"John Rumm" wrote in message
et...

What about if you watch a recording that someone (with a licence) made for
you off air. No license required typically. Now what if they happen to be
broadcasting a repeat of the program at the same time you happen to choose
to watch your recording?

That's not a problem.
the law that allows you to make a personal recording doesn't allow you to
give it to someone else.
You have broken copyright so you may as well break the TV license laws too.
(unless it was a recording of a live event.)