Your comment goes to the question: "Why do I turn?"

Some turn for the challenge - they might want to improve. Some turn
for fun and are quite satisfied with their product. Some turn for
commerce where speed, quality and cost containment mean everything.

Faults? No. Only different motivations.

Joe Fleming - San Diego



Arch wrote:
Excellent work doesn't arise 'de nouveau'.
Fine turnings result from hard work and attention to detail. At least
I
think that's true. Question: where is it written that to advance, we
must always do the best we can? Answer: Everywhere.

Almost every instructional demo, article or posting admonishes us to
turn at our max and strive for even higher, no exceptions. It appears
that anything less is anathema and the attitude of a flawed
woodturner.

Reasonably good but less than best may be unacceptable, even for
production work, but this isn't about turning 50 fine bannisters or a
superior one-off object. It's about sloppy turning, happy and
unfettered. Is it wrong to just have fun with no need to eternally
reach
for unattainable perfection?

Forget art vs craft, grind vs hone, peel vs punch, and all that;
carefree vs compulsive is the debate du jour. If there are no rules,
no
always, no nevers and no turning police, am I a heretic for not
trying
for my best at the lathe every time?

Is this a fault of one carefree underachiever or are there other
part-time slobs out there? If so, can the compulsive overachievers
ever
understand us? Moreover, who cares?


Turn to Safety, Arch
Fortiter



http://community.webtv.net/almcc/MacsMusings