Faced with the same issue, I went with Eagle (www.eaglewindow.com). A true
divided lite, double hung, tilt-in sash.

I looked for a long time as I'm replacing some original windows (some 16 over
2) in a 130yr old Victorian on the Registry.

Also, less expensive than Anderson.

Regards,
Joe

In article , wrote:
Joe Bobst wrote:

recommendations for any of the following brands:
\ - Newpro
- Mastic
- National Vinyl
- Diamond
- Vermont Vinyl
- Park Ave

None of the above. Save yourself the aggravation and go with Andersen. The
reason many companies are more successful than others is because their
quality
is better, so they don't spend a ton of money fending off unhappy customers.
That said, consider Pella. Their window performance on some of my properties
has been very good indeeed. YMMV.

Joe

Any thoughts on Milgard, like how they stack up against Andersen?