Home |
Search |
Today's Posts |
|
Home Repair (alt.home.repair) For all homeowners and DIYers with many experienced tradesmen. Solve your toughest home fix-it problems. |
Reply |
|
LinkBack | Thread Tools | Display Modes |
#1
|
|||
|
|||
Could douglas fir root damage house foundation?
There is a 80-ft tall douglas fir tree three feet from my outside wall and
it has been there ever since the house was built some 20 years ago. I recently read that roots of large tree could damage house foundation. However, nobody else (including an arborist, a house inspector) who saw that tree ever mentioned anything like that, although I didn't specifically ask them about this issue. On the other hand, my driveway was cracked by a much smaller tree (maple) which forced me to cut it down. So "large tree roots may damage house foundation" does have a ring of truth. On the third hand, if that was true, the builder (and a reputable one) wouldn't have built the house 3 feet away from that tree, would they? Any thoughts? |
#2
|
|||
|
|||
Tree roots can damage foundations but if nothing is visable now why
worry. I has a pipe leak in a corner for years, an oak tree 15ft away found the water with its roots growing in. |
#3
|
|||
|
|||
"peter" wrote in news:6m7Md.1361$uc.168@trnddc05:
There is a 80-ft tall douglas fir tree three feet from my outside wall and it has been there ever since the house was built some 20 years ago. I recently read that roots of large tree could damage house foundation. However, nobody else (including an arborist, a house inspector) who saw that tree ever mentioned anything like that, although I didn't specifically ask them about this issue. On the other hand, my driveway was cracked by a much smaller tree (maple) which forced me to cut it down. So "large tree roots may damage house foundation" does have a ring of truth. On the third hand, if that was true, the builder (and a reputable one) wouldn't have built the house 3 feet away from that tree, would they? Any thoughts? Depends entirely on root type. Oaks have shallow roots systems, while redwoods have deep tap roots. I had to take out 15 juniper bushes because they craked my enitre sidewalk, but I've had 40' pines close to the house that gave me no problems. Ask an arborist. |
#4
|
|||
|
|||
"peter" wrote in news:6m7Md.1361$uc.168@trnddc05:
There is a 80-ft tall douglas fir tree three feet from my outside wall and it has been there ever since the house was built some 20 years ago. I recently read that roots of large tree could damage house foundation. However, nobody else (including an arborist, a house inspector) who saw that tree ever mentioned anything like that, although I didn't specifically ask them about this issue. On the other hand, my driveway was cracked by a much smaller tree (maple) which forced me to cut it down. So "large tree roots may damage house foundation" does have a ring of truth. On the third hand, if that was true, the builder (and a reputable one) wouldn't have built the house 3 feet away from that tree, would they? Any thoughts? If I remember correctly, and I may not, a pine (fir) tree has roots that resemble a carrot. Oaks, maples, etc have roots that spread out. The worst of this type would be a weeping willow where the roots "hunt" for water. But then, I may be totally wrong. I heard this a long time ago. |
#5
|
|||
|
|||
"peter" wrote in message news:6m7Md.1361$uc.168@trnddc05... There is a 80-ft tall douglas fir tree three feet from my outside wall and it has been there ever since the house was built some 20 years ago. I recently read that roots of large tree could damage house foundation. However, nobody else (including an arborist, a house inspector) who saw that tree ever mentioned anything like that, although I didn't specifically ask them about this issue. On the other hand, my driveway was cracked by a much smaller tree (maple) which forced me to cut it down. So "large tree roots may damage house foundation" does have a ring of truth. On the third hand, if that was true, the builder (and a reputable one) wouldn't have built the house 3 feet away from that tree, would they? Arborists if not carefully chosen are just tree cutters, and may overemphasize "dangers" of tree and roots in order to get a job. House inspectors, the lowest of the low, often don't catch everything, and there is no red flag here. Even reputable builders often leave trees too close to houses in order to make the house attractive and landscaped to sell. They tend to know little about trees, but rather building and selling. Dont sweat the foundation risk unless you see a hint of damage. If curious, you can dig a test trench along your fdn to see size and orientation of roots. Roots of practically all trees tend to look for moisture,and back off from foundations, as under the house it is usually dry. The biggest risk for your house is limbs falling on roof and invading sewer/drainage lines, if they are the jointed metal or tile type. PVC with glued joints tends to resist root damage. BTW redwoods have no tap roots, as one poster suggested. Nearly all trees have shallow roots. Here is a quote from the Dept. of Energy: "Redwoods have the same kind of root system as any other tree. Usually, the root systems of the redwoods stay close to the soil surface, only going 4-6 feet deep but spreading way beyond the tree, 250 feet in width. " Same general principles apply to firs. I have 60-85 foot Monterey Pines that have similar growth styles but smaller than Douglas Firs, and they are within 18-25 feet of fdn. Perhaps three feet is a bit close, but as said, I would just monitor fdn, and do test trench to get root location/orientation. I have also used a bladed punch bar to chop roots that are going the wrong way, or under driveways.. No real harm to tree or its stability. |
