I have a customer that wanted an adjustment made to her formica countertop.
I made the adjustment and when I went to screw the countertop back on, I
realized that whoever put the screws in used long screws and simple
carefully screwed them in just enough to hold the countertop in place. I
started to screw it back in, went too far, and started to lift the formica
finish on the countertop. I cracked the surface but didn't drill through
the top. I stopped just in time.

Now how do I fix it?