View Single Post
  #113   Report Post  
Posted to uk.d-i-y
The Natural Philosopher The Natural Philosopher is offline
external usenet poster
 
Posts: 9,045
Default Calculating your carbon footprint - a load of ********

Roger wrote:
The message
from Terry Fields contains these words:

There is indeed a strong link between Solutrean artifacts and very
similar items in America and there is some mitochondrial DNA linkage
between several native American tribes and some modern European groups
but as with any hypothesis for which there is absolutely no evidence
there is some dispute about whether the the Solutreans ever made it from
Europe to America at all let alone whether they did it by land or sea.
Nor that they used kayaks.


In that case, the BBC TV programme that showed the DNA traces was a
load of rubbish.


Thanks for your input.


Not a program I ever remember watching but have you any evidence that
DNA relating to the Solutreans or native Americans of similar antiquity
has ever been extracted?


I think you miss the point of how this particular brand of science works.

It merely allows you to predict that, given common strands of DNA in tow
populations, that there was a common ancestor, and roughly how many
generations ago that was.


The BBC is good at turning supposition into concrete fact - vis walking
with dinosaurs.

As for alternative routes for DNA, the obvious one is a minor European
contamination of the largely Asian DNA of the Native Americans.


Doesnt work like that. That gives a different pattern altogether.