Which is stronger?
Swingman wrote:
"Chris Friesen" wrote in message
I would go with "B".
I'm to lazy to do it for you but if you calculate the section modulus
of each joint, you'll find "B" is stronger.
S = M/Z
S = Stress
M = Bending Moment
Z = Section Modulus
Z = I/d
I = Moment of Inertia
d = Distance from centroid to outermost fiber.
I (for a retangle) = bh^3/12 = 1/2ad^2
b = base
h = height
a = area
d = distance from center of area to center of bending moment.
Any decent strength text will give you the formula for a circle.
(Dredged from my memory from all those strength of materials classes
taken so long ago.)
Have fun.
Lew
|