Mox-Nix. Neither one is offering any measurable advantage over the other.
Both ares low output, small storage compressors which can serve light duty
useage quite well and won't take up a ton of room. I would be concerned
for
the 5.8cfm rating though. You're going to be very limited in what you can
do with this compressor. The key is that these will support light duty.

I think the key is 120v vs 220v. The compressors mentioned by the OP are
about average output for 15 amp units. Since both units he was looking at
were 120v units, I'm assuming he doesn't have 220v available.