Home Repair (alt.home.repair) For all homeowners and DIYers with many experienced tradesmen. Solve your toughest home fix-it problems.

Reply
 
LinkBack Thread Tools Search this Thread Display Modes
  #1   Report Post  
Posted to alt.home.repair
external usenet poster
 
Posts: 17
Default Heat Pump repair, am I getting hosed?

My heat pump has never been all that great, but near the end of winter
(here) it pretty much stopped working altogether. Here's the back-
story:

My house is about 1700 sq.ft (heated), and has a single heat pump. I'm
not sure what size it is, but it's a Bryant, and I'm wanting to say 3-
ton. It was installed in 2000.

It has worked fine until about 4 months ago, when we noticed a
ridiculously high power bill (roughly double the usual, which has
never been too cheap anyway). I started paying attention, and noticed
that the heat pump was pretty much running all the time, just to keep
everything at the right temperature.

After a couple of weeks, it went on a downward slope. I would have the
thermostat at 74, but noticed that the temperature never went above 71
or 72, and it was still running all the time.

I called out the company that originally installed it, and after a lot
of "I'm not sure" and "everything seems OK here," they finally
guesstimated that the problem is what they called a "UV Valve." The
tech said that all of the voltages were right, and everything was
kicking on correctly, so this was literally the only thing left that
it could be. He called the home office, and they sent out another guy
a few days later to confirm (I wasn't here when he came to confirm,
but he left me a voicemail).

Here's the problem: the estimate to replace this UV Valve was a
whopping $950! The original tech said it would probably be $600, but
the tech that came to confirm when I wasn't here was the one that gave
the higher quote. This makes me worry that (a) they saw my nice house
and cool car in the garage, or (b) they found out what business I own,
and think that I have money to pay extra (which I don't have, thanks
to the nice house and cool car in the garage!)

I don't want to go in to too much detail, but I also had to have a
minor repair done to the heat pump after I bought the house that makes
me question the quality of the original installers work. It seemed as
if they installed something that they knew would fail, possibly with
the intention of getting paid to come and fix it at a later date. I
can explain more if necessary.

So here are my questions:

1. Based on the symptoms I posted, does the diagnosis of a faulty UV
Valve seem reasonable?

2. If so, would an estimate of $950 seems fair to replace that valve?

I hate to say "please reply urgently," but the temperature here is
going to be close to 95 by the weekend, so I have to decide pretty
quickly whether to pay someone else a $100 "diagnostic fee," or to
just trust this one. It turns out that every HVAC guy in the county
charges a minimum $100 fee, just to come and look at the darn thing!

TIA,

Jason

  #2   Report Post  
Posted to alt.home.repair
external usenet poster
 
Posts: 17
Default Heat Pump repair, am I getting hosed?

On May 8, 11:57 pm, Jason wrote:
My heat pump has never been all that great, but near the end of winter
(here) it pretty much stopped working altogether. Here's the back-
story:

My house is about 1700 sq.ft (heated), and has a single heat pump. I'm
not sure what size it is, but it's a Bryant, and I'm wanting to say 3-
ton. It was installed in 2000.

It has worked fine until about 4 months ago, when we noticed a
ridiculously high power bill (roughly double the usual, which has
never been too cheap anyway). I started paying attention, and noticed
that the heat pump was pretty much running all the time, just to keep
everything at the right temperature.

After a couple of weeks, it went on a downward slope. I would have the
thermostat at 74, but noticed that the temperature never went above 71
or 72, and it was still running all the time.

I called out the company that originally installed it, and after a lot
of "I'm not sure" and "everything seems OK here," they finally
guesstimated that the problem is what they called a "UV Valve." The
tech said that all of the voltages were right, and everything was
kicking on correctly, so this was literally the only thing left that
it could be. He called the home office, and they sent out another guy
a few days later to confirm (I wasn't here when he came to confirm,
but he left me a voicemail).

Here's the problem: the estimate to replace this UV Valve was a
whopping $950! The original tech said it would probably be $600, but
the tech that came to confirm when I wasn't here was the one that gave
the higher quote. This makes me worry that (a) they saw my nice house
and cool car in the garage, or (b) they found out what business I own,
and think that I have money to pay extra (which I don't have, thanks
to the nice house and cool car in the garage!)

I don't want to go in to too much detail, but I also had to have a
minor repair done to the heat pump after I bought the house that makes
me question the quality of the original installers work. It seemed as
if they installed something that they knew would fail, possibly with
the intention of getting paid to come and fix it at a later date. I
can explain more if necessary.

So here are my questions:

1. Based on the symptoms I posted, does the diagnosis of a faulty UV
Valve seem reasonable?

2. If so, would an estimate of $950 seems fair to replace that valve?

I hate to say "please reply urgently," but the temperature here is
going to be close to 95 by the weekend, so I have to decide pretty
quickly whether to pay someone else a $100 "diagnostic fee," or to
just trust this one. It turns out that every HVAC guy in the county
charges a minimum $100 fee, just to come and look at the darn thing!

TIA,

Jason


After reading further, the guy MUST have meant "reversing valve." I
can't find anything on a UV valve except for in reference to gas heat,
and a sticking reversing valve seems to have similar symptoms.

- J

  #3   Report Post  
Posted to alt.home.repair
external usenet poster
 
Posts: 307
Default Heat Pump repair, am I getting hosed?

On 8 May 2007 21:16:02 -0700, Jason wrote:


After reading further, the guy MUST have meant "reversing valve." I
can't find anything on a UV valve except for in reference to gas heat,
and a sticking reversing valve seems to have similar symptoms.

- J



The mechanical principals behind a heat pump can't be that complex.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Heat_pump I would check the fluid level.
Then I would look around for a similar valve from a HVAC place and
swap it.
  #4   Report Post  
Posted to alt.home.repair
external usenet poster
 
Posts: 75
Default Heat Pump repair, am I getting hosed?



The mechanical principals behind a heat pump can't be that complex.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Heat_pump I would check the fluid level.
Then I would look around for a similar valve from a HVAC place and
swap it.


Replacing a reversing valve is a BIG job. First, they are soldered into
the "outside" unit. When you open up the system you will expose the
compressor oil to contamination from moisture in the air. It will require
a longer than average "pump down" to restore the system. The existing R-22
(or whatever) will have to be "recovered" and not just dumped into the
atmosphere.

The OP definitely needs to get a second opinion but this is definitely not a
DIY project. Considering the age, it might make sense to replace the
outside unit. His best bet is a one man shop type of operation.


Reply
Thread Tools Search this Thread
Search this Thread:

Advanced Search
Display Modes

Posting Rules

Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off
Trackbacks are On
Pingbacks are On
Refbacks are On


Similar Threads
Thread Thread Starter Forum Replies Last Post
Possible to repair a cracked heat pump fan blade? wgd Home Repair 12 August 17th 06 12:57 AM
Heat Pump - Repair or Replace? shibumi Home Repair 29 March 3rd 06 01:09 PM
Repair heat pump, or replace it? [email protected] Home Repair 19 February 22nd 06 01:45 AM
Buddy tells me if I have elec heat and a heat pump, I can get a deal with PSE&G... dean Home Repair 3 September 26th 05 04:31 AM
Heat Pump Repair Burhans Home Repair 3 April 16th 05 07:36 PM


All times are GMT +1. The time now is 11:30 PM.

Powered by vBulletin® Copyright ©2000 - 2024, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Copyright ©2004-2024 DIYbanter.
The comments are property of their posters.
 

About Us

"It's about DIY & home improvement"