Mary Fisher wrote:

"Jonathan" wrote

... "An
Inconvenient Truth", which was cleared to be shown in UK schools after
axe-grinding truck driver and political activist Stewart Dimmock
failed in his case to have the film banned. Although the judge

A renowned expert ...

A judge doesn't have to be a (scientific) expert. The suggestion he should have
been is a classic disingenuous attempt to dumb down the ruling by greenies.

The job of a judge is to weight the evidence. It's clear to me he did that job
well.

Graham