Home |
Search |
Today's Posts |
|
Home Repair (alt.home.repair) For all homeowners and DIYers with many experienced tradesmen. Solve your toughest home fix-it problems. |
Reply |
|
LinkBack | Thread Tools | Display Modes |
#1
|
|||
|
|||
Electrical inspector makes up new rules during inspection
I had an appointment Monday morning with the electrical inspector for him
to inspect the feeder circuit to my new detached garage. I took off from work to be home; he showed up promptly at *noon* -- I was just about to give up on him and leave. It went downhill from there. I suspect he's a former electrician who went out of business, and he blames homeowners doing their own wiring. Several boxes were a little too small. I had only counted the devices as one wire and they should have been two, so I was 1 to 2 cubic inches too small on the box size. My mistake. I'll fix that. The wiring is exposed NM-B, and mostly metal boxes. I stapled the wires down the center of the 2x4's using a variety of types of staples. I have a staple gun that shoots 9/16" (I think) staples that are UL listed for use with NM cable. You're supposed to shoot 2 staples right next to each other. I also had some plastic straps with 2 little captive nails leftover from a previous job, and some Gardner Bender plastic coated heavy-duty staples I bought at the electrical dept at Home Depot. I used either the plastic strap staples or the heavy wire staples at each end of the cables, and the staple gun every couple of feet along the cables. Inspector says I can't use metal staples because they are not UL listed. He gleefully tells me about seeing them all the time at HD and Menard's, and they're not allowed by the electrical code. He tells me to use them next time I put up a barbed wire fence or something. I showed him the box of staplegun staples where it says "UL". He said I still can't use them. WTF? The reason I have to pull out all the big wire staples is they are not listed, but the UL listed staples are not allowed either, "just because"? One of the receptacles I used was a heavy duty duplex outlet that is back-wired and takes up to #10 wire. I specifically picked it because there are two holes under each screw, so you could backwire 4 wires on black and 4 wires on white. I had 3 wires on each side. Inspector says you can only have 2 wires on each side of the device, but he can't show me in the code where it says that. This is easy to redo, and it's one of the boxes that was a little too small anyway, but it's another example of making up rules on-the-spot. The panel has a ground bar and a neutral bar. The neutral feeder wire is connected to the neutral lug, the ground electrode conductor is connected to the ground bar, and the green bonding screw is installed. I'm supposed to move the ground electrode conductor to the neutral bar -- not a big deal because it is long enough to reach. But why? For the feeder wires to the panel, I used three #6 THHN wires in a 3/4" EMT. I used black wire because that's all I could find, and I taped the neutral wire white at each end. He says I gotta pull that neutral wire out of there and run a new one that is white or green end-to-end from the factory. I can't just spray paint it; it's gotta be a white or green (but not bare) wire. That's legitimate I guess, but it's chicken****. I don't know anyplace to buy white wire that big by the foot, so I may just run a #4 aluminum wire and tape *it* white. I have a scrap long enough. But I might have to increase the conduit to 1". Still, conduit is cheaper than copper wire lately. I stopped by Home Depot tonight just to see if they had white or green #6 wire, and of course they don't. The old guy there in the electrical dept had never heard of the white-from-end-to-end rule being enforced for #6 wires. He wanted to look at my main panel in the house that is feeding this. I showed him and he didn't like something; the number of breakers in the box, or the wire bending distance, or something. I told him that *everything* in the house, including the 60A breaker to the garage and the feeder conductors up to the weatherhead were already inspected 10 years ago by one of his colleagues, and the inspection sticker is *right there*. He harrumphed, said he would have to talk with the other inspectors when he got back to the office, and we went back out to the garage. That's not all, but that's enough to make my point. I'm still ****ed, just in case you can't tell. I wish I lived out in the county instead of within the city limits. I probably should have gotten a permit to run one 15A 110V underground feeder out there. One receptical, one lightbulb inside the garage, one porch light. (It's a new building, I had to do *something* electrical or they'd be suspicious.) After getting it inspected, I could pull it up and run my 60A overhead feeder without a permit. I'll know better next time. Best regards, Bob |
#2
|
|||
|
|||
Electrical inspector makes up new rules during inspection
Talk to an electrician for opinions and the person in charge of city
inspections to have a supervisor reinspect it. You may be right. |
#3
|
|||
|
|||
Electrical inspector makes up new rules during inspection
