Home |
Search |
Today's Posts |
|
Home Repair (alt.home.repair) For all homeowners and DIYers with many experienced tradesmen. Solve your toughest home fix-it problems. |
Reply |
|
LinkBack | Thread Tools | Display Modes |
|
#1
|
|||
|
|||
Dish/Direct TV vs Cable
I'd like to hear from various customers of all the different methods of
receiving TV stations regarding cost and service satisfaction. I heard there is a current sale with Direct TV where you get service and install on 4 TV's for $50. I don't know if this is as good as it sounds or if the sale is still even on. Any replies are appreciated. Also does the best system depend on geographic area? I'm in Phila. PA area. Sherry |
#2
|
|||
|
|||
I had Dish Network, dropped them and went to cable to get local channels and
internet. Seems they are broadcasting local channels now, so that objection has been over come. I like my internet service, other than that I would drop cable like a rock and go back to Dish! Cable here brags about no loss due to the weather compared to dish. Well every time a little thunder boomer rolls through cable is running weather advisories, fine, I think the feds require it, but for every little rain drop? On the other hand, dish would lose signal maybe once or twice a year during torrential rain. So I guess you could say I was very satisfied with Dish Network, kind of, almost, sort of satisfied with cable! Greg "FreespiritedFem" wrote in message ... I'd like to hear from various customers of all the different methods of receiving TV stations regarding cost and service satisfaction. I heard there is a current sale with Direct TV where you get service and install on 4 TV's for $50. I don't know if this is as good as it sounds or if the sale is still even on. Any replies are appreciated. Also does the best system depend on geographic area? I'm in Phila. PA area. Sherry |
#3
|
|||
|
|||
Greg, I see what you mean. Positive and negative about both. I didn't realize
you don't get the storm warnings with a dish. I get them with the news channels on cable. Don't remember if I get them with others. I don't think on TV Land but maybe I just don't notice, taking them for granted. We pay 139 a month for all cable stations but it's not digital, so if the dish is almost as good and a lot less cost, that's probably better for us. Thanks for replying. Sherry |
#4
|
|||
|
|||
We get "local channels" (i.e., the local outlets of the major networks)
via DirecTV, and they broadcast the storm warnings. What we don't get are the truly local channels such as public access and broadcasts of city council and school board meetings. We've lost our signal twice in the year we've had DirecTV, but only during torrential rain, not during normal rainfall. But the cable companies are receiving their signals from satellites too, so sometimes the signal they receive (and pass on to you) will deteriorate too; the only difference is that their dishes are bigger. With any kind of satellite system, your signal quality will depend on how well your dish can "see" the satellite, so nearby trees and tall buildings need to be taken into consideration. Check all the available services and packages and figure out which gives you the channels you want for the most affordable price. Perce On 12/09/04 11:17 pm PaNjDeFemale tossed the following ingredients into the ever-growing pot of cybersoup: Greg, I see what you mean. Positive and negative about both. I didn't realize you don't get the storm warnings with a dish. I get them with the news channels on cable. Don't remember if I get them with others. I don't think on TV Land but maybe I just don't notice, taking them for granted. We pay 139 a month for all cable stations but it's not digital, so if the dish is almost as good and a lot less cost, that's probably better for us. Thanks for replying. Sherry |
#5
|
|||
|
|||
