View Single Post
  #23   Report Post  
Posted to uk.d-i-y
Rod Speed Rod Speed is offline
external usenet poster
 
Posts: 40,893
Default OT Knackered wind turbine

Paul wrote
Brian Gaff (Sofa) wrote


How can you tell, I've no idea what your picture
shows, does it have a blade missing and by the
way why do turbines not use more blades?


NASA made an experimental turbine, with just
one blade, and a counterweight. Someone has
tested that idea.


They do have turbines with two blades. The tower
wobbles more, when the top blade is in full wind, the
bottom blade is shielded by the tower. That torques
the hub and tower.


Apparently, adding the third blade only adds 3%
more power. But the torque ripple in the tower is less.


Additional blades would only add more mass and drag.


But doesn't explain why the old windmills as opposed
to windmill water pumps normally had 4.

The next number of practical blades would be five.


That's not right.

One article on wind turbines, mentions that the design
is all about "number of flexures". And the blades are only
good for about 100 million flexures. Each rotation counts
as a flexure for the blade, it is constantly being worked
(and ruined). Same goes for the tower, it takes a lot of
abuse too.

The Dutch windmills are different. There's an entire article
on "Windmill Sail" design and mechanisms for automating
the furling in high wind (spring-loaded shutters).


But doesn't explain why they had 4 and not 3.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Windmill_sail