I just did a bunch of work on my house including a new roof. I though about getting a permit, which is required by law, but decided against it. I've saved myself some money and feel good about it. Pj On Wed, 10 Mar 2004 01:23:12 -0600, zxcvbob wrote: I had an appointment Monday morning with the electrical inspector for him to inspect the feeder circuit to my new detached garage. I took off from work to be home; he showed up promptly at *noon* -- I was just about to give up on him and leave. It went downhill from there. I suspect he's a former electrician who went out of business, and he blames homeowners doing their own wiring. Several boxes were a little too small. I had only counted the devices as one wire and they should have been two, so I was 1 to 2 cubic inches too small on the box size. My mistake. I'll fix that. The wiring is exposed NM-B, and mostly metal boxes. I stapled the wires down the center of the 2x4's using a variety of types of staples. I have a staple gun that shoots 9/16" (I think) staples that are UL listed for use with NM cable. You're supposed to shoot 2 staples right next to each other. I also had some plastic straps with 2 little captive nails leftover from a previous job, and some Gardner Bender plastic coated heavy-duty staples I bought at the electrical dept at Home Depot. I used either the plastic strap staples or the heavy wire staples at each end of the cables, and the staple gun every couple of feet along the cables. Inspector says I can't use metal staples because they are not UL listed. He gleefully tells me about seeing them all the time at HD and Menard's, and they're not allowed by the electrical code. He tells me to use them next time I put up a barbed wire fence or something. I showed him the box of staplegun staples where it says "UL". He said I still can't use them. WTF? The reason I have to pull out all the big wire staples is they are not listed, but the UL listed staples are not allowed either, "just because"? One of the receptacles I used was a heavy duty duplex outlet that is back-wired and takes up to #10 wire. I specifically picked it because there are two holes under each screw, so you could backwire 4 wires on black and 4 wires on white. I had 3 wires on each side. Inspector says you can only have 2 wires on each side of the device, but he can't show me in the code where it says that. This is easy to redo, and it's one of the boxes that was a little too small anyway, but it's another example of making up rules on-the-spot. The panel has a ground bar and a neutral bar. The neutral feeder wire is connected to the neutral lug, the ground electrode conductor is connected to the ground bar, and the green bonding screw is installed. I'm supposed to move the ground electrode conductor to the neutral bar -- not a big deal because it is long enough to reach. But why? For the feeder wires to the panel, I used three #6 THHN wires in a 3/4" EMT. I used black wire because that's all I could find, and I taped the neutral wire white at each end. He says I gotta pull that neutral wire out of there and run a new one that is white or green end-to-end from the factory. I can't just spray paint it; it's gotta be a white or green (but not bare) wire. That's legitimate I guess, but it's chicken****. I don't know anyplace to buy white wire that big by the foot, so I may just run a #4 aluminum wire and tape *it* white. I have a scrap long enough. But I might have to increase the conduit to 1". Still, conduit is cheaper than copper wire lately. I stopped by Home Depot tonight just to see if they had white or green #6 wire, and of course they don't. The old guy there in the electrical dept had never heard of the white-from-end-to-end rule being enforced for #6 wires. He wanted to look at my main panel in the house that is feeding this. I showed him and he didn't like something; the number of breakers in the box, or the wire bending distance, or something. I told him that *everything* in the house, including the 60A breaker to the garage and the feeder conductors up to the weatherhead were already inspected 10 years ago by one of his colleagues, and the inspection sticker is *right there*. He harrumphed, said he would have to talk with the other inspectors when he got back to the office, and we went back out to the garage. That's not all, but that's enough to make my point. I'm still ****ed, just in case you can't tell. I wish I lived out in the county instead of within the city limits. I probably should have gotten a permit to run one 15A 110V underground feeder out there. One receptical, one lightbulb inside the garage, one porch light. (It's a new building, I had to do *something* electrical or they'd be suspicious.) After getting it inspected, I could pull it up and run my 60A overhead feeder without a permit. I'll know better next time. Best regards, Bob |
#4
|
|||
|
|||
Electrical inspector makes up new rules during inspection
