View Single Post
  #80   Report Post  
Posted to alt.home.repair
Fred McKenzie Fred McKenzie is offline
external usenet poster
 
Posts: 388
Default Solder or crimp ??

In article ,
Ashton Crusher wrote:

Depending on what's needed, crimping is almost always going to be
faster and cheaper for a great many applications and will be "good
enough" for the life needed.


You are suggesting that soldering, although more time consuming and
expensive, would be better for longer-life applications.

Back in the early 60s, I worked with an engineer that needed to
determine which type of connection would be best for use in a
high-reliability military system.

Half of several connector sets were soldered, half were crimped. This
included using smaller gauge wire in some pins, folding the wire for
crimping.

My job was to monitor the testing, which included vibration, shock,
temperature cycling, humidity cycling and salt spray.

As I recall, there were numerous failures of the soldered connections.
The only crimp failures were where smaller gauge wire was used.

Fred