..... with no bandsaw.

My 10 year old daughter ended up on the floor during dinner a few nights
ago when one of my wife's 2nd hand chairs ended up giving up the ghost.

I do well with basic tool operation, straight lines, tables, and
casework - but I always viewed chair making as perhaps beyond my skill
and tool set. My wife has recently been hinting at a new walnut table -
and I had assumed I'd purchase chairs. But, as a wood hack, when an
immediate need shows itself, I wonder "hmmm - wonder if I can do
better??" It's a blow to my already fragile ego to run to the local mass
production, low quality furniture store and spend $150/chair.

I've ordered a few books to start my research (Jeff Miller), but thought
I'd toss it out to the group. Chairs aren't discussed much, but I seem
to remember following the saga of someone's experience a few years back
(thinking Swingman and Arts and Crafts chairs?).

Is a bandsaw crucial? Other tools outside the norm (TS, planer, router
table, jigsaw, etc)? Necessary skills?

Thanks -

jbd in Denver

--
Posted via a free Usenet account from http://www.teranews.com

"jbd in Denver" wrote in message

Is a bandsaw crucial? Other tools outside the norm (TS, planer, router
table, jigsaw, etc)? Necessary skills?

You can do it, just take your time, research, plan every step and go for it.
I would suggest that, after deciding upon a style/design (pick something
else than "Queen Anne" g), making a full scale drawing on a sheet of 1/4"
mdf and then making a prototype out of cheap wood before you start working
with the good stuff.

I didn't have a great deal of time or space to a very detailed, blow by
blow, on the website, but you might want to check out that page again if you
haven't seen it lately:

http://www.e-woodshop.net/Projects10.htm


... also, there is some information on the jigs page for cutting mortises
in chair back rails.

And, there was a discussion yesterday in the "Printing Full Size Drawings"
on making making the curved chair back rails from printer generated
drawings.

Also, there is an article on making an Art n' Crafts chair in the April 2007
Fine Woodworking that goes into detail and looks as if it could be adjusted
for style.

Might want to check that out.

On the tool issue, I did find a band saw to be necessary, at least in my
estimation, for doing the curved chairback rails, but there are other ways
to attack that, although the bandsaw will save a LOT of time in that regard.

Once again, and IMNSHO, making a prototype is a key component in your
endeavor. For goodness sake ask any pertinent questions, as there are a
couple of other's posting here who have made chair sets, so there is a good
deal of experience to draw from.


--
www.e-woodshop.net
Last update: 9/30/07
KarlC@ (the obvious)

On Oct 2, 9:34 am, jbd in Denver
wrote:
.... with no bandsaw.

My 10 year old daughter ended up on the floor during dinner a few nights
ago when one of my wife's 2nd hand chairs ended up giving up the ghost.

I do well with basic tool operation, straight lines, tables, and
casework - but I always viewed chair making as perhaps beyond my skill
and tool set. My wife has recently been hinting at a new walnut table -
and I had assumed I'd purchase chairs. But, as a wood hack, when an
immediate need shows itself, I wonder "hmmm - wonder if I can do
better??" It's a blow to my already fragile ego to run to the local mass
production, low quality furniture store and spend $150/chair.

I've ordered a few books to start my research (Jeff Miller), but thought
I'd toss it out to the group. Chairs aren't discussed much, but I seem
to remember following the saga of someone's experience a few years back
(thinking Swingman and Arts and Crafts chairs?).

Is a bandsaw crucial? Other tools outside the norm (TS, planer, router
table, jigsaw, etc)? Necessary skills?

You can avoid a lot of the compound angles by making simple mission or
"arts and crafts" style chairs. This would also allow you to avoid
the need for a lathe and any need for steam bending. You can avoid
scooping out the seat by using an apholstered seat or slats. There
are a lot of things you can do to make the chair a much simpler task
that doesn't require so many tools and skills. But, there will be
some sacrifice in comfort and style. Windsor chairs have been made
since before there were table saws, planers, routers, jigsaws,
bandsaws, etc. All you need is a lathe, a drawknife, an adze, a
gouge, a scraper, a brace and bits, and a steambox. What you lack in
tools will surely be made up for in skills. If you are interested in
a traditional style (windsor, chippendale, queen anne, colonial,
hepplewhite, regency, etc.) don't expect it to be an easy project -
expect it to be an epic adventure. There's a reason why every town
has dozens of cabinet makers and virtually no chair makers - and it's
not because nobody needs chairs!

