On May 29, 2:51*pm, mike wrote:
I'm replacing 44' of buried 3/4 galvanized water pipe to the water meter
at the sidewalk.
Looks like PEX is the way to go.
But the inside diameter of 3/4" galvanized is about the
same as 1" PEX.
1" is quite a bit more expensive, but it's a small
part of the total cost.

People at hardware stores say, "just use 3/4", it'll be fine."
Comment on that???

Sounds like the local ACE Hardware here. Everytim I go in
some knucklehead runs over to "help" and starts asking all
kinds of dumb questions. My favorite is the one that explained
to me how residential water systems work at about 2 PSI.

That line should be 1". Around here, new construction, they
pull 1" poly from the street. Seems reasonable. If you run
3/4" to upstairs bathrooms, seems the whole house should
have 1".





Then there's the problem of having a tiny variety of PEX
"sharkbite" type fittings. *They don't even carry a 1" *female to
PEX fitting at the Big Box stores.
I'm also concerned about the stiffness of the 1" making it harder
to install and easier for movement in the earth, etc. to pull it out
of the fitting.

Are the sharkbite fittings strong enough to bury? *They say they are,
but are they really?
Seems like
serious potential problem to me. *The fitting at the meter is a straight
shot and visible in the meter box.
The one at the house has to go down to get to 24". *Any compaction of the
soil below the pipe could allow tremendous pressure pulling the pipe
out of the connector.

Am I worrying too much?
Techniques for mitigating that problem?

Are the clamp-type fittings better? *I hate to buy a tool to
make two crimps of the circular stuff, but the ones with the
protrusion that you squeeze should be easy enough.

Suggestions?

I'd use regular PEX fittings. Did you check rental places,
like HD to see if you can rent the tool? Or how about Ebay?
You can buy one and sell it on Ebay if you like later.