View Single Post
  #19   Report Post  
ATP*
 
Posts: n/a
Default Why are RAS so unpopular?


"Charlie Self" wrote in message
oups.com...

ATP* wrote:
"Lee Michaels" wrote in message
...

"Charlie Self" wrote

Toller wrote:
98% of the crosscutting I do (depending on the size with my CMS,
crosscut TS
sled, or with a guide and a circular saw) is 90 degrees in both
directions.

I understand that RAS can be fussy to set up, but if set up properly
will
they do decent 90 degree cuts? Or are they just inherently
inaccurate?
I
don't mind spending an extra 10 minutes on the rare occasion I want
to
do
something more exotic; especially since it would take much longer to
do
it
now (at least on stuff bigger than my CMS).

I have my eye on a 2 year old craftsman that was barely used. Sure
would be
nice to be able to do 16" crosscuts without a lot of fuss; but if it
won't
be accurate, then it would just be a waste of room and money.

Buy the saw. Find a copy of Jon Eakins' book on radial arm saws.
Enjoy.
You'll need to tune it, check the tune every so often, and it will
probably wear out in 20 or so years, but what the hell.

I don't like them for ripping, but for wider crosscuts, they're great.

I grew up around radial arm saws. Now everybody acts like they are
going
to get a disease from it or something. If you have a healthy respect
for
tools. You observe some basic safety rules. You tune the thing now and
then. It should give you long service.

But if you do not respect the beast, it will bite you. I used to work
in
insurance. And a lot of stupid people hurt themselves on this thing. I
read the reports.

But I have worked around these saws for about forty years. And I have
all
fingers and toes. And I have built a mile or two of bookcases with
them
too. Not that long ago, almost all houses were built with these things.

How do you figure? Framing has been done with circular saws for as long
as I
can remember. Prior to the advent of chopsaws, trim was done with
manually
operated mitre boxes. In my experience, the RAS has been a shop tool 99%
of
the time.


As recently as 20 years ago, many job sites had an RAS there to do the
cutting of heavier timbers, trim and similar parts. That particular
tool use in my experience goes back into at least the middle '50s when
I started bending nails. My brother, who contracted aluminum, and then
vinyl, siding always preferred one on the site.

I've used them for siding, although I haven't see too many other contractors
in NY employ them in that manner.