Home |
Search |
Today's Posts |
|
UK diy (uk.d-i-y) For the discussion of all topics related to diy (do-it-yourself) in the UK. All levels of experience and proficency are welcome to join in to ask questions or offer solutions. |
Reply |
|
LinkBack | Thread Tools | Display Modes |
#1
Posted to uk.d-i-y
|
|||
|
|||
Low voltage and mains in same duct
I had assumed that linking sensors in outlying barns to a common burglar
alarm panel would simply be a matter of drawing in cables and connecting up! However, the existing 4" ducts already contain steel wire armoured cables carrying mains supplies. The alarm salesman was adamant that the only way round (other than radio/second set of ducts) is to insert a metal conduit. This is not practicable because of concreted over bends. Radio looks expensive and range iffy (50m+ and not line of sight). Could the requirements of the relevant regulations be met by using SWA for the low voltage circuit? regards -- Tim Lamb |
#2
Posted to uk.d-i-y
|
|||
|
|||
Low voltage and mains in same duct
"Tim Lamb" wrote in message ... I had assumed that linking sensors in outlying barns to a common burglar alarm panel would simply be a matter of drawing in cables and connecting up! However, the existing 4" ducts already contain steel wire armoured cables carrying mains supplies. The alarm salesman was adamant that the only way round (other than radio/second set of ducts) is to insert a metal conduit. This is not practicable because of concreted over bends. Radio looks expensive and range iffy (50m+ and not line of sight). Could the requirements of the relevant regulations be met by using SWA for the low voltage circuit? regards -- Tim Lamb Tim, The way to get around this is to use a mains rated multi core cable. Something such as 1.0mm 8 core SY would be fine. Regards Steve |
#3
Posted to uk.d-i-y
|
|||
|
|||
Low voltage and mains in same duct
In message , Stephen Dawson
writes "Tim Lamb" wrote in message .. . I had assumed that linking sensors in outlying barns to a common burglar alarm panel would simply be a matter of drawing in cables and connecting up! However, the existing 4" ducts already contain steel wire armoured cables carrying mains supplies. The alarm salesman was adamant that the only way round (other than radio/second set of ducts) is to insert a metal conduit. This is not practicable because of concreted over bends. Radio looks expensive and range iffy (50m+ and not line of sight). Could the requirements of the relevant regulations be met by using SWA for the low voltage circuit? regards -- Tim Lamb Tim, The way to get around this is to use a mains rated multi core cable. Something such as 1.0mm 8 core SY would be fine. Oh! Is this because the insulation of the low voltage cores is adequate for exposure to the mains supply? The IEE regs. (fifteenth edition, I know I'm just old) calls for an earthed metallic screen between the two supplies. regards -- Tim Lamb |
#4
Posted to uk.d-i-y
|
|||
|
|||
Low voltage and mains in same duct
In article , Tim Lamb
writes In message , Stephen Dawson writes "Tim Lamb" wrote in message . .. I had assumed that linking sensors in outlying barns to a common burglar alarm panel would simply be a matter of drawing in cables and connecting up! However, the existing 4" ducts already contain steel wire armoured cables carrying mains supplies. The alarm salesman was adamant that the only way round (other than radio/second set of ducts) is to insert a metal conduit. This is not practicable because of concreted over bends. Radio looks expensive and range iffy (50m+ and not line of sight). Could the requirements of the relevant regulations be met by using SWA for the low voltage circuit? regards -- Tim Lamb Tim, The way to get around this is to use a mains rated multi core cable. Something such as 1.0mm 8 core SY would be fine. Oh! Is this because the insulation of the low voltage cores is adequate for exposure to the mains supply? The IEE regs. (fifteenth edition, I know I'm just old) calls for an earthed metallic screen between the two supplies. It has certainly been reported here that where one cable in a group is carrying mains then all the cables in the group must be mains rated. This does seem a bit harsh when the mains cable is SWA with armour as earth but I'm not sure whether this would meet earthed metallic screen requirement you describe. As an aside, I'm not sure where the 'all mains rated' requirement spawned from as the sheath of a mains rated cable is finger safe for contact, why should the contact of a low (safety, extra or whatever) voltage cable require a more strenuous restriction. -- fred Plusnet - I hope you like vanilla |
