Woodworking (rec.woodworking) Discussion forum covering all aspects of working with wood. All levels of expertise are encouraged to particiapte.

Reply
 
LinkBack Thread Tools Search this Thread Display Modes
  #1   Report Post  
Posted to rec.woodworking
 
Posts: n/a
Default Review of Craftsman's new 12" BS

Got it a few days ago. $255 for CClub members.

Comes in 1 box, small enough to move around by yer self. Minimal
assembly required,
takes no more than 30 mins.

Stand is very sturdy, heavy gage steel.

Overall, paint quality top notch. Inside edges are not deburred.

Cast iron table is truly massive and most impecable in quality.
Tiliting mechanism
is smooth and locks solid. Checked the thing with machinist square - it
is all square.

Overall construction gets 9.9 out of 10. Welded out of heavy gage
steel.

Here's where the .1 went:

- wheels have clip retainers. Out into the trash can they went.
Drilled/tapped 1/4, turned
some caps. Much nicer now

- the blade cut in the table is not @ right angle to the blade. Every
now and then I work on thinner
pieces and having a gap toward in the feeding path is not appreciated.
3/16 or so.


Blade guides are the nicest I've ever seen . All ball bearing, they ARE
micro-adjustable. Rock solid. R&P, smooth, positive locking, alum
extrusion. Blade's back rides on the back of BB, not
on face . AAAA

Takes 1/8 -3/4 blades (adverised as 1/2 max). Tracking adjustment is
very easy. Has a look-through window so that
you can see the blade's position on the upper wheel. Has a
scale/indicator for blade-tension adjustment.

As it is to be expected, the "free' included blade was cr@p. After
cutting may be 40" in 2x4, as I was
adjusting the thing, it quit . May be it was plastic ? Dunno, don't
care and it was expected.

Timberwolf arrived pronto and with it, it shines.

Cutting hight capacity is stated @ 7", is more like 7 1/4 (amazing that
marketing dept didn't
see it and advertize it as such). With a quick look, it can be adjusted
to may be 8" by milling out
a notch in the guide assy. 7" is more than plenty for my needs.



Rip fence is top notch. No play, locks in solid.

Blade length is 89 1/2. Rather odd. TW stocks 90" - it worked just
fine. I also won't hesitate, in a
pinch, silver-solder my own out of 93 1/2. I also have a TIG setup, but
never tried welding blades
with it . Any pointers ?

Don't want to spend $30 on a mobile base (HD has them on sale, BTW). I
will simply weld on
some angle on 2 feet on narrow side and then weld 2 cheap caster to the
angles. THen, to move,
all you have to do is to lift the other side 1/4" or so and it will
roll around with ease. Kind of similar
to the HF's 4x6 arrangement.

2 speed setup. Changing speeds is very easy, no bolts . A hand-crank
releases tension on
the drive belt and then you can move the belt on the pulleys.

All right, it is all downhill from here.

DON'T expect to stick 7" high piece of oak and rip it at 5"/sec.
Don't expect anything faster than 5"/minute. The 3/4 HP motor
(adverised) looks massive, but
is rated at only at meager 7Amp. It ain't no 3/4 in my book.120V only,
no 240v. I opened the motor control assy,
it doesn't look it could be rewired to 240V. Only 3 wires come out of
motor.

On high SFPM setting, motor HAS DIFFICULTY simply spinning the pulleys
with a blade mounted.

Putting a hamster in to drive this thing would probably generate more
power. And cost less too,
few nuts a day.


Now, I can see the smirks disappearing on the faces of those that were
reading this review, thinking about buying this product.

Here's my take. For this price it is a great deal. EVEN after you spend
$160 to add a proper
1 1/2 HP motor. Grizzly . I'd err on side of safety, but 1 HP motor
might work too ($100 @ Grizzly).

The shaft on the stock motor is metric, so is the drive pulley. Will
have to bore to 5/8. Key size
is suspect as well. Good news is that standard 56 will fit in like a
glove. Base mount will
require drilling mounting holes in the base. The stock face mount
pattern is probably metric too.

No way to add a riser block, unless you cut it and weld in an extension
and/or a removable extension plate arrangement.

Craftsman could've had an absolute winner with this one. 1,000,000 sold
and counting, if ONLY they put in a decent motor. Would've costed them
may be $10 extra for the thicker windings.


So there you have it.

  #2   Report Post  
Posted to rec.woodworking
Mike W.
 
Posts: n/a
Default Review of Craftsman's new 12" BS

Thanks for the review... I've been watching for one since they came out.

Based on your review I think I'll wait until I save the extra $200 (cost
and shipping) to get the Grizzly.

Mike W.


wrote:
Got it a few days ago. $255 for CClub members.