I would say that you are doing well to get some books on the topic. I
would look to see if there are any companion videos with the books. I
would also visit several "higher end" furniture stores (i.e. Ethan
Allen, etc.) to examine their chairs for insight into how they are
constructed.

Ed Bennett


http://www.ts-aligner.com
Home of the TS-Aligner.com

Two options I would consider.

1, the Leigh FMT jig. It is great for doing the compound miters and
I'd assume they give some pointers on chair specific joints, plus many
users here too. Look at their SLOWWWWW website at www.leighjigs.com/fmt.php.
If you look at the magazine articles on their site about the FMT, the
Fine Woodworking article actually lists all of the similar more
expensive and less expensive cousins by other vendors.

2. You can buy chair kits from www.tablelegs.com. Their product line
keeps getting longer and they will eventually complete co-opt my idea
for a kit business if they keep adding products. They have a few
different kits so you are just assembling and finishing. Not sure they
have any Walnut though.

Best of luck. By the way if you want some great figured, crotch or
burl Walnut look at the online catalog of Northwest Timber http://www.nwtimber.net/

BW



On Oct 2, 8:34 am, jbd in Denver
wrote:
.... with no bandsaw.

My 10 year old daughter ended up on the floor during dinner a few nights
ago when one of my wife's 2nd hand chairs ended up giving up the ghost.

I do well with basic tool operation, straight lines, tables, and
casework - but I always viewed chair making as perhaps beyond my skill
and tool set. My wife has recently been hinting at a new walnut table -
and I had assumed I'd purchase chairs. But, as a wood hack, when an
immediate need shows itself, I wonder "hmmm - wonder if I can do
better??" It's a blow to my already fragile ego to run to the local mass
production, low quality furniture store and spend $150/chair.

I've ordered a few books to start my research (Jeff Miller), but thought
I'd toss it out to the group. Chairs aren't discussed much, but I seem
to remember following the saga of someone's experience a few years back
(thinking Swingman and Arts and Crafts chairs?).

Is a bandsaw crucial? Other tools outside the norm (TS, planer, router
table, jigsaw, etc)? Necessary skills?

Thanks -

jbd in Denver

--
Posted via a free Usenet account fromhttp://www.teranews.com

On Oct 2, 12:25 pm, "Swingman" wrote:

You can do it, just take your time, research, plan every step and go for it. I would suggest that, after deciding upon a style/design (pick something
else than "Queen Anne" g)

Hah! Or a sculpted Hensarling or the like. Like some of the
Federalist period furniture, I think the starting point is the most
important for this task. It is no fun to be reduced to tears over
something that is supposed to be fun. Maybe the next set of chairs...

making a full scale drawing on a sheet of 1/4"
mdf and then making a prototype out of cheap wood before you start working with the good stuff.

Wow... the best advice you can get there. A really fine chair maker
near here has been making chairs for about 25 years, and he still uses
his templates. Not because he doesn't know how his designs go
together, but it makes it really easy for him to see the best use of
his material by simply laying it on the wood. In his classes, he
teaches the students to make their templates on 1/2 plywood, and write
the names of the pieces on the plywood. These are to be hung on the
wall in the shop.

My advice: Don't bite off more than you can chew. If you are
learning joinery, including clamping, glueing, fitting, wood
finishing, and all the other things all at once it can be
overwhelming.

You don't want to turn out a piece of work that people smile and look
at you with that look of "nice try" or "as long as you are happy with
it", or their best comment is "boy, that damn thing sure is sturdy!"

I think I would start with a kit so I could get some of the techniques
down and learn which of my tools were going to do the job for me. You
can buy some kits for about the price of materials.

http://www.vandykes.com/product/02344531/

Those kits are easy to "make your own" with some design touches or
finishing.