#6
|
|||
|
|||
"Roger T." wrote in
: "peter" wrote in message news:6m7Md.1361$uc.168@trnddc05... There is a 80-ft tall douglas fir tree three feet from my outside wall and it has been there ever since the house was built some 20 years ago. I recently read that roots of large tree could damage house foundation. However, nobody else (including an arborist, a house inspector) who saw that tree ever mentioned anything like that, although I didn't specifically ask them about this issue. On the other hand, my driveway was cracked by a much smaller tree (maple) which forced me to cut it down. So "large tree roots may damage house foundation" does have a ring of truth. On the third hand, if that was true, the builder (and a reputable one) wouldn't have built the house 3 feet away from that tree, would they? Arborists if not carefully chosen are just tree cutters, and may overemphasize "dangers" of tree and roots in order to get a job. House inspectors, the lowest of the low, often don't catch everything, and there is no red flag here. Even reputable builders often leave trees too close to houses in order to make the house attractive and landscaped to sell. They tend to know little about trees, but rather building and selling. Dont sweat the foundation risk unless you see a hint of damage. If curious, you can dig a test trench along your fdn to see size and orientation of roots. Roots of practically all trees tend to look for moisture,and back off from foundations, as under the house it is usually dry. The biggest risk for your house is limbs falling on roof and invading sewer/drainage lines, if they are the jointed metal or tile type. PVC with glued joints tends to resist root damage. BTW redwoods have no tap roots, as one poster suggested. Nearly all trees have shallow roots. Here is a quote from the Dept. of Energy: "Redwoods have the same kind of root system as any other tree. Usually, the root systems of the redwoods stay close to the soil surface, only going 4-6 feet deep but spreading way beyond the tree, 250 feet in width. " Same general principles apply to firs. I have 60-85 foot Monterey Pines that have similar growth styles but smaller than Douglas Firs, and they are within 18-25 feet of fdn. Perhaps three feet is a bit close, but as said, I would just monitor fdn, and do test trench to get root location/orientation. I have also used a bladed punch bar to chop roots that are going the wrong way, or under driveways.. No real harm to tree or its stability. I stand corrected about redwood tree root systems. I was either misinformed by my nursery when I planted redwoods on my property, or I just didn't listen/remember. I just looked it up he http://groups.ucanr.org/mgnapa/Artic...wood_Trees.htm : Redwood trees have shallow, aggressive root systems that can raise havoc with house foundations, sidewalks or lawn. Almost anytime improvements compete with redwood tree roots, the roots will win. Apologies for spreading non-factual information. I usually don't contribute unless I sure of what I'm talking about, and this time I wasn't. Bruce |
#7
|
|||
|
|||
"peter" wrote in message news:6m7Md.1361$uc.168@trnddc05... There is a 80-ft tall douglas fir tree three feet from my outside wall and it has been there ever since the house was built some 20 years ago. I recently read that roots of large tree could damage house foundation. However, nobody else (including an arborist, a house inspector) who saw that tree ever mentioned anything like that, although I didn't specifically ask them about this issue. On the other hand, my driveway was cracked by a much smaller tree (maple) which forced me to cut it down. So "large tree roots may damage house foundation" does have a ring of truth. On the third hand, if that was true, the builder (and a reputable one) wouldn't have built the house 3 feet away from that tree, would they? Any thoughts? If it falls over and the roots are under the footings then you are totally screwed. Otherwise, its a gamble--mosty dependant on the soil under the foundation, sand, clay.... Solid rock........(eeks !!!) -- SVL |
#8
|
|||
|
|||
In article 6m7Md.1361$uc.168@trnddc05, peter
wrote: There is a 80-ft tall douglas fir tree three feet from my outside wall and it has been there ever since the house was built some 20 years ago. I recently read that roots of large tree could damage house foundation. However, nobody else (including an arborist, a house inspector) who saw that tree ever mentioned anything like that, although I didn't specifically ask them about this issue. On the other hand, my driveway was cracked by a much smaller tree (maple) which forced me to cut it down. So "large tree roots may damage house foundation" does have a ring of truth. On the third hand, if that was true, the builder (and a reputable one) wouldn't have built the house 3 feet away from that tree, would they? Doug fir have shallow root systems. djb -- "The thing about saying the wrong words is that A, I don't notice it, and B, sometimes orange water gibbon bucket and plastic." -- Mr. Burrows |
Reply |
Thread Tools | Search this Thread |
Display Modes | |
|
|
Similar Threads | ||||
Thread | Forum | |||
Buying a house: Some questions | Home Ownership | |||
new foundation question | Home Repair | |||
buying a house with Weyerhaeuser siding | Home Repair | |||
bath along or across joists? (further stories from the house fromhell) | UK diy | |||
Contacting contractor to buy our house? (Long) | Home Repair |