"zxcvbob" wrote in message ... I had an appointment Monday morning with the electrical inspector for him to inspect the feeder circuit to my new detached garage. I took off from work to be home; he showed up promptly at *noon* -- I was just about to give up on him and leave. It went downhill from there. I suspect he's a former electrician who went out of business, and he blames homeowners doing their own wiring. Several boxes were a little too small. I had only counted the devices as one wire and they should have been two, so I was 1 to 2 cubic inches too small on the box size. My mistake. I'll fix that. The wiring is exposed NM-B, and mostly metal boxes. I stapled the wires down the center of the 2x4's using a variety of types of staples. I have a staple gun that shoots 9/16" (I think) staples that are UL listed for use with NM cable. You're supposed to shoot 2 staples right next to each other. I also had some plastic straps with 2 little captive nails leftover from a previous job, and some Gardner Bender plastic coated heavy-duty staples I bought at the electrical dept at Home Depot. I used either the plastic strap staples or the heavy wire staples at each end of the cables, and the staple gun every couple of feet along the cables. Inspector says I can't use metal staples because they are not UL listed. He gleefully tells me about seeing them all the time at HD and Menard's, and they're not allowed by the electrical code. He tells me to use them next time I put up a barbed wire fence or something. I showed him the box of staplegun staples where it says "UL". He said I still can't use them. WTF? The reason I have to pull out all the big wire staples is they are not listed, but the UL listed staples are not allowed either, "just because"? One of the receptacles I used was a heavy duty duplex outlet that is back-wired and takes up to #10 wire. I specifically picked it because there are two holes under each screw, so you could backwire 4 wires on black and 4 wires on white. I had 3 wires on each side. Inspector says you can only have 2 wires on each side of the device, but he can't show me in the code where it says that. This is easy to redo, and it's one of the boxes that was a little too small anyway, but it's another example of making up rules on-the-spot. The panel has a ground bar and a neutral bar. The neutral feeder wire is connected to the neutral lug, the ground electrode conductor is connected to the ground bar, and the green bonding screw is installed. I'm supposed to move the ground electrode conductor to the neutral bar -- not a big deal because it is long enough to reach. But why? For the feeder wires to the panel, I used three #6 THHN wires in a 3/4" EMT. I used black wire because that's all I could find, and I taped the neutral wire white at each end. He says I gotta pull that neutral wire out of there and run a new one that is white or green end-to-end from the factory. I can't just spray paint it; it's gotta be a white or green (but not bare) wire. That's legitimate I guess, but it's chicken****. I don't know anyplace to buy white wire that big by the foot, so I may just run a #4 aluminum wire and tape *it* white. I have a scrap long enough. But I might have to increase the conduit to 1". Still, conduit is cheaper than copper wire lately. I stopped by Home Depot tonight just to see if they had white or green #6 wire, and of course they don't. The old guy there in the electrical dept had never heard of the white-from-end-to-end rule being enforced for #6 wires. He wanted to look at my main panel in the house that is feeding this. I showed him and he didn't like something; the number of breakers in the box, or the wire bending distance, or something. I told him that *everything* in the house, including the 60A breaker to the garage and the feeder conductors up to the weatherhead were already inspected 10 years ago by one of his colleagues, and the inspection sticker is *right there*. He harrumphed, said he would have to talk with the other inspectors when he got back to the office, and we went back out to the garage. That's not all, but that's enough to make my point. I'm still ****ed, just in case you can't tell. I wish I lived out in the county instead of within the city limits. I probably should have gotten a permit to run one 15A 110V underground feeder out there. One receptical, one lightbulb inside the garage, one porch light. (It's a new building, I had to do *something* electrical or they'd be suspicious.) After getting it inspected, I could pull it up and run my 60A overhead feeder without a permit. I'll know better next time. Best regards, Bob Sounds like your inspector has a chip on his shoulder, possibly for the reasons you stated. Have you contacted someone else at your state board of electricity, or whoever inspects in your area? Maybe they could send out someone else? You should certainly be able to use black wire for your neutral, as long as it was coded white. For contrast, I just did some relatively extensive wiring, added a sub panel to basement, added circuits for lights and outlets and a hot tub, all feeding from my new sub. The electrical inspector was a pleasure to work with. He was fair, polite, and very talkative on the how's and why's on the few things I had to re-do. They should realize that treating homeowners like you were treated will make some people likely to skip the permits on future work. Dave |
#5
|
|||
|
|||
Electrical inspector makes up new rules during inspection
