View Single Post
  #91   Report Post  
J. Clarke
 
Posts: n/a
Default

J wrote:

If the choice was that or 1600 bucks for a new saw, then the answer

is
obvious.

Why would that be the only choice? Do you buy a new saw when you
have an accident on it?

If the accident does $100 worth of damage to the saw then the choice
is to
pay the $100 to fix it or to get a new saw. Same situation.

??? really?


Yes, really. The sawstop fires, you now have a saw that won't run until

you
fix it, same as if anything else went wrong with it.


I thought you said the choice was to buy a new saw for $1600? That is why
I said really.
Which one is it?


Huh? Where did I say that? If you look at the third line of this post you
will see that I said "If the choice was that or 1600 bucks for a new
saw . . ." The part that you snipped clearly indicates that the "that" in
that sentence was "pay $100 for a new Sawstop cartridge".

An equally valid choice would be pay $100 or have a peanut butter
and jelly sandwich rammed down your throat by a purple titanium
robot

while
you are sleeping.

How is that an "equally valid choice"? It makes absolutely no sense
as an analogy.

Hey! That is what I was trying to say!


What is what you were trying to say?

I hate false dilemmas.

What "false dilemma"? If one has a saw equipped with a Sawstop, then

the
choice is to replace the cartridge for 100 bucks, replace the saw for
whatever is the price of a new saw, defeat the absent cartridge, or

don't
saw. I don't see another option.

Now you offer 4 choices. You understand that this proves that the first
post with only two choices was a false dilemma, don't you?


I understand that you seem more interested in the cleverness of your own
argument than in any kind of discourse.

Life's too short.


You started it.


Started what? I made a comment on a possible marketing strategy. Then you
come in here with all this bull**** about "false dilemmas" when it is clear
that your real problem is comprehension of the English language.

-j


--
--John
Reply to jclarke at ae tee tee global dot net
(was jclarke at eye bee em dot net)