I would also recommend to get on down the library or half price book
store and look for:

The Art of Chairmaking - Kerry Pierce

Jack Hill's Country Chair Making - Jack Hill

Building Chairs - from the Time/Life Art of Woodworking

Each one of these were purchased by me in the 1/2 priced store. They
each have their strong and weak points, but all have a lot of good
information on design, joinery, and even some scaled plans.

One of these days I'll find time for a great rocker I have in mind. I
have 250 bf of mesquite dried and ready to go... has been for about 3
years. It's on the list...

Robert

wrote in message

In his classes, he
teaches the students to make their templates on 1/2 plywood, and write
the names of the pieces on the plywood. These are to be hung on the
wall in the shop.

Yep, I've always thought that Archimedes' fabled saying ought to be revised
for wooddorkers: "Give me a fulcrum, and a place to stand, and I will move
the world; a template, and a jig, and I will build a chair."

One could make a good case that the better the template/jigmaker, the better
the chairmaker. I can guarantee you that the reverse is true.

--
www.e-woodshop.net
Last update: 9/30/07
KarlC@ (the obvious)

On Oct 2, 1:39 pm, Ed Bennett wrote:
On Oct 2, 9:34 am, jbd in Denver
wrote:



.... with no bandsaw.

My 10 year old daughter ended up on the floor during dinner a few nights
ago when one of my wife's 2nd hand chairs ended up giving up the ghost.

I do well with basic tool operation, straight lines, tables, and
casework - but I always viewed chair making as perhaps beyond my skill
and tool set. My wife has recently been hinting at a new walnut table -
and I had assumed I'd purchase chairs. But, as a wood hack, when an
immediate need shows itself, I wonder "hmmm - wonder if I can do
better??" It's a blow to my already fragile ego to run to the local mass
production, low quality furniture store and spend $150/chair.

I've ordered a few books to start my research (Jeff Miller), but thought
I'd toss it out to the group. Chairs aren't discussed much, but I seem
to remember following the saga of someone's experience a few years back
(thinking Swingman and Arts and Crafts chairs?).

Is a bandsaw crucial? Other tools outside the norm (TS, planer, router
table, jigsaw, etc)? Necessary skills?

You can avoid a lot of the compound angles by making simple mission or
"arts and crafts" style chairs. This would also allow you to avoid
the need for a lathe and any need for steam bending.

Steam bent (or bent lamination) rails waste less wood than sawn.
They're also stronger. Shaping is at least halfway done when
you take the rail from the mold.

A steam chest is easy. Long box, open both ends. PVC
drainpipe would work great. Lay on sawhorses. Place a kettle
at one end with a hose running up into the box. Pack the ends
with rags to build steam pressure without creating a bomb. I
could have built one and had it running in the time it took me to
write this.

"jbd in Denver" wrote in message
5.47...
.... with no bandsaw.

My 10 year old daughter ended up on the floor during dinner a few nights
ago when one of my wife's 2nd hand chairs ended up giving up the ghost.

I do well with basic tool operation, straight lines, tables, and
casework - but I always viewed chair making as perhaps beyond my skill
and tool set. My wife has recently been hinting at a new walnut table -
and I had assumed I'd purchase chairs. But, as a wood hack, when an
immediate need shows itself, I wonder "hmmm - wonder if I can do
better??" It's a blow to my already fragile ego to run to the local mass
production, low quality furniture store and spend $150/chair.

I've ordered a few books to start my research (Jeff Miller), but thought
I'd toss it out to the group. Chairs aren't discussed much, but I seem
to remember following the saga of someone's experience a few years back
(thinking Swingman and Arts and Crafts chairs?).

Is a bandsaw crucial? Other tools outside the norm (TS, planer, router
table, jigsaw, etc)? Necessary skills?

I made my first (and possibly my last) chairs last year. I found a great
book in the library that showed how to make a succession of chairs from very
simple to complicated, adding one feature (inclinded back, arms, etc.) with
each. Sorry I don't know the name of it, but it was very helpful.