DaveG wrote: "zxcvbob" wrote in message ... I had an appointment Monday morning with the electrical inspector for him to inspect the feeder circuit to my new detached garage. I took off from work to be home; he showed up promptly at *noon* -- I was just about to give up on him and leave. It went downhill from there. I suspect he's a former electrician who went out of business, and he blames homeowners doing their own wiring. Several boxes were a little too small. I had only counted the devices as one wire and they should have been two, so I was 1 to 2 cubic inches too small on the box size. My mistake. I'll fix that. The wiring is exposed NM-B, and mostly metal boxes. I stapled the wires down the center of the 2x4's using a variety of types of staples. I have a staple gun that shoots 9/16" (I think) staples that are UL listed for use with NM cable. You're supposed to shoot 2 staples right next to each other. I also had some plastic straps with 2 little captive nails leftover from a previous job, and some Gardner Bender plastic coated heavy-duty staples I bought at the electrical dept at Home Depot. I used either the plastic strap staples or the heavy wire staples at each end of the cables, and the staple gun every couple of feet along the cables. Inspector says I can't use metal staples because they are not UL listed. He gleefully tells me about seeing them all the time at HD and Menard's, and they're not allowed by the electrical code. He tells me to use them next time I put up a barbed wire fence or something. I showed him the box of staplegun staples where it says "UL". He said I still can't use them. WTF? The reason I have to pull out all the big wire staples is they are not listed, but the UL listed staples are not allowed either, "just because"? One of the receptacles I used was a heavy duty duplex outlet that is back-wired and takes up to #10 wire. I specifically picked it because there are two holes under each screw, so you could backwire 4 wires on black and 4 wires on white. I had 3 wires on each side. Inspector says you can only have 2 wires on each side of the device, but he can't show me in the code where it says that. This is easy to redo, and it's one of the boxes that was a little too small anyway, but it's another example of making up rules on-the-spot. The panel has a ground bar and a neutral bar. The neutral feeder wire is connected to the neutral lug, the ground electrode conductor is connected to the ground bar, and the green bonding screw is installed. I'm supposed to move the ground electrode conductor to the neutral bar -- not a big deal because it is long enough to reach. But why? For the feeder wires to the panel, I used three #6 THHN wires in a 3/4" EMT. I used black wire because that's all I could find, and I taped the neutral wire white at each end. He says I gotta pull that neutral wire out of there and run a new one that is white or green end-to-end from the factory. I can't just spray paint it; it's gotta be a white or green (but not bare) wire. That's legitimate I guess, but it's chicken****. I don't know anyplace to buy white wire that big by the foot, so I may just run a #4 aluminum wire and tape *it* white. I have a scrap long enough. But I might have to increase the conduit to 1". Still, conduit is cheaper than copper wire lately. I stopped by Home Depot tonight just to see if they had white or green #6 wire, and of course they don't. The old guy there in the electrical dept had never heard of the white-from-end-to-end rule being enforced for #6 wires. He wanted to look at my main panel in the house that is feeding this. I showed him and he didn't like something; the number of breakers in the box, or the wire bending distance, or something. I told him that *everything* in the house, including the 60A breaker to the garage and the feeder conductors up to the weatherhead were already inspected 10 years ago by one of his colleagues, and the inspection sticker is *right there*. He harrumphed, said he would have to talk with the other inspectors when he got back to the office, and we went back out to the garage. That's not all, but that's enough to make my point. I'm still ****ed, just in case you can't tell. I wish I lived out in the county instead of within the city limits. I probably should have gotten a permit to run one 15A 110V underground feeder out there. One receptical, one lightbulb inside the garage, one porch light. (It's a new building, I had to do *something* electrical or they'd be suspicious.) After getting it inspected, I could pull it up and run my 60A overhead feeder without a permit. I'll know better next time. Best regards, Bob Sounds like your inspector has a chip on his shoulder, possibly for the reasons you stated. Have you contacted someone else at your state board of electricity, or whoever inspects in your area? Maybe they could send out someone else? You should certainly be able to use black wire for your neutral, as long as it was coded white. Although it's not typically enforced the NEC only lets you tape "larger than #6" not #6. [NEC 310-12(a). NEC200-6(a) doesn't permit taping either for #6.] You got hold of an inspector who doesn't want your installation to pass. The NEC, if applied without discretion would cause every installation to fail. RB For contrast, I just did some relatively extensive wiring, added a sub panel to basement, added circuits for lights and outlets and a hot tub, all feeding from my new sub. The electrical inspector was a pleasure to work with. He was fair, polite, and very talkative on the how's and why's on the few things I had to re-do. They should realize that treating homeowners like you were treated will make some people likely to skip the permits on future work. Dave |
