Thanks everyone.

Since this part is part of an assembly, the OD has to be +/- .0005 as
it is a press fit... with a little green loctite, the rest I decided
was fine at +/- .0025.

I had a few quotes on the work before specifying the tolerance, and
when I humbly added my tolerance, both places said it would not matter
and the price would not change.

thanks for the insight fellas!