I settled on a moderate armchair that was a cross between two in the book.
Far and away the hardest things I ever made; getting all the compound angles
and curves to line up..........
But the worked out nicely. http://wood.lippman.info/oakdiningroomchairs

Couldn't have made them without access to a pretty decent bandsaw. I just
wish I had my domino back then!

On Oct 2, 4:45 pm, "Toller" wrote:

I settled on a moderate armchair that was a cross between two in the book.
Far and away the hardest things I ever made; getting all the compound angles and curves to line up..........
But the worked out nicely.http://wood.lippman.info/oakdiningroomchairs

Nicely done. My personal preference is either a very complicated
design, or a simple one. I think that's a real nice design. (Looks
like good work, too!)

Robert

On Oct 2, 3:43 pm, "Swingman" wrote:

One could make a good case that the better the template/jigmaker, the better the chairmaker. I can guarantee you that the reverse is true.

I can easily see that. Even the vaunted Sam Maloof uses patterns
(when needed) for his work. Although I did see a show on TV a while
back that interviewed him in his shop, and he said that he had made so
many Maloof rockers that he could (and did on camera) cut the back
supports by eye.

This is the guy I was referring to in an earlier post,

http://www.mesquiterocker.com/

and you can certainly see where he learned to make his rocker. The
truth is that Robert is a gifted woodworker, and makes all kinds of
furniture, and likes to make all kinds of things. I have a good
friend of mine that is good friends with him, and apparently now he
has perfected his knife making skills and is making those as well.

I have met Robert a couple of times, and a nicer guy you'll never
meet. His shop is about an hour from here, and it is surprisingly
informal. He has none of the false airs that come from being "pretty
good", or having learned about furniture making by reciting all the
proper names and styles from different popular books. He is talented
to the point of being gifted, and he gets a low key (but pleased)
chuckle out of people ooohing and aaahhing over his work.

To build his business to where it is now, over the years he has made
every show, state fair, exposition, celebration, and any other excuse
for a city party to sell his wares. He built his business the old
fashioned way, one customer at a time.

If you are an old student, you can stop in anytime to chat, and
probably go up the street to the BBQ joint he favors.
And I have never one talked to anyone that thought the money on the
classes were wasted.

In a true Texas tradition, once the seminar/classes wind down,
significant others are invited up to the shop where they have barbecue
and "graduation".

I would love to take one of his classes, but the time and the money
haven't oriented themselves properly at the same time to allow me to
do it.

One day....

Robert

wrote

This is the guy I was referring to in an earlier post,

http://www.mesquiterocker.com/

Those aren't chairs, those are Chairs!

Got a kick out of the knife page also. Particularly seeing that old picture
of a shop in Madisonville, where I've spent a good deal of time down through
the years.

Thanks for the link.

--
www.e-woodshop.net
Last update: 9/30/07
KarlC@ (the obvious)

"Ed Bennett" wrote in message
ups.com...
On Oct 2, 9:34 am, jbd in Denver
wrote:
.... with no bandsaw.

My 10 year old daughter ended up on the floor during dinner a few nights
ago when one of my wife's 2nd hand chairs ended up giving up the ghost.

I do well with basic tool operation, straight lines, tables, and
casework - but I always viewed chair making as perhaps beyond my skill
and tool set. My wife has recently been hinting at a new walnut table -
and I had assumed I'd purchase chairs. But, as a wood hack, when an
immediate need shows itself, I wonder "hmmm - wonder if I can do
better??" It's a blow to my already fragile ego to run to the local mass
production, low quality furniture store and spend $150/chair.

I've ordered a few books to start my research (Jeff Miller), but thought
I'd toss it out to the group. Chairs aren't discussed much, but I seem
to remember following the saga of someone's experience a few years back
(thinking Swingman and Arts and Crafts chairs?).

Is a bandsaw crucial? Other tools outside the norm (TS, planer, router
table, jigsaw, etc)? Necessary skills?

