"IanJH" wrote in message
...
"Grunff" wrote in message
...
Some of you may remember the sad loss of my Erbauer 18V drill.
There were several suggestions as to what I should replace it
with. One suggestion was the B&Q PPPro 18V.
Having looked at these in the shop, and looked at their
motor/battery spec, I'd dismissed them as being too poor to
contemplate. But this wasn't based on actually having owned one.
I was in B&Q last week, and knowing that I'd be near B&Q again
next week thought what the hell, I'll try one. So I handed over
my £90 and took one home.
You get the drill, 2x 1.5Ah batteries, and a 1 hour charger. You
also get quite a nice case (which I didn't have with the
Erbauer, which cost £160 just over a year ago, now priced at £140).
The overall dimensions are quite a bit bigger than those of the
Erbauer, which makes the drill more difficult to use. In
particular, the 1.5Ah battery packs are significantly bigger
than the 1.9Ah ones that come with the Erbauer.
The chuck is of similar quality and design to the Erbauer, but
has the annoying habit of switching over to hammer action as
soon as the clutch comes into play.
It does, however, have two major problems.
First, battery life is awful. Lucky to get half the use on a
full charge that I would with the Erbauer.
Second, and more serious, is the speed controller. It doesn't
control the speed in a manner proportional to trigger movement.
There is a step jump to near full speed about half way along the
travel. This is a real pain, and makes it very difficult to use.
If this drill was £40, I think I'd keep it and live with the
deficiencies. But at that price, and especially when they brand
it as a semi-pro machine, no way.
Tune in next week, when I'll be reviewing Axminster's White 18V
drill...
--
Grunff
I think you shall find that the Axminster White range are the cheapo
rebadged Chinese stuff that B+Q et al so fondly like to call trade
stuff....
well to a 6 yr old then maybe but not to anyone who uses trade stuff they
aint...
The PP Pro range is not trade, it is better quality DIY.
Not to worry I use Axminster a lot and they are a good company.. but I
doubt
there drills are up to much.. Rebadged Nu-Tool????
I fear they have just bundled in nickel metal hydride batteries, which have
their advanatges and disadvantages, and the quality is the same as B&Q etc.
Which is fine for DIY.
You wll find that more expensive drills have better batteries to cope with
every day use, which appears to be the bulk of the cost of these items.
---
--
Checked by AVG anti-virus system (
http://www.grisoft.com).
Version: 6.0.520 / Virus Database: 318 - Release Date: 19/09/2003