#6
|
|||
|
|||
Electrical inspector makes up new rules during inspection
DaveG wrote:
Sounds like your inspector has a chip on his shoulder, possibly for the reasons you stated. Have you contacted someone else at your state board of electricity, or whoever inspects in your area? Maybe they could send out someone else? You should certainly be able to use black wire for your neutral, as long as it was coded white. For contrast, I just did some relatively extensive wiring, added a sub panel to basement, added circuits for lights and outlets and a hot tub, all feeding from my new sub. The electrical inspector was a pleasure to work with. He was fair, polite, and very talkative on the how's and why's on the few things I had to re-do. I replaced my old 60A fusebox service with 150A breaker panel ten years ago, including a 60A overhead feeder to the garage using the old service wires -- identical to this new one. The garage panel was part of that permit. That inspector was easy to work with (but he did make me redo a few things), and he told me I had done a good job when I was done. This inspector didn't even like the previously inspected main panel. They should realize that treating homeowners like you were treated will make some people likely to skip the permits on future work. I know a supervisor in the Building Safety office (where the inspectors work.) Next time I see him in church I think I'll tell him that I regret getting a permit for this work and see what he says. Also ask what happens if I let the permit expire without getting a final inspection. -bob |
#7
|
|||
|
|||
Electrical inspector makes up new rules during inspection
"zxcvbob" wrote in message ... I had an appointment Monday morning with the electrical inspector for him to inspect the feeder circuit to my new detached garage. I took off from work to be home; he showed up promptly at *noon* -- I was just about to give up on him and leave. It went downhill from there. I suspect he's a former electrician who went out of business, and he blames homeowners doing their own wiring. snipped Best regards, Bob First you must decide if this is worth your effort. Personally I would be wiring a complaint and demanding to see a supervisor. Which can be a mixed blessing. The guy should be able to quote the sections of the NEC or municipal code that apply. If he can not then it is supervisor time. Failing to complete the project with in limits only puts you and your property at risk of civil intervention. They might do nothing or they could take you to court. Take a walk and cool down. Then decide if you want to tilt at some wind mills. I would. I was a manufactures rep and we were changing out all of the fused switches to circuit breakers. The electrical inspector said we could not do that. I explained that I was the factory and the service would be tested appropriately on completion. He refused and called his supervisor. A man that I have known for 25 years. oops I showed the supervisor the UL labels and listings for what we were doing and explained the testing procedure that would be done when the installation was finished. He asked for his inspector to be present. I explained that time was a factor and we could not hold up the project. I would give him 24 hours notice and we would proceed with the tests with or without him. Agreed. I turned to the inspector and said we would be testing at 8:30 in the morning and he was welcome to attend. The inspector never showed up and we moved on. |
#8
|
|||
|
|||
Electrical inspector makes up new rules during inspection
Dont let your permit expire you wont get a cert of ocupancy. Big
trouble. And you cant sell it and Dont wait till church get the supervisor and indepenant advise . This guy is maybe wrong now time is in your favor its your responsibilty for final inspection not the citys, they realy dont care. You may be fined to. |
#9
|
|||
|
|||
Electrical inspector makes up new rules during inspection
Bob,
Sorry to hear about your unpleasant inspection. I recently wired our new house and, thankfully, it went rather smoothly. The first words my inspector said was "let's talk about electricity". So, I knew immediately he was expecting a total homeowner botch job. But, I let him say his piece, tried to pay attention and let him inspect my work. As he started looking things over his comments slowly turned from grade school electricity to "Wow! this is nice! I should bring the contractors out to see how it's SUPPOSED to be done". I passed with flying colors the first time out. My only real mistake was not running a separate ground wire in the few metal boxes I had used. I figured they were grounded through the tabs of the devices that had the grounds attached. My mistake. He let it pass, but I fixed it after he left. Several boxes were a little too small. I hate cramped boxes, so I went as large