On 20/05/2013 03:37, mcp wrote:
.....
So you are counting the defeit as some kind of subsidy to Scotland
despite England having a much greater defict per head?

I don't recall using the term subsidy at any stage. I have, however,
repeated pointed out that your figures are wrong, because they rely upon
Scotland receiving a geographical share of oil revenue, rather than a
per capita share.

Colin Bignell