#5
Posted to uk.d-i-y
|
|||
|
|||
Low voltage and mains in same duct
In message , fred writes
In article , Tim Lamb writes In message , Stephen Dawson writes "Tim Lamb" wrote in message .. . The IEE regs. (fifteenth edition, I know I'm just old) calls for an earthed metallic screen between the two supplies. It has certainly been reported here that where one cable in a group is carrying mains then all the cables in the group must be mains rated. This does seem a bit harsh when the mains cable is SWA with armour as earth but I'm not sure whether this would meet earthed metallic screen requirement you describe. As an aside, I'm not sure where the 'all mains rated' requirement spawned from as the sheath of a mains rated cable is finger safe for contact, why should the contact of a low (safety, extra or whatever) voltage cable require a more strenuous restriction. I suppose it is not unreasonable that an engineer called in to work on what he believes is a safe *low voltage* system might be at risk from insulation failures. In my case, mice may gain entry to the ducts. ISTR earlier regulations calling for all cable insulation in a mixed bunch to be rated at the highest voltage encountered. I think I'll go with the mains rated multicore as suggested unless anyone knows different? regards -- Tim Lamb |
#6
Posted to uk.d-i-y
|
|||
|
|||
Low voltage and mains in same duct
Tim Lamb wrote:
In message , Stephen Dawson writes "Tim Lamb" wrote in message ... I had assumed that linking sensors in outlying barns to a common burglar alarm panel would simply be a matter of drawing in cables and connecting up! However, the existing 4" ducts already contain steel wire armoured cables carrying mains supplies. The alarm salesman was adamant that the only way round (other than radio/second set of ducts) is to insert a metal conduit. This is not practicable because of concreted over bends. Radio looks expensive and range iffy (50m+ and not line of sight). Could the requirements of the relevant regulations be met by using SWA for the low voltage circuit? regards -- Tim Lamb Tim, The way to get around this is to use a mains rated multi core cable. Something such as 1.0mm 8 core SY would be fine. Oh! Is this because the insulation of the low voltage cores is adequate for exposure to the mains supply? The IEE regs. (fifteenth edition, I know I'm just old) calls for an earthed metallic screen between the two supplies. regards IIRC the issue is to have TWO insulants each capable of taking full mains voltage between HV and LV. |
#7
Posted to uk.d-i-y
|
|||
|
|||
Low voltage and mains in same duct
If converters are available, have you considered the option of using a
fibre optic cable to the barn? If the strength member is kevlar you would have totally non-metalic cable and hence on problem. |
#8
Posted to uk.d-i-y
|
|||
|
|||
Low voltage and mains in same duct
If converters are available, have you considered the option of using
a fibre optic cable to the barn? If the strength member is kevlar you would have totally non-metalic cable and hence no problem. |
#9
Posted to uk.d-i-y
|
|||
|
|||
Low voltage and mains in same duct
In message
, 1501 writes If converters are available, have you considered the option of using a fibre optic cable to the barn? If the strength member is kevlar you would have totally non-metalic cable and hence on problem. Fibre optic is way outside my experience so not considered. I had wondered about using relays to isolate the sensors from supplies in the ducts but would still have the issue of putting others at risk (an engineer called in to replace a PIR sensor would not expect to find 240V in the control box). I'm trying to do a cheap job:-) regards -- Tim Lamb |
#10
Posted to uk.d-i-y
|
|||
|
|||
Low voltage and mains in same duct
Tim Lamb wrote:
In message , Stephen Dawson writes "Tim Lamb" wrote in message .. . I had assumed that linking sensors in outlying barns to a common burglar alarm panel would simply be a matter of drawing in cables and connecting up! However, the existing 4" ducts already contain steel wire armoured cables carrying mains supplies. The alarm salesman was adamant that the only way round (other than radio/second set of ducts) is to insert a metal conduit. This is not practicable because of concreted over bends. Radio looks expensive and range iffy (50m+ and not line of sight). Could the requirements of the relevant regulations be met by using SWA for the low voltage circuit? regards -- Tim Lamb Tim, The way to get around this is to use a mains rated multi core cable. Something such as 1.0mm 8 core SY would be fine. Oh! Is this because the insulation of the low voltage cores is adequate for exposure to the mains supply? The IEE regs. (fifteenth edition, I know I'm just old) calls for an earthed metallic screen between the two supplies. regards And the swa armour provides that. The issue with sharing isnt the cable runs per se, but rather what happens where cables are terminated. Terminate both in the same box and you've got a real risk if any cable comes loose. Terminate them in separate boxes and you've got risk if the LV insulated cable touches bare mains terminations, since its not mains rated. NT |
#11
Posted to uk.d-i-y
|
|||
|
|||
Low voltage and mains in same duct
|
#12
Posted to uk.d-i-y
|
|||
|
|||
Low voltage and mains in same duct
Tim Lamb wrote:
Could the requirements of the relevant regulations be met by using SWA for the low voltage circuit? Firstly we need to be clear that low voltage (LV) means mains and that the alarm circuits are ELV. In my view there is no problem here. In the 16th ed. regs 528-01-02 is relevant and one of the permissible options is: "(iii) for a multicore cable or cord the cores of the band I [ELV] circuit shall be separated from the cores of the band II [mains] circuit by an earthed metal screen of equivalent current carrying capacity to that of the largest core of the band II circuit." Provided that we're talking about smallish SWA sizes (certainly up to 16 mm^2 or so) the armour of the mains cables will almost certainly have the necessary current carrying capacity to comply with that and the ELV wiring will not need to be mains insulated. In the 17th ed. the same voltage band definitions apply and reg. 528.1 (vi) says much the same thing. If the problem is political rather than technical then using a 300/500 V rated multicore flexible cable (something like 'YY' control cable, 0.75 mm^2) for the alarm would comply with the requirement for both cables to be mains insulated. You don't need armoured multicore for the alarm. -- Andy |
#13
Posted to uk.d-i-y
|
|||
|
|||
Low voltage and mains in same duct
In message , Andy Wade
writes Tim Lamb wrote: Could the requirements of the relevant regulations be met by using SWA for the low voltage circuit? Firstly we need to be clear that low voltage (LV) means mains and that the alarm circuits are ELV. OK:-) In my view there is no problem here. In the 16th ed. regs 528-01-02 is relevant and one of the permissible options is: "(iii) for a multicore cable or cord the cores of the band I [ELV] circuit shall be separated from the cores of the band II [mains] circuit by an earthed metal screen of equivalent current carrying capacity to that of the largest core of the band II circuit." Provided that we're talking about smallish SWA sizes (certainly up to 16 mm^2 or so) the armour of the mains cables will almost certainly have the necessary current carrying capacity to comply with that and the ELV wiring will not need to be mains insulated. Good. Probably 16mm^2 max. In the 17th ed. the same voltage band definitions apply and reg. 528.1 (vi) says much the same thing. OK If the problem is political rather than technical then using a 300/500 V rated multicore flexible cable (something like 'YY' control cable, 0.75 mm^2) for the alarm would comply with the requirement for both cables to be mains insulated. You don't need armoured multicore for the alarm. I think *political* in that Aegis policy is intended to provide safe working conditions for their staff. I plan to purchase the various elements and install in stages myself. Thanks to all who have contributed. regards -- Tim Lamb |
Reply |
Thread Tools | Search this Thread |
Display Modes | |
|
|
Similar Threads | ||||
Thread | Forum | |||
UK mains voltage 240...220..? | UK diy | |||
Mains Voltage | UK diy | |||
Downlighters - mains or low voltage | UK diy | |||
LED mains voltage light fittings | UK diy | |||
Mains Voltage fluctations | UK diy |