Home |
Search |
Today's Posts |
![]() |
|
Home Repair (alt.home.repair) For all homeowners and DIYers with many experienced tradesmen. Solve your toughest home fix-it problems. |
Reply |
|
LinkBack | Thread Tools | Display Modes |
|
#1
![]()
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
![]()
Hi,
Do filters vary in quality? Will I be disappointed if I buy filters for FiltersFast.com? Theirs are much cheaper than Filtrete and they claim that they are more efficient. What's the downside? Thanks! Sam |
#2
![]()
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
![]() "Sam Takoy" wrote in message ... Hi, Do filters vary in quality? Will I be disappointed if I buy filters for FiltersFast.com? Theirs are much cheaper than Filtrete and they claim that they are more efficient. What's the downside? Thanks! Sam Yeah they do. Some block more air causing your a/c to work harder. Some claim to be hypoallergenic. Personally, I get the cheapest I can find and change it often. I never use pleated because of the cost and my a/c runs more efficiently with a flat filter. |
#3
![]()
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
![]()
On Aug 11, 11:56*am, "JimT" wrote:
"Sam Takoy" wrote in message ... Hi, Do filters vary in quality? Will I be disappointed if I buy filters for FiltersFast.com? Theirs are much cheaper than Filtrete and they claim that they are more efficient. What's the downside? Thanks! Sam Yeah they do. Some block more air causing your a/c to work harder. Some claim to be hypoallergenic. Personally, I get the cheapest I can find and change it often. I never use pleated because of the cost and my a/c runs more efficiently with a flat filter. The choice of which filter to use is a trade off between operating cost of the system versus replacement cost of the filters. A filter which will trap finer particulates will require more energy to run the system since it introduces additional pressure drop in the return duct work, upstream of the blower. A filter which will allow larger particle to pass will eventually allow a build up to plate out on the evaporator coils, which will eventually require an acid cleaning. The optimal filter selection is question that an unbiased laboratory could determine on the test bench. My guess is that this question has been answered already and can be found in the technical literature, but will take a little effort to root out. Perhaps Consumer Reports magazine has addressed this issue. JoeG |
#4
![]()
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
![]() "GROVER" wrote in message ... On Aug 11, 11:56 am, "JimT" wrote: "Sam Takoy" wrote in message ... Hi, Do filters vary in quality? Will I be disappointed if I buy filters for FiltersFast.com? Theirs are much cheaper than Filtrete and they claim that they are more efficient. What's the downside? Thanks! Sam Yeah they do. Some block more air causing your a/c to work harder. Some claim to be hypoallergenic. Personally, I get the cheapest I can find and change it often. I never use pleated because of the cost and my a/c runs more efficiently with a flat filter. The choice of which filter to use is a trade off between operating cost of the system versus replacement cost of the filters. A filter which will trap finer particulates will require more energy to run the system since it introduces additional pressure drop in the return duct work, upstream of the blower. A filter which will allow larger particle to pass will eventually allow a build up to plate out on the evaporator coils, which will eventually require an acid cleaning. The optimal filter selection is question that an unbiased laboratory could determine on the test bench. My guess is that this question has been answered already and can be found in the technical literature, but will take a little effort to root out. Perhaps Consumer Reports magazine has addressed this issue. JoeG === CR Sept 2010 has a review of Filtrete and the MPR 2200 scored 67 out of 100. Not a very in-depth review. |
#5
![]()
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
![]()
On Aug 11, 11:56*am, "JimT" wrote:
"Sam Takoy" wrote in message ... Hi, Do filters vary in quality? Will I be disappointed if I buy filters for FiltersFast.com? Theirs are much cheaper than Filtrete and they claim that they are more efficient. What's the downside? Thanks! Sam Yeah they do. Some block more air causing your a/c to work harder. Some claim to be hypoallergenic. Personally, I get the cheapest I can find and change it often. I never use pleated because of the cost and my a/c runs more efficiently with a flat filter. I can only imagine what you evaporator core looks like. Hell, why don't you just use horse hair since it's washable and save some money? |
#6
![]()
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
![]() "Ron" wrote in message ... On Aug 11, 11:56 am, "JimT" wrote: "Sam Takoy" wrote in message ... Hi, Do filters vary in quality? Will I be disappointed if I buy filters for FiltersFast.com? Theirs are much cheaper than Filtrete and they claim that they are more efficient. What's the downside? Thanks! Sam Yeah they do. Some block more air causing your a/c to work harder. Some claim to be hypoallergenic. Personally, I get the cheapest I can find and change it often. I never use pleated because of the cost and my a/c runs more efficiently with a flat filter. I can only imagine what you evaporator core looks like. Hell, why don't you just use horse hair since it's washable and save some money? === heh You're not real bright are you? |
#7
![]()
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
![]()
On Aug 11, 4:13*pm, "JimT" wrote:
"Ron" wrote in message ... On Aug 11, 11:56 am, "JimT" wrote: "Sam Takoy" wrote in message ... Hi, Do filters vary in quality? Will I be disappointed if I buy filters for FiltersFast.com? Theirs are much cheaper than Filtrete and they claim that they are more efficient. What's the downside? Thanks! Sam Yeah they do. Some block more air causing your a/c to work harder. Some claim to be hypoallergenic. Personally, I get the cheapest I can find and change it often. I never use pleated because of the cost and my a/c runs more efficiently with a flat filter. I can only imagine what you evaporator core looks like. Hell, why don't you just use horse hair since it's washable and save some money? === heh You're not real bright are you? Apparently you're the dim wit if you don't think all kind of **** is being sucked into your EC. . |
#8
![]()
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
![]() "Ron" wrote in message ... On Aug 11, 4:13 pm, "JimT" wrote: "Ron" wrote in message ... On Aug 11, 11:56 am, "JimT" wrote: "Sam Takoy" wrote in message ... Hi, Do filters vary in quality? Will I be disappointed if I buy filters for FiltersFast.com? Theirs are much cheaper than Filtrete and they claim that they are more efficient. What's the downside? Thanks! Sam Yeah they do. Some block more air causing your a/c to work harder. Some claim to be hypoallergenic. Personally, I get the cheapest I can find and change it often. I never use pleated because of the cost and my a/c runs more efficiently with a flat filter. I can only imagine what you evaporator core looks like. Hell, why don't you just use horse hair since it's washable and save some money? === heh You're not real bright are you? Apparently you're the dim wit if you don't think all kind of **** is being sucked into your EC. . ====== http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wFY8AupDK3w Some of us are a little handier than others. :-) |
#9
![]()
Posted to alt.home.repair
|
|||
|
|||
![]()
On Aug 11, 4:31*pm, Sam Takoy wrote:
Hi, Do filters vary in quality? Will I be disappointed if I buy filters for FiltersFast.com? Theirs are much cheaper than Filtrete and they claim that they are more efficient. What's the downside? Thanks! Sam There are differing technologies with air filters. Some filters act just like a "strainer". Some are paper (the cheaper ones) Some have a material on fibres that picks up particals like a glue almost. (several technologies of this alone). Some enlarge the area of the filter by folding or pleating. Some are multilayer, the first layer picks up coarse particals and further layers pick up progressively smaller particals. They are all affected by humidity too. Some work better on different sorts of dust. Some you can vacuum clean(er), some you can't. Some can be washed but you don't see these much these days. This means that for different situations different filters perform differently. All you can do is try them. Ideally your plant should be fitted with a "U" tube water guage (or an inclined guage)so you can monitor what's happening. |
Reply |
Thread Tools | Search this Thread |
Display Modes | |
|
|