View Single Post
  #5   Report Post  
Posted to sci.electronics.repair
nvic nvic is offline
external usenet poster
 
Posts: 15
Default DVD burner screwed by 2nd burner added to system

On May 31, 8:43*am, "William Sommerwerck"
wrote:

This is probably a coincidental event. The LG's failure has nothing to do
with the installation or use of the Lite-On burner. You can confirm this by
installing the LG in another computer.


There SHOULD be no relationship, but experience with LITE-ON and LG
drives leads me to think otherwise. I've killed 3 LG burners, and all
failed within a week of me attaching a LITE-ON burner for use as a
second drive. Either I've had bad luck with the LG drives, or LITE-ON
stuff kills LG stuff.

The LGs were models GH22NS50 and GH22LS50. They're almost identical
(the NS50 is an LS50 without LightScribe). All were purchased in 2009,
but were none were bought together.

I still have the LS50 in my main PC...It makes coasters, and only
reads CDs. It won't read DVDs, and will usually freeze the PC if one
is inserted. The PC then hangs while posting if rebooted, unless I
remove the DVD first. LightScribe doesn't work (freezes PC when I try
to burn the label).

When they failed, I tried reinstalling in device manager. Didn't help.
I moved them to another PC...same results. I tried a firmware update
on two of them. It succeeded both times, but didn't fix anything.

As for LITE-ON stuff, it's cheap, but it works. The LITE-ON burner
that seemingly killed the LGs is 5 years old and still works great
(it's my main drive now...) I also have a CD-RW drive from them that's
9.5 years old and has seen its fair share (hundreds) of burning
jobs...it still works as well.