar windows and are super insulated with 6" walls. *Should have been 3 or even 3.5 ton. s wrote in message ... We recently had a contractor install a new unit (a Bryant Puron 2.5 ton in a 1500sq/ft 3br/2ba home) a couple of months ago. This week we've had some really warm weather with temperatures in the 90s nearing 100 degrees. The problem is the unit is not cooling the house. The unit runs all day and doesn't drop the temperature below 78 degrees. Our older unit never had this problem. We called the contractor that installed the unit out and he said that was normal. He told us that these units won't cool more than 20 degrees below the ambient air temperature. He also said that the fact that our ducts are in the celing makes this problem worse. Something doesn't sound right here. I mean, our old unit cooled the house fine and that unit was smaller (2 ton). What's going on here? Is he correct, ignorant or simply lying? Can you guys educate me on this? Should this unit be capable of cooling the house better than it's doing now?- Hide quoted text - - Show quoted text - we have 3 ton and space pack cooling a 3500 sq ft 90 yr old original window, poorly to non insulated all original leaker. It was even guarnteed in writing by the installer to give a 30f drop which it exceeded when it reached 113f here in chgo after it was installed 20 years ago. I dont know where you get your numbers. |
#25
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
new HVAC not cooling
On Jun 9, 4:11*pm, wrote:
We recently had a contractor install a new unit (a Bryant Puron 2.5 ton in a 1500sq/ft 3br/2ba home) a couple of months ago. This week we've had some really warm weather with temperatures in the 90s nearing 100 degrees. The problem is the unit is not cooling the house. The unit runs all day and doesn't drop the temperature below 78 degrees. Our older unit never had this problem. We called the contractor that installed the unit out and he said that was normal. He told us that these units won't cool more than 20 degrees below the ambient air temperature. He also said that the fact that our ducts are in the celing makes this problem worse. Something doesn't sound right here. I mean, our old unit cooled the house fine and that unit was smaller (2 ton). What's going on here? Is he correct, ignorant or simply lying? Can you guys educate me on this? Should this unit be capable of cooling the house better than it's doing now? If you had 2 ton and it cooled you fine before why did he want to put in a more expensive 2.5 ton and why did you agree to it, a larger unit will run less, but remove less humidity and that you didnt want, but to the point of cooling something must be wrong on the install if you are sure you had 2 ton before and it cooled better. The new larger unit wont remove as much humidity since it will run less, if it was put in right. |
#26
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
new HVAC not cooling
On Jun 9, 4:11*pm, wrote:
We recently had a contractor install a new unit (a Bryant Puron 2.5 ton in a 1500sq/ft 3br/2ba home) a couple of months ago. This week we've had some really warm weather with temperatures in the 90s nearing 100 degrees. The problem is the unit is not cooling the house. The unit runs all day and doesn't drop the temperature below 78 degrees. Our older unit never had this problem. We called the contractor that installed the unit out and he said that was normal. He told us that these units won't cool more than 20 degrees below the ambient air temperature. He also said that the fact that our ducts are in the celing makes this problem worse. Something doesn't sound right here. I mean, our old unit cooled the house fine and that unit was smaller (2 ton). What's going on here? Is he correct, ignorant or simply lying? Can you guys educate me on this? Should this unit be capable of cooling the house better than it's doing now? Did you pull a permit, is one required in your area, what does the contract say because inspectors help by checking work for free. If I had a non performing , wrongly oversized AC that will now leave me more humid I would make the installer put in the right unit, I bet he didnt do a load calc in writing, which is to your benefit if you did have 2 ton before, You hired a crooked hack if he oversized you, as you state you cooled before with 2 ton. |
#27
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
new HVAC not cooling
|
#28
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
new HVAC not cooling
wrote:
We recently had a contractor install a new unit (a Bryant Puron 2.5 ton in a 1500sq/ft 3br/2ba home) a couple of months ago. This week we've had some really warm weather with temperatures in the 90s nearing 100 degrees. The problem is the unit is not cooling the house. The unit runs all day and doesn't drop the temperature below 78 degrees. Our older unit never had this problem. We called the contractor that installed the unit out and he said that was normal. He told us that these units won't cool more than 20 degrees below the ambient air temperature. He also said that the fact that our ducts are in the celing makes this problem worse. Something doesn't sound right here. I mean, our old unit cooled the house fine and that unit was smaller (2 ton). What's going on here? Is he correct, ignorant or simply lying? Can you guys educate me on this? Should this unit be capable of cooling the house better than it's doing now? A couple of things you can check. 1. I figure when they upgraded you to a 2.5-ton from a 2-ton condensing unit they replaced the evaporator coil. If so, look around the system and see if you have any air leaks. 2. The system may have never been charged properly in the first place. I would have another service tech out from another company come out double check their work and see if you need further work. Just have him check the system, labor only, and if he finds problems then contact the company that did the work. -- Moe Jones http://www.MoeJones.info |
Reply |
Thread Tools | Search this Thread |
Display Modes | |
|
|
Similar Threads | ||||
Thread | Forum | |||
about cooling water pump design for closed circuit and forced circulation cooling tower | UK diy | |||
HVAC questions welcomed at alt.hvac | Home Repair | |||
HVAC questions welcomed at alt.hvac | Home Repair | |||
please post your HVAC questions to alt.hvac | Home Repair | |||
A/C--Is It Really Cooling? | Home Repair |