"Percival P. Cassidy" wrote in message ... We get "local channels" (i.e., the local outlets of the major networks) via DirecTV, and they broadcast the storm warnings. What we don't get are the truly local channels such as public access and broadcasts of city council and school board meetings. You get the warnings the local channels broadcast, you would get them on an antenna too. Our cable breaks in on whatever channel you are on and goes to the weather channel so they can tell you to run and hide because it is raining outside. If thet ran a banner at the bottem of the screen it would be ok, but they interupt what ever show you are watching and tune to the weather channel, you can not turn back to your movie, sports, what ever, they run the show. You might be watching a pay per view movie and they will interupt the show! It ticks me off! Greg |
#6
|
|||
|
|||
On 12/10/2004 2:16 PM US(ET), Greg O took fingers to keys, and typed the
following: "Percival P. Cassidy" wrote in message ... We get "local channels" (i.e., the local outlets of the major networks) via DirecTV, and they broadcast the storm warnings. What we don't get are the truly local channels such as public access and broadcasts of city council and school board meetings. You get the warnings the local channels broadcast, you would get them on an antenna too. Our cable breaks in on whatever channel you are on and goes to the weather channel so they can tell you to run and hide because it is raining outside. If thet ran a banner at the bottem of the screen it would be ok, but they interupt what ever show you are watching and tune to the weather channel, you can not turn back to your movie, sports, what ever, they run the show. You might be watching a pay per view movie and they will interupt the show! It ticks me off! Greg That's a 'feature' of your particular cable company and perhaps your local govt. The local govt. has a say in what, and how, cable will be distributed ( I want to say 'broadcast', but that's not the proper terminology with cable). Where I live, with Time-Warner cable, if there is a weather alert, they have the scrolling banner on the bottom of the screen, *except* on any premium channels. |
#7
|
|||
|
|||
I just switched from cable to Dish no way I would go back I have a PVR that
takes care of 2 TVs. I have a TV in the bedroom and no box at all. It can record 100hr of TV and I can pause and rewind live TV since it has 2 tuners I can do PIP. Not quite as good as Tivo but I felt the package was better from DISH. I still have cable internet but have been toying with DSL but Comcast draws you in with the 3 MB download speed which works pretty well where I have probably 1/2-2/3rd of the homes in my neighborhood have cable access but the backbone is new so it does not bog down. Between Dish and Direct you need to look at the packages they offer and what fits your viewing. Each has pluses and minuses. Dish now has Sirius radio also. I don't use it but you might. Wayne "FreespiritedFem" wrote in message ... I'd like to hear from various customers of all the different methods of receiving TV stations regarding cost and service satisfaction. I heard there is a current sale with Direct TV where you get service and install on 4 TV's for $50. I don't know if this is as good as it sounds or if the sale is still even on. Any replies are appreciated. Also does the best system depend on geographic area? I'm in Phila. PA area. Sherry |
#8
|
|||
|
|||
"wayne" wrote:
I just switched from cable to Dish no way I would go back I have a PVR that takes care of 2 TVs. I have a TV in the bedroom and no box at all. It can record 100hr of TV and I can pause and rewind live TV since it has 2 tuners I can do PIP. Do you have the DVR522? If so, do you find that the audio gets out of sync with the video when playing recordings? They keep saying they know about the problem, but they haven't fixed it yet. Other than that, I love Dish Network and the DVR. And it's a lot cheaper than cable in my area. -- Ray Heindl (remove the Xs to reply to: ) |
#9
|
|||
|
|||
Ray, at least one thumbs up for Dish Network in particular with your reply.