as I could on everything, even if it wasn't required by code. The wiring is exposed NM-B I didn't think NM cable could be left exposed? I thought it had to be covered or else you had to run wires in conduit? Don't know for sure. I have a staple gun that shoots 9/16" (I think) staples that are UL listed for use with NM cable. They may be UL listed but not necessarily NEC approved? In any case, I wouldn't feel comfortable with wire staples, or even those vinyl covered metal staples. Just my preference. I prefer the little plastic straps with the two nails. Non-conductive, just in case... seeing them all the time at HD and Menard's, and they're not allowed by the electrical code. I see stuff at Home Depot and Lowes all the time that I know is against plumbing and electrical codes. Doesn't seem to prevent them from selling the stuff? Inspector says you can only have 2 wires on each side of the device The best way to do this is to join all the wires with the appropriate wire nut inside the box, with a pigtail running to the device. That way if the device fails for some reason, the rest of the circuit doesn't go dead. And, you aren't running the full circuit load through that device. I'm supposed to move the ground electrode conductor to the neutral bar -- not a big deal because it is long enough to reach. But why? You got me on that one. My panel has specific lugs for the hots, neutral, and ground connections, with a bonding screw to ground the cabinet, and a bar to connect the neutral and ground bars. He says I gotta pull that neutral wire out of there and run a new one that is white or green end-to-end from the factory. Haven't run across that either, but I use 4/0 copper service entrance cables for my supply (three black wires, the neutral has a green stripe). You might check with electrical supply stores in your area. They'll often have the unique stuff that the box stores don't carry. That's not all, but that's enough to make my point. Right or not, the inspector is basically the final rule. I'm pretty sure this is even stated in the electrical code. Everyone has a bad day. Maybe you were just unlucky enough to catch him on one of his. There may be "workmanship" issues that set off red flags to him that made him take a closer look at the small stuff. Who knows... In any case, it's all for your safety anyway, so even if it's not necessary, humor the inspector and do whatever it takes to make him/her happy. Sooner or later they'll run out of things to nitpick and you'll pass. Good luck, Anthony |
#10
|
|||
|
|||
Electrical inspector makes up new rules during inspection
Bob,
It's hard to tell from your one sided post if the inspector had an attitude problem. It does sound as if he was late though you don't say at what time he hoped to arrive at your home. But other than that what is your complaint? He told you what he believed to be wrong with your work and how to fix it. Do you think that he is misinterpreting the code? Was he rude or abrupt? In characterizing the inspector as "a former electrician who went out of business, and he blames homeowners doing their own wiring." you make it clear that you have an attitude problem. It's possible that the man was having a bad day but I doubt that would lead him to go over your wiring and carefully explain to you all of the defects in your workmanship and materials. If you truly need to pursue this, research your local building code and determine whether your work is up to code, then file a complaint with his supervisor. Dave M. |
#11
|
|||
|
|||
Electrical inspector makes up new rules during inspection
David Martel wrote:
Bob, It's hard to tell from your one sided post if the inspector had an attitude problem. It does sound as if he was late though you don't say at what time he hoped to arrive at your home. But other than that what is your complaint? He told you what he believed to be wrong with your work and how to fix it. Do you think that he is misinterpreting the code? Was he rude or abrupt? In characterizing the inspector as "a former electrician who went out of business, and he blames homeowners doing their own wiring." you make it clear that you have an attitude problem. It's possible that the man was having a bad day but I doubt that would lead him to go over your wiring and carefully explain to you all of the defects in your workmanship and materials. If you truly need to pursue this, research your local building code and determine whether your work is up to code, then file a complaint with his supervisor. Dave M. I've already changed the undersized boxes and removed most of the nonlisted staples. I do have an attitude problem, and it gets worse the more I think about it. He was sarcastic and belittling. He said he would be there probably about 10:00 and he didn't show up until noon. When he was looking at the service panel in my basement, he disconnected a cable TV ground wire that was in his way, and he didn't hook it back up again. He said the #6 neutral wire had to be marked white or gray or green from end-to-end by the manufacturer. The code doesn't say that; I just looked it up: "310-12 (a) Grounded Conductors. Insulated conductors of No. 6 or smaller, intended for use as grounded conductors of circuits, shall have an outer identification of a white or natural gray color" [doesn't say green, doesn't say continuous] Article 310-12(b) is for equipment grounding conductors, and *it* says the covering must have a continuous green covering or green stripe, and it has an exception allowing the just the ends to be taped green "where conditions of maintenance and supervision blah blah blah" He's trying to apply parts of article 310-12b that don't really apply to article 310-12a. 310-12a doesn't have an exception about taping the ends white under "conditions of maintenance and supervision" because no exception is necessary. Best regards, Bob |
