On Oct 31, 5:14*pm, "Joe" wrote:
"RicodJour" wrote in message
On Oct 31, 10:13 am, dpb wrote:

IOW, as posed, imo it's indeterminate as being underspecified...

Sounds like you're trying to help the OP weasel his way out of a
losing bet.

The OP is on the winning side.
"I say no, but a friend says yes"

Let the man get his steak!

Point noted. It's still weaseling.

R