We'll do a little more investigating. Thank you. Sherry |
#10
|
|||
|
|||
Wayne, I know what Tivo is but not the other two anachonyms you mentioned. PIP
is picture in picture? PVR? We have 5 television sets so don't know if this will destroy any good package deals. I know there was a deal for 4 tv's. We've been falling for the ads by cable showing the dish so vulnerable to elements so far, which seemed reasonable, although our cable has been down for several hours at a time several times a year. We just didn't think anything was better. Is any particular dish preferred, especially as far as quality and reliability? Direct TV vs dish? Next maybe to investigate the current offers. Thanks for your reply. Sherry |
#11
|
|||
|
|||
PVR/DVR = Personal Video Recorder/Digital Video Recorder
Perce On 12/09/04 11:30 pm PaNjDeFemale tossed the following ingredients into the ever-growing pot of cybersoup: Wayne, I know what Tivo is but not the other two anachonyms you mentioned. PIP is picture in picture? PVR? |
#12
|
|||
|
|||
FreespiritedFem wrote:
I'd like to hear from various customers of all the different methods of receiving TV stations regarding cost and service satisfaction. I heard there is a current sale with Direct TV where you get service and install on 4 TV's for $50. I don't know if this is as good as it sounds or if the sale is still even on. Any replies are appreciated. Also does the best system depend on geographic area? I'm in Phila. PA area. Sherry I've got Directv and am happy with it. I've been with them for about 10 years now and have only had a few episodes of signal fade due to extremely heavy rainfall. Frankly, Cablevision had more service outages. You should be able to find installation of four receivers for free if you're a new customer. $50 would buy you TIVO for one of those receivers if you wanted that. But for just four ordinary receivers: free. Of course, you'll have to obligate yourself to a service contract for a year, but so what? You've got to get your content from somebody, right? Seeing as how you live in a city, you'll be able to get your local stations on Directv. Not all markets do, but if Wilmington, NC can, I know Philadelphia will. -- Mortimer Schnerd, RN |
#13
|
|||
|
|||
Mortimer, if you've read all my posts in this thread, you see I know basically
nothing about anything but cable TV, but hearing such glowing things about Dish Network and Direct TV I think it's time my household became more educated, especially since we pay 139 monthly even without digital. We're curious as to how many movie channels, if any, come with a basic dish package. Also we need to keep our 5 TV sets operating with full package of movie channels, etc, which we are dependent on. HBO and Starz are favorites at my home. How many channels do you get? Thanks for your reply. Sherry |
#14
|
|||
|
|||
I subscribed to both cable TV and cable internet simultainiously. When
Comcast took it over I switched to Direct TV, but kept my cable internet service, because cable kept on increasing it's subscription rates at least once a year and I got fed up with being screwed over. Then, about a year and a half ago, I got notified by Comcast, my internet provider, that if I didn't subscribe to cable TV and the internet they would increase my internet subscription by almost $20.00/month. I emailed them telling them I wouldn't be strong-armed into buying their cable TV service and if they persisted I would go to DSL. I received a response pretty much telling me that it was the policy and they were not going to change, so I gladly switched.---cable still arrogantly treats consumers as if they are the only service in town. I'll never go back to cable. Direct TV is great and I've never had any problems with it. "FreespiritedFem" wrote in message ... I'd like to hear from various customers of all the different methods of receiving TV stations regarding cost and service satisfaction. I heard there is a current sale with Direct TV where you get service and install on 4 TV's for $50. I don't know if this is as good as it sounds or if the sale is still even on. Any replies are appreciated. Also does the best system depend on geographic area? I'm in Phila. PA area. Sherry |
#15
|
|||
|
|||
Ron, had no idea cable used such arrogant manipulations. I'm wondering if the
dish programming shows problems caused by CABLE as cable does with the dish! Of course over the years we've seen cable ads showing dishes wiped out by inclement weather and it looked reasonable. With something sitting on a roof, porch, etc. it does seem vulnerable. Apparently if the dish had those problems, they've been overcome. The replies in this thread are evidence of this and we have no one else to ask about this. Husband said friends from New Jersey all love the dish over cable in every way but I can't go by what they say. We needed objective opinions and we're grateful to have them. Thanks for your reply. Sherry |
#16
|
|||
|
|||
Here on Long Island ,NY Cablevision has a special "triple play"
promotion. You get digital cable TV, high speed internet, and Voice over IP unlimited phone service, each for $30 for the first year. After that, it goes up slightly for the second year, then it goes to full price for the third year, which right now would be about $63 for TV, $45 for internet, and $35 for the phone, which is $143 for the month, which is not bad IMO. I'm happy with the service. |
#17
|
|||
|
|||
Mikepier, you're doing great for having cable. We pay 139 monthly just for
cable on 5 tv sets with 5 movie channels -- no digital. Local phone is about 60 monthly and ATT for long distance ends up about 16 monthly. I don't have the AOL figure as another household memeber handles that but it's in the 20's monthly. So we're waaaayyy above what you pay. Is everything else cheaper there? hehe! We have comcast here (formerly Suburban Cable). I assume also you're happy with the service. Thanks for your reply. Sherry |
#18
|
|||
|
|||
Direct TV would be ok if you didn't have to have a receiver for each tv.