You can avoid a lot of the compound angles by making simple mission or
"arts and crafts" style chairs. This would also allow you to avoid
the need for a lathe and any need for steam bending. You can avoid
scooping out the seat by using an apholstered seat or slats. There
are a lot of things you can do to make the chair a much simpler task
that doesn't require so many tools and skills. But, there will be
some sacrifice in comfort and style. Windsor chairs have been made
since before there were table saws, planers, routers, jigsaws,
bandsaws, etc. All you need is a lathe, a drawknife, an adze, a
gouge, a scraper, a brace and bits, and a steambox. What you lack in
tools will surely be made up for in skills. If you are interested in
a traditional style (windsor, chippendale, queen anne, colonial,
hepplewhite, regency, etc.) don't expect it to be an easy project -
expect it to be an epic adventure. There's a reason why every town
has dozens of cabinet makers and virtually no chair makers - and it's
not because nobody needs chairs!

I would say that you are doing well to get some books on the topic. I
would look to see if there are any companion videos with the books. I
would also visit several "higher end" furniture stores (i.e. Ethan
Allen, etc.) to examine their chairs for insight into how they are
constructed.

Ed Bennett


http://www.ts-aligner.com
Home of the TS-Aligner.com

Thanks for kicking the door wide open Ed.
Take Mike Dunbar's course. It will be one of the best weeks of your whole
life.
No saw dust. Lots of curly wood shavings.

http://www.thewindsorinstitute.com/

I know, the original poster may not have the time, etc., but this is the
correct answer.

-Dean
Sitting in chair number one as I type this.

"jbd in Denver" wrote in message
5.47...
.... with no bandsaw.

My 10 year old daughter ended up on the floor during dinner a few nights
ago when one of my wife's 2nd hand chairs ended up giving up the ghost.

I do well with basic tool operation, straight lines, tables, and
casework - but I always viewed chair making as perhaps beyond my skill
and tool set. My wife has recently been hinting at a new walnut table -
and I had assumed I'd purchase chairs. But, as a wood hack, when an
immediate need shows itself, I wonder "hmmm - wonder if I can do
better??" It's a blow to my already fragile ego to run to the local mass
production, low quality furniture store and spend $150/chair.

I've ordered a few books to start my research (Jeff Miller), but thought
I'd toss it out to the group. Chairs aren't discussed much, but I seem
to remember following the saga of someone's experience a few years back
(thinking Swingman and Arts and Crafts chairs?).

Is a bandsaw crucial? Other tools outside the norm (TS, planer, router
table, jigsaw, etc)? Necessary skills?

Thanks -

jbd in Denver

--
Posted via a free Usenet account from http://www.teranews.com

A bandsaw is not crucial, but it is a big help. You can get by with a
smaller and less expensive saw than a $1000 14" saw (which is what I have).
The bandsaw makes short work of tenons and ripping materials.

Frank Klausz's video "Making Mortise and Tenon Joints" shows how to lay out
the joints and I think is excellent. He shows lofting and joints for a
chair. Jeff Millers book is a must have for a newbie chair maker.

I went to Homestead Heritage's School of Woodworking and took two of their
chairmaking classes (all hand work).

I have completed three rocking chairs using their techniques and have
started one for a daughter using tiger maple. I use both power and hand
tools for my chairs.

The wood can be expensive. The last chair was of quarter sawn white oak and
the wood cost over $400. The maple I bought for the current chair cost over
$500, but the chairs should last for generations.

I can post pictures if you want to see them. I don't do the Maloof style
chairs because it seems everyone making a chair does one.

Woodwork magazine ran a two issue article for a craftsman rocker (it is the
Waco chair). You can build the chair with their article.

On Oct 2, 4:56 pm, "Dean H." wrote:
Thanks for kicking the door wide open Ed.
Take Mike Dunbar's course. It will be one of the best weeks of your whole
life.
No saw dust. Lots of curly wood shavings.

http://www.thewindsorinstitute.com/

I know, the original poster may not have the time, etc., but this is the
correct answer.

-Dean
Sitting in chair number one as I type this.

Couldn't agree more Dean. If you can take a course, DO IT! There is
nothing better than getting guidance from an expert like Mike Dunbar
while you learn.

