Thread
:
Frugal lighting
View Single Post
#
4
Posted to misc.consumers.frugal-living,alt.energy.homepower,alt.home.repair
Harry Chickpea
external usenet poster
Posts: 4
Frugal lighting
wrote:
This morning I put two $20 Kill-a-Watt meters on two power strips with
a 100 W bulb screwed into one plug socket 80 cm from a "100 W equivalent"
23 W 10,000-hour Commercial Electric compact fluorescent with a 9-year
guarantee ($8.97 for 4 from Home Depot) and compared the outputs with
a Bunsen grease-spot photometer (a drop of oil on a piece of white paper :-)
Robert Bunsen (1811-1899) also invented the Bunsen burner. He was known as
an inept experimentalist with radical theories who isolated a foul-smelling
compound which he named cacodyl oxide and a whole series of related compounds
which turned out to be highly explosive. At one point, Bunsen accidentally
blew up his lab and was laid up in bed for a long time.
The grease spot disappeared (indicating equal illumination on both sides) when
the paper was 42.4 cm from the incandescent bulb, so it had (42.4/(80-42.4))^2
= 1.27 times the CF light output. After a minute or so, the 100 watt bulb
consumption dropped from 100 to 99 watts and the CF rose from 22 to 24, so
the CF was 99/(1.27x24) = 3.24 times more efficient, with 3.24 times more
lumens per watt.
After warmup, a "150 W equivalent" 42 W CF ($5.97 from Home Depot) used
35 watts and made the spot disappear 36.2 cm from the 100 W bulb when
it drew 98 watts, so it was (36.2/(80-36.2))^2 = 0.683 times brighter
than the CF, which was 98/(0.683x35) = 4.10 times more efficient.
Nick
Nick, this is much more useful than a lot of your pie in the sky
calculations. Well done.
BTW, if the CFs were in a pack of four, did you test for variations?
That would be useful information as well.
Also, did you check the lumen output either by using a standard
candle, or a photometer (perhaps one in a camera?). Incandescent
lamps dim with age, so using an older 100 watt lamp might have
affected the results.
Reply With Quote
Harry Chickpea
View Public Profile
Find all posts by Harry Chickpea