View Single Post
  #17   Report Post  
Posted to sci.electronics.repair,sci.electronics.design
Phil Allison Phil Allison is offline
external usenet poster
 
Posts: 493
Default Opinions on adding fuses to power amp

"msg"
Phil Allison


** Be very wary of adding +/- DC rail fuses to any power amp designed
without them.

Very likely if one or other DC fuse blows or is removed, the amp's
output will swing fully to the rail with its fuse still intact.

snip

One could add overcurrent shutdown circuitry on each rail designed to
shut
down the entire supply,



** How idiotic !



or for antique simplicity use 'indicator fuses' which
have a spring-loaded plunger which makes contact with an endstop terminal
when they blow -- the endstop is often connected to a crowbar which blows
main fuses upstream.



** Or simply use no DC rail fuses and let the AC supply fuse blow when
overloaded - as originally intended by the designer.


Evidently the designer did not account for the sort of catastrophic
failure described by the OP.



** Nonsense.

Output stage S/C failure is intended to blow the AC supply fuse.

The circuit damage is already done when it failed.

( snip drivel)



Those power amps that DO use +/-DC rail fuses, almost invariably have
them fitted in line with the output devices but NOT in line with low
power, voltage amplification circuitry.


Indeed that was implicit in my response; the rails in question are the
power amp rails, _not_ low-power rails.



** No - you have got it WRONG again !!!

It is the same two DC rails, split to service the output stage devices via
fuses.

YOU have NO clue whatever about power amplifier circuitry.

Better you learned to shut the **** up.



It must be possible to remove either DC ( or both) rail fuse with the amp
under load and drive and have no circuit damage occur. Any competent amp
designer can arrange things so this is the case - but not likely the OP.


Yes, but the OP did not design the amp and short of re-engineering it he
would need workable solutions.



** Well, he ain't gonna get any from a posturing ASS like you then.

The only *problem* the OP ever had was due to dropping a metal object
inside the amp - to which the solution is damn obvious.




....... Phil