In article , jim beam wrote:

well, you live and learn. apparently the reason they use a linear
controller is because it allows the fan to run near silently at low
speed. with pwm control the fluctuating magnetic fields in the motor
coils cause it to vibrate and make a humming noise at the pwm control
frequency.

Yes, this is why you put an integrator stage after the pwm stage, so that
the motor sees nice filtered DC with very little of the PWM leftover.

Problem is that the integrator stage costs money and big electrolytics
tend to have limited life, so auto folks don't like doing that.

that doesn't of course get around the fact that the unit in question
here is apparently badly under rated, but the above does at least
explain why it's used.

It's a cheap, reliable way of doing the job, if it's done right. It's clear
that it wasn't done right, but I'm still waiting to hear what was done wrong.
Given all the RoHS-related failures and the report that touching up solder
joints on the transistors fixes the problem, I am suspicious that it's a
soldering issue made worse by the extreme temperature cycling.
--scott
--
"C'est un Nagra. C'est suisse, et tres, tres precis."