Comes in 1 box, small enough to move around by yer self. Minimal
assembly required,
takes no more than 30 mins.

Stand is very sturdy, heavy gage steel.

Overall, paint quality top notch. Inside edges are not deburred.

Cast iron table is truly massive and most impecable in quality.
Tiliting mechanism
is smooth and locks solid. Checked the thing with machinist square - it
is all square.

Overall construction gets 9.9 out of 10. Welded out of heavy gage
steel.

Here's where the .1 went:

- wheels have clip retainers. Out into the trash can they went.
Drilled/tapped 1/4, turned
some caps. Much nicer now

- the blade cut in the table is not @ right angle to the blade. Every
now and then I work on thinner
pieces and having a gap toward in the feeding path is not appreciated.
3/16 or so.


Blade guides are the nicest I've ever seen . All ball bearing, they ARE
micro-adjustable. Rock solid. R&P, smooth, positive locking, alum
extrusion. Blade's back rides on the back of BB, not
on face . AAAA

Takes 1/8 -3/4 blades (adverised as 1/2 max). Tracking adjustment is
very easy. Has a look-through window so that
you can see the blade's position on the upper wheel. Has a
scale/indicator for blade-tension adjustment.

As it is to be expected, the "free' included blade was cr@p. After
cutting may be 40" in 2x4, as I was
adjusting the thing, it quit . May be it was plastic ? Dunno, don't
care and it was expected.

Timberwolf arrived pronto and with it, it shines.

Cutting hight capacity is stated @ 7", is more like 7 1/4 (amazing that
marketing dept didn't
see it and advertize it as such). With a quick look, it can be adjusted
to may be 8" by milling out
a notch in the guide assy. 7" is more than plenty for my needs.



Rip fence is top notch. No play, locks in solid.

Blade length is 89 1/2. Rather odd. TW stocks 90" - it worked just
fine. I also won't hesitate, in a
pinch, silver-solder my own out of 93 1/2. I also have a TIG setup, but
never tried welding blades
with it . Any pointers ?

Don't want to spend $30 on a mobile base (HD has them on sale, BTW). I
will simply weld on
some angle on 2 feet on narrow side and then weld 2 cheap caster to the
angles. THen, to move,
all you have to do is to lift the other side 1/4" or so and it will
roll around with ease. Kind of similar
to the HF's 4x6 arrangement.

2 speed setup. Changing speeds is very easy, no bolts . A hand-crank
releases tension on
the drive belt and then you can move the belt on the pulleys.

All right, it is all downhill from here.

DON'T expect to stick 7" high piece of oak and rip it at 5"/sec.
Don't expect anything faster than 5"/minute. The 3/4 HP motor
(adverised) looks massive, but
is rated at only at meager 7Amp. It ain't no 3/4 in my book.120V only,
no 240v. I opened the motor control assy,
it doesn't look it could be rewired to 240V. Only 3 wires come out of
motor.

On high SFPM setting, motor HAS DIFFICULTY simply spinning the pulleys
with a blade mounted.

Putting a hamster in to drive this thing would probably generate more
power. And cost less too,
few nuts a day.


Now, I can see the smirks disappearing on the faces of those that were
reading this review, thinking about buying this product.

Here's my take. For this price it is a great deal. EVEN after you spend
$160 to add a proper
1 1/2 HP motor. Grizzly . I'd err on side of safety, but 1 HP motor
might work too ($100 @ Grizzly).

The shaft on the stock motor is metric, so is the drive pulley. Will
have to bore to 5/8. Key size
is suspect as well. Good news is that standard 56 will fit in like a
glove. Base mount will
require drilling mounting holes in the base. The stock face mount
pattern is probably metric too.

No way to add a riser block, unless you cut it and weld in an extension
and/or a removable extension plate arrangement.

Craftsman could've had an absolute winner with this one. 1,000,000 sold
and counting, if ONLY they put in a decent motor. Would've costed them
may be $10 extra for the thicker windings.


So there you have it.

Reply
Thread Tools Search this Thread
Search this Thread:

Advanced Search
Display Modes

Posting Rules

Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off
Trackbacks are On
Pingbacks are On
Refbacks are On


Similar Threads
Thread Thread Starter Forum Replies Last Post
Tool Review - Rigid 12" Miter Saw Anthony Metalworking 1 December 13th 05 11:26 PM
Tool Review: Rigid 12" Miter Saw Gunner Asch Metalworking 0 December 10th 05 10:48 PM
deWalt 718 12" SCMS Review Dave Jackson Woodworking 2 November 7th 05 12:40 AM


All times are GMT +1. The time now is 07:06 AM.

Powered by vBulletin® Copyright ©2000 - 2024, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Copyright ©2004-2024 DIYbanter.
The comments are property of their posters.
 

About Us

"It's about DIY & home improvement"