Another thing I thought of after posting my first message. If I
remember correctly, Norm made a few chairs on the NYWS:

A chippendale "style" chair:
http://www.newyankee.com/getproduct3.cgi?0507

A windsor chair (with the help of Bill Wallick):
http://www.newyankee.com/getproduct3.cgi?0407

You can get the drawings and video for these: $40. My philosophy: if
Norm can do it, anybody can do it!

Ed Bennett


http://www.ts-aligner.com
Home of the TS-Aligner

I consider my pattern making skills the most important of my
capabilities and those of which I most proud

On Oct 2, 1:43 pm, "Swingman" wrote:
wrote in message
In his classes, he
teaches the students to make their templates on 1/2 plywood, and write
the names of the pieces on the plywood. These are to be hung on the
wall in the shop.

Yep, I've always thought that Archimedes' fabled saying ought to be revised
for wooddorkers: "Give me a fulcrum, and a place to stand, and I will move
the world; a template, and a jig, and I will build a chair."

One could make a good case that the better the template/jigmaker, the better
the chairmaker. I can guarantee you that the reverse is true.

--www.e-woodshop.net
Last update: 9/30/07
KarlC@ (the obvious)

My first major project was a dining room set. I had misgivings about making
the chairs, especially since I preferred lots of spindles and slats versus
simpler designs. I was mostly concerned about having the time and patience
to crank out two arm chairs and four side chairs. I'd recommend doing what I
did - make your table and buy the chairs. I bought some really nice chairs
from an unfinished furniture store at a reasonable price, then finished them
the same as the table. With the confidence and experience I gained from
making the table, I also made a buffet (with dovetailed drawers and raised
panel doors) and hutch in a much shorter time.

Buddy

"jbd in Denver" wrote in message
5.47...
.... with no bandsaw.

My 10 year old daughter ended up on the floor during dinner a few nights
ago when one of my wife's 2nd hand chairs ended up giving up the ghost.

I do well with basic tool operation, straight lines, tables, and
casework - but I always viewed chair making as perhaps beyond my skill
and tool set. My wife has recently been hinting at a new walnut table -
and I had assumed I'd purchase chairs. But, as a wood hack, when an
immediate need shows itself, I wonder "hmmm - wonder if I can do
better??" It's a blow to my already fragile ego to run to the local mass
production, low quality furniture store and spend $150/chair.

I've ordered a few books to start my research (Jeff Miller), but thought
I'd toss it out to the group. Chairs aren't discussed much, but I seem
to remember following the saga of someone's experience a few years back
(thinking Swingman and Arts and Crafts chairs?).

Is a bandsaw crucial? Other tools outside the norm (TS, planer, router
table, jigsaw, etc)? Necessary skills?

Thanks -

jbd in Denver

--
Posted via a free Usenet account from http://www.teranews.com

wrote in message
oups.com...
On Oct 2, 4:45 pm, "Toller" wrote:

I settled on a moderate armchair that was a cross between two in the
book.
Far and away the hardest things I ever made; getting all the compound
angles and curves to line up..........
But the worked out nicely.http://wood.lippman.info/oakdiningroomchairs

Nicely done. My personal preference is either a very complicated
design, or a simple one. I think that's a real nice design. (Looks
like good work, too!)

Robert

Thanks

On Oct 2, 3:01 pm, "
wrote:

I would also recommend to get on down the library or half price book
store and look for:

The Art of Chairmaking - Kerry Pierce

Jack Hill's Country Chair Making - Jack Hill

Building Chairs - from the Time/Life Art of Woodworking

Each one of these were purchased by me in the 1/2 priced store. They
each have their strong and weak points, but all have a lot of good
information on design, joinery, and even some scaled plans.

One of these days I'll find time for a great rocker I have in mind. I
have 250 bf of mesquite dried and ready to go... has been for about 3
years. It's on the list...

