Im Sooo Confussed, Oneway or Stubby lathe
 

george wrote:

Oddly, greater rigidity is touted as one of the advantages of the steel
lathe over iron. I guess it's a bit more of the grinding controversy
all
over again.

Though with stands almost universally cheesier than the lathe, I'm
betting
it's the stand that makes the difference.

"cindy drozda" wrote in message
...

I'm curious that no one responding to this post has said anything
about
the "welded vs. cast" question. The Stubby is a cast
iron/steel machine,
and the OneWay is welded up from tubing and plate. I have never
used a
OneWay myself, but have heard a number of pro turners say that they
don't
like to turn for long periods of time on the OneWay because of the
harmonic vibration in the weldments. Supposedly cast iron is better
at
dampening vibration.




I live a couple of hours away from the Stubby manufacturer and have just put a
deposit on a 1000. I have to wait 3 months but am very excited. I am sure I
have made a good decision but enjoyed this thread.


--

Im Sooo Confussed, Oneway or Stubby lathe
 

On Monday, August 14, 2017 at 1:44:04 PM UTC-5, Treehunter wrote:
george wrote:

Oddly, greater rigidity is touted as one of the advantages of the steel
lathe over iron. I guess it's a bit more of the grinding controversy
all
over again.

Though with stands almost universally cheesier than the lathe, I'm
betting
it's the stand that makes the difference.

"cindy drozda"

I'm curious that no one responding to this post has said anything
about
the "welded vs. cast" question. The Stubby is a cast
iron/steel machine,
and the OneWay is welded up from tubing and plate. I have never
used a
OneWay myself, but have heard a number of pro turners say that they
don't
like to turn for long periods of time on the OneWay because of the
harmonic vibration in the weldments. Supposedly cast iron is better
at
dampening vibration.




I live a couple of hours away from the Stubby manufacturer and have just put a
deposit on a 1000. I have to wait 3 months but am very excited. I am sure I
have made a good decision but enjoyed this thread.


--

Getting a new lathe is always a bit like Christmas when you were a kid. Congrats.