ransley wrote:
On Apr 28, 7:03 pm, (Una) wrote:
Una wrote:
....

I didnt see the roofer proposing 4" of insulation, which is worthless
in a vented attic

Guess you didn't see the "good tongue and groove board, which may or may
not be the very same T&G boards that make up the exposed rafter ceiling
of the room below", either. There is no attic afaict.

--