Robert

I agree with most of the comments that I just cut out. I wanted to
second the rec for Country Chair making. I drew inspiration from the
Hill book for a rocker a few years ago. Don't worry about the rather
hoky title -- it's not about making rustic furniture out of pine
limbs. Country is in the English sense -- and loosely translates as
"not stuffy Queen Anne ". I was reading an old library-owned version
from the 80's that looked really dated. Amazon seems to indicate a new
edition appeared in '98 and is also out of print. The best part of
Hill's book was that it helped me get over the feeling that things
need to be planned with machine shop levels of precision. Make
templates and mock ups. If the template/mock up is comfortable go
with that design -- it really doesn't matter if the leg splay is 12,
15, 17.5, or 20 degrees. If you plan on bending, practice on a
similar or less forgiving wood (e.g. I was building a chair in
cherry, tested the forms for bending backsticks, arms and rockers
with red oak).

Good luck. Chair making is challenging, but when it works out the
rewards are great. Most wood butchers can use machines to make things
straight and square (that's not written in a mean spirit -- I'm in the
wood butcher brotherhood). Case work is by and large meant to
interact with "stuff" -- clothes, dishes, etc. Chairs are meant to
interact with the human form; that introduces challenges and suggests
or even begs for a more organic design. That, I think, is what Maloof
and other great chair makers have fully embraced.

hex
-30-

On Oct 2, 7:36 pm, hex wrote:

Chairs are meant to interact with the human form; that introduces challenges and suggests or even begs for a more organic design. That, I think, is what Maloof
and other great chair makers have fully embraced.

hex
-30--


If you read his book and dig up some interviews with the man, or
better yet, talk to someone that has taken his classes I think you
will find that you are 110% completely accurate in that statement.

I remember something like "I was just trying to make a chair that was
comfortable to sit in" when he read his speech at the Smithsonian (yup
- THE Smithsonian) when they purchased one of his rockers and some
furniture as part of their permanent American Classics collection.

Robert

jbd in Denver wrote:
.... with no bandsaw.

My 10 year old daughter ended up on the floor during dinner a few
nights ago when one of my wife's 2nd hand chairs ended up giving up
the ghost.

I do well with basic tool operation, straight lines, tables, and
casework - but I always viewed chair making as perhaps beyond my
skill and tool set. My wife has recently been hinting at a new
walnut table - and I had assumed I'd purchase chairs. But, as a
wood hack, when an immediate need shows itself, I wonder "hmmm -
wonder if I can do better??" It's a blow to my already fragile ego
to run to the local mass production, low quality furniture store
and spend $150/chair.

I've ordered a few books to start my research (Jeff Miller), but
thought I'd toss it out to the group. Chairs aren't discussed much,
but I seem to remember following the saga of someone's experience a
few years back (thinking Swingman and Arts and Crafts chairs?).

Is a bandsaw crucial?

Always nice if you want to cut curves. But curves can be cut with
saber/jig saws too. They can also be bent in or laminated. Moreover,
chairs don't *have* to have curves.

Don't have to have slanted backs either. For example, the rear legs
can be vertical extending a few inches above the seat; the back can be
a separate slab or frame that is bolted to the rear legs so it can
swing using the rear of the seat as a stop. You could also use
leather/canvas/etc as a slingback ala director's chairs. Another way
is a fixed straight back upholstered to provide a slope.

So many ways, depends on what you want.

--

dadiOH
____________________________

dadiOH's dandies v3.06...
....a help file of info about MP3s, recording from
LP/cassette and tips & tricks on this and that.
Get it at http://mysite.verizon.net/xico

hex wrote:
On Oct 2, 3:01 pm, "
wrote:

I would also recommend to get on down the library or half price
book
store and look for:

The Art of Chairmaking - Kerry Pierce

Jack Hill's Country Chair Making - Jack Hill

Building Chairs - from the Time/Life Art of Woodworking

Each one of these were purchased by me in the 1/2 priced store.
They
each have their strong and weak points, but all have a lot of good
information on design, joinery, and even some scaled plans.

One of these days I'll find time for a great rocker I have in mind.
I have 250 bf of mesquite dried and ready to go... has been for
about 3 years. It's on the list...

