"Don Pearce" wrote in message
...
NOPE, IF the host picks the remaining door he now has a 1/3 chance of
the
big prize, and the other two also have only a 1/3 chance each of the big
prize, NOT 50:50.

I should have added that yes IF (and only IF) the host reveals a goat,
the
other two will now have a 50:50 chance, but surely that is obvious, and
remains so whether they both switch or both stay, so is NO Longer like the
original MH problem at all.

Of course - and that is precisely the new scenario presented. As I
said - re-read. And no, it is nothing like the original MH problem.


Why do I need to re-read, that is exactly what I said!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
What the hell are you objecting to??????????????????

Trevor.