View Single Post
  #23   Report Post  
Posted to uk.d-i-y
polygonum polygonum is offline
external usenet poster
 
Posts: 5,386
Default The wrong kind of light

On Mon, 16 Jul 2012 07:48:10 +0100, Andrew Gabriel
wrote:

In article ,
writes:
I've just ordered 4. Would prefer lower wattage too. SWMBO won't accept
6500K
ones apart from the one in the futility room. The usual 2700K slow
start ones
are abominable, like crap lady's makeup in colour. Whatever happened to
3500K
which would be more acceptable.


They aren't acceptable to most people, which is why they will be hard
to find. The lux level required to make 3500K look acceptable (lookup
Kruithof Curve) would be hard to achieve with CFLs - you need several
linear fluorescent tubes, which is why you'll find 3500K in fluorescent
tubes, but not CFLs.

The 5000K and up lamps and really just gimicks - you are effectively
using a blue coloured lamp, because you will never get the lux level high
enough for 5000+K to look natural. You would have to line most of the
ceiling with fluorescent tubes.


Not speaking for anyone else, but I find the colour and brightness of the
already-mentioned trumpet top CFLs to be pretty darned good. Far nicer
than incandescent (standard lamps or most halogens). And far far far nicer
than most 2700 K CFLs.

And the 4200 K (IIRC) link lights in the kitchen are not too bad.

--
Rod