Why can't they have one central tv converter and use a different remote for each tv set. Tom "FreespiritedFem" wrote in message ... I'd like to hear from various customers of all the different methods of receiving TV stations regarding cost and service satisfaction. I heard there is a current sale with Direct TV where you get service and install on 4 TV's for $50. I don't know if this is as good as it sounds or if the sale is still even on. Any replies are appreciated. Also does the best system depend on geographic area? I'm in Phila. PA area. Sherry |
#19
|
|||
|
|||
Tom, well we have a "jerrold box" for each our 5 TV sets. Don't know if that's
the counterpart to the receiver you speak of. Dish still sounds better than cable from the replies so far. We'll check out offers. Thanks for your reply. Sherry |
#20
|
|||
|
|||
I'm in the Philly suburbs. I have had DishNetwork for over 6 years. I have
been very happy with their service. Make sure you get DVR receivers, at least one for your primary viewing location. I have a model 721 and model 501. Make sure Dish has a programming package that is to your liking. DirecTV may be better for you if they have a channel Dish doesn't and its one you really want. DirecTV has NFL Season Pass or something like that, gets you all NFL games. Dish does not. Dish has NHL and MLB season passes. (Not that NHL matters right now). Make your decision based upon programming then look for the best deal for that vendor. I have used www.dishdepot.com with good success. "FreespiritedFem" wrote in message ... I'd like to hear from various customers of all the different methods of receiving TV stations regarding cost and service satisfaction. I heard there is a current sale with Direct TV where you get service and install on 4 TV's for $50. I don't know if this is as good as it sounds or if the sale is still even on. Any replies are appreciated. Also does the best system depend on geographic area? I'm in Phila. PA area. Sherry |
#21
|
|||
|
|||
I'd also figure out how HDTV fits into your plans. Currently, many
cable providers offer the local networks in HD, while the sat providers, do not. With Sat, you still need to use an antenna to receive the locals in HD. The sats do have an assortment of 8 or so other HD channes, eg Discovery, HBO, etc avail in HD as do many of the cable companies. And don't forget internet access. By bundling that into the deal, cable becomes more attractive. |
#22
|
|||
|
|||
|
#23
|
|||
|
|||
What kind of internet access do you have for $14? Sure sounds like
dial up, in which case you're comparing apples to oranges. |
#24
|
|||
|
|||
On Thu, 09 Dec 2004 18:18:03 GMT, Phisherman wrote:
Cable TV with cable Internet costs $85+taxes here. Dish is close to $40 (minimum setup) and my AT&T Internet is $14 a month. For about $100 (phone, TV and internet): Internet - 256K Internet connection for T1 and T2 only pay a few bucks more, TV - All local channels, digital tier, HBO and sport. |
#25
|
|||
|
|||
Phisherman, we don't yet have an HDTV set. We have ordinary ones as we're not
into TV features that much. We're interested in content and number of channels available because of 3 people with diverse TV interests. We're going to look over the offerings as well as cost and service. Hope we don't have a conflict because of differences within the household. :/ Thanks for your reply. Sherry |
#26
|
|||
|
|||
I have used both cable and DirecTV. I rarely encountered weather
related problem with cable (when I was in New York City and in Fort Lee-New Jersey). Since I have switched to DirecTV, I have weather related problem whenever there is mild-to-heavy rain. This may have to do with the fact that my house is not tall (2 floors, relatively flat roof), and there is a not-so-short tree south of the house. The other thing is that DirecTV requires a decoder box at each TV. If I remember correctly, each additional decoder box costs additional monthly fee. I used cable basic service and I didn't need a decoder box. The use of decoder box not only costs more but also causes some inconveniences. For example, I cannot use picture-in-picture any more because that would require 2 decoder boxes in one TV, and I cannot watch TV in more than 2 locations in my house because I am restricted to 2 decoder boxes (and I don't want to pay extra). Of course, this point is irrelevant if you want to watch premium channels in cable or if you want to subscribe to HDTV cable service or your local cable requires you to use a decoder box even for basic cable service (such as in New York City); in these three cases, you will need a decoder box, and cable will not be better than DirecTV in this espect. I am still staying with DirecTV because a family member wants to watch a channel that cable doesn't carry. Otherwise, I would have switched back to cable. Jay Chan |
#27
|
|||
|
|||
|
#29
|
|||
|
|||
Dan, basic cable here is probably a little more than your cost but our issue is
3 viewers with diverse TV viewing interests. I don't care about Court TV, for example, but mom would miss not having it. Also she loves the home decorating shows and my husband watches dopey shows like "favorite TV bloopers" which mom and I would never watch. Necessary -- large package to satisfy all of us. Thanks for your reply. Sherry |
#30
|
|||
|
|||
Paul, guess what's to our southwest?????!!! Next door neighbor's HUGE sycamore
tree! Leaves are up to 14" across and many end up in our yard due to mysterious wind gusts isolated on our property. Maybe this will all be moot for now as we're moving in about 6 months. We have comcast and doubt we could get a deal like yours. Where are you from, BTW? We tried to get digital on one TV set, a very basic Sylvania VCR combo and they couldn't connect digital to it. We have a newer TV now but the others are all older and maybe none are compatible with digital. So we do have many questions for the dish companies. Thanks for your reply. Sherry |
#31
|
|||
|
|||
|
#32
|
|||
|
|||
FreespiritedFem wrote:
I'd like to hear from various customers of all the different methods of receiving TV stations regarding cost and service satisfaction. I heard there is a current sale with Direct TV where you get service and install on 4 TV's for $50. I don't know if this is as good as it sounds or if the sale is still even on. Any replies are appreciated. Also does the best system depend on geographic area? I'm in Phila. PA area. Sherry Hi, I am on digital cable TV/Internet combo. I know dish is affected by weather conditions. Some does not provide local programming. I have over 400 channels of HD digital video, music, pay per view, etc. Tony |
#33
|
|||
|
|||
FreespiritedFem wrote:
I'd like to hear from various customers of all the different methods of receiving TV stations regarding cost and service satisfaction. I heard there is a current sale with Direct TV where you get service and install on 4 TV's for $50. I don't know if this is as good as it sounds or if the sale is still even on. Any replies are appreciated. Also does the best system depend on geographic area? I'm in Phila. PA area. Sherry I switched to DirecTV since it had become cheaper than cable. (price had gone up steadily since Comcast took over the local co-op) I love the fact that I now have a dual-tuner Tivo instead of a single-tuner standalone one. I like that I get Comedy Central on East Coast time, even though I'm on the West Coast. I don't like that I have to plug the Tivo into the phone (the standalone one I had before can use a network connection) Is the $50 you mention the installation fee or the monthly cost? If it's the installation fee, shop around. You can get free installation for up to 4 rooms, at http://www.expertsatellite.com/ for example. |
#34
|
|||
|
|||
|
#35
|
|||
|
|||
Jason wrote:
that offers this if you are a football fan like myself. Also , when local channels were added, I have to add a additional Dish, so two dishes instead of one, check into this. Dish Network....the cheapest of the bunch, no NFL Sunday Ticket, only one dish. Not necessarily. DirecTV can give you an oval dish with a triple LNB, allowing it to look at 3 satellites at the same time. My neighbor just got Dish Network, and for some reason they put 2 dishes on his roof, pointing in different directions. |
Reply |
Thread Tools | Search this Thread |
Display Modes | |
|
|
Similar Threads | ||||
Thread | Forum | |||
Low Voltage lighting cable size | UK diy | |||
slightly OT NTL/Telewest cable descrambler | UK diy | |||
Chasing cable for wall mounted plasma | UK diy | |||
Need Cable TV expert - I have questions | Electronics Repair | |||
Routeing Electrical FTE cable | UK diy |