Adam wrote:
The caulk I used is Color Caulk Premium Tile & Fixture Caulk. It has a
picture of a rooster as the logo.
Has anyone else had a bad experience with this brand?
I will look for GE Silicone II in Bright While to match my grout, and
it sounds like I need to scrape the works off and start over.
Still open to any other opinions though.

I am not sure what the original question was but I have had excellent
results with GE Silicon II caulk. Anything with latex in it should be
avoided, based on my experience. I used to get cheap caulk but now I
look for the most expensive and so far I am pleased with the results.