Robert

I agree with most of the comments that I just cut out. I wanted to
second the rec for Country Chair making. I drew inspiration from
the
Hill book for a rocker a few years ago. Don't worry about the
rather
hoky title -- it's not about making rustic furniture out of pine
limbs. Country is in the English sense -- and loosely translates as
"not stuffy Queen Anne ". I was reading an old library-owned
version
from the 80's that looked really dated. Amazon seems to indicate a
new
edition appeared in '98 and is also out of print. The best part of
Hill's book was that it helped me get over the feeling that things
need to be planned with machine shop levels of precision. Make
templates and mock ups. If the template/mock up is comfortable go
with that design -- it really doesn't matter if the leg splay is 12,
15, 17.5, or 20 degrees. If you plan on bending, practice on a
similar or less forgiving wood (e.g. I was building a chair in
cherry, tested the forms for bending backsticks, arms and rockers
with red oak).

Good luck. Chair making is challenging, but when it works out the
rewards are great. Most wood butchers can use machines to make
things
straight and square (that's not written in a mean spirit -- I'm in
the
wood butcher brotherhood). Case work is by and large meant to
interact with "stuff" -- clothes, dishes, etc. Chairs are meant to
interact with the human form; that introduces challenges and
suggests
or even begs for a more organic design. That, I think, is what
Maloof
and other great chair makers have fully embraced.

Frank Lloyd Wright admitted at some point that he couldn't design a
comfortable chair--his best _looked_ marvelous but even he admitted
that they were miserable to sit in. If it was hard for _him_ . . .

--
--
--John
to email, dial "usenet" and validate
(was jclarke at eye bee em dot net)

On 02 Oct 2007 15:34:04 GMT, jbd in Denver
wrote:

.... with no bandsaw.

My 10 year old daughter ended up on the floor during dinner a few nights
ago when one of my wife's 2nd hand chairs ended up giving up the ghost.

I do well with basic tool operation, straight lines, tables, and
casework - but I always viewed chair making as perhaps beyond my skill
and tool set. My wife has recently been hinting at a new walnut table -
and I had assumed I'd purchase chairs. But, as a wood hack, when an
immediate need shows itself, I wonder "hmmm - wonder if I can do
better??" It's a blow to my already fragile ego to run to the local mass
production, low quality furniture store and spend $150/chair.

I've ordered a few books to start my research (Jeff Miller), but thought
I'd toss it out to the group. Chairs aren't discussed much, but I seem
to remember following the saga of someone's experience a few years back
(thinking Swingman and Arts and Crafts chairs?).

Is a bandsaw crucial? Other tools outside the norm (TS, planer, router
table, jigsaw, etc)? Necessary skills?

Thanks -

jbd in Denver


If in the end you find that you need to move more quickly into a new
set or you continue to be a little overwhelmed by chairmaking, and if
you want to make the table and if you like Queen Ann, you might
consider Adams Wood Products chair kits.

http://www.adamswoodproducts.com/

A close friend bought some Adams chair kits and they are well made,
very solid, and a savings over what you can buy in the store. You
also would be able to finish them the same as the table.

Not the same as making them but you do get to assemble, finish and the
results will be nice.

Frank

" wrote:


This is the guy I was referring to in an earlier post,

http://www.mesquiterocker.com/

I have met Robert a couple of times, and a nicer guy you'll never
meet. His shop is about an hour from here, and it is surprisingly
informal. He has none of the false airs that come from being "pretty
good", or having learned about furniture making by reciting all the
proper names and styles from different popular books. He is talented
to the point of being gifted, and he gets a low key (but pleased)
chuckle out of people ooohing and aaahhing over his work.

I have one of his rockers in curly maple. The gorgeous thing is sitting right
next to me know. I also have met him several times. I agree with the above
completely.

Like you, one of his classes is on my list of "things to do before I die".

-- Doug

"J. Clarke" wrote:

Frank Lloyd Wright admitted at some point that he couldn't design a
comfortable chair--his best _looked_ marvelous but even he admitted
that they were miserable to sit in. If it was hard for _him_ . . .


I love his architecture, but it has a reputation of being less than practical. I
have season tickets to a theater company that uses a FLW designed theater. It
is always too hot or too cold. I've read stories of leaking roofs, shifting
foundations, etc.

-- Doug