#12
|
|||
|
|||
Electrical inspector makes up new rules during inspection
I've already changed the undersized boxes and removed most of the
nonlisted staples. I do have an attitude problem, and it gets worse the more I think about it. Then stop thinking about it. You can't win, you'll just get madder. He was sarcastic and belittling. He said he would be there probably about 10:00 and he didn't show up until noon. When he was looking at the service panel in my basement, he disconnected a cable TV ground wire that was in his way, and he didn't hook it back up again. The ground may have been a mistake, and isn't a big deal. Approximate times are just that, he showed up a few hours late. He has other places to inspect, you don't. You could have called and canceled the inspection if it was an issue to you. He said the #6 neutral wire had to be marked white or gray or green from end-to-end by the manufacturer. The code doesn't say that; I just looked it up: "310-12 (a) Grounded Conductors. Insulated conductors of No. 6 or smaller, intended for use as grounded conductors of circuits, shall have an outer identification of a white or natural gray color" [doesn't say green, doesn't say continuous] Article 310-12(b) is for equipment grounding conductors, and *it* says the covering must have a continuous green covering or green stripe, and it has an exception allowing the just the ends to be taped green "where conditions of maintenance and supervision blah blah blah" He's trying to apply parts of article 310-12b that don't really apply to article 310-12a. 310-12a doesn't have an exception about taping the ends white under "conditions of maintenance and supervision" because no exception is necessary. *All* code is as interpreted by the inspector and/or building official. Stop ****ing and moaning. Either fix the problems so you pass the inspection or call the building official and ask for a grievance hearing. Jeff |
#13
|
|||
|
|||
Electrical inspector makes up new rules during inspection
@charter.net wrote in message ...
He said the #6 neutral wire had to be marked white or gray or green from end-to-end by the manufacturer. The code doesn't say that; I just looked it up: "310-12 (a) Grounded Conductors. Insulated conductors of No. 6 or smaller, intended for use as grounded conductors of circuits, shall have an outer identification of a white or natural gray color" [doesn't say green, doesn't say continuous] The grounded conductor is your NEUTRAL. It must be totally white or grey in sizes 6 and smaller. My Home Depot carries 3 and usually 4 colors in sizes 6 - 14. The inspector is correct that you must replace the neutral, but to me this is a rather picky item if you've done a good job recoloring it. Equipment groundING conductors are bare, green, or green with a yellow stripe. If you ran a 3 wire feeder, you have no equipment grounding conductor in that feeder (assuming you have 120V loads). I don't know why he wants you to move your grounding electrode conductor to the other bus -- the busses are basically one and the same since you've got the bonding screw installed. Article 310-12(b) is for equipment grounding conductors, and *it* says the covering must have a continuous green covering or green stripe, and it has an exception allowing the just the ends to be taped green "where conditions of maintenance and supervision blah blah blah" He's trying to apply parts of article 310-12b that don't really apply to article 310-12a. 310-12a doesn't have an exception about taping the ends white under "conditions of maintenance and supervision" because no exception is necessary. Sounds like you both need to learn the difference between groundING and groundED. If you plan to have 120V loads in your panel, the wire must be white. It its 240V only, it can be green (and I'd remove the neutral bus to avoid any possible future confusion). You could also run a 4 wire feeder with 2 blacks, a white, and a green. Then, the green and white must terminate on isolated busses (with the green wire bus bonded to the panel chassis). -- Mark Kent, WA |
#14
|
|||
|
|||
Electrical inspector makes up new rules during inspection
Mark or Sue wrote:
@charter.net wrote in message ... He said the #6 neutral wire had to be marked white or gray or green from end-to-end by the manufacturer. The code doesn't say that; I just looked it up: "310-12 (a) Grounded Conductors. Insulated conductors of No. 6 or smaller, intended for use as grounded conductors of circuits, shall have an outer identification of a white or natural gray color" [doesn't say green, doesn't say continuous] The grounded conