"mdboulay" wrote in message
news:fbc881c32ba3a5d9b15f6de783b15d1a@homerepairli ve.com...
During a recent thunderstorm one of our vinyl shutters was torn off of the
house. When we went to reinstall the shutter (with the new plastic
screws) we realized that the original plastic screws were sheared off
within the drill hole. Any suggestions for removing the old screws from
the drill holes? We have tried needle nose pliers and tried to redrill
the holes but nothing has worked.

It's most likely NOT a screw. Vinyl shutters typicaly use a barbed style
mount that simply pushes in to the pre-drilled hole. You can not unscrew
them and they are very difficult to pull out. When they break they are
normally pushed further in to the wall which forces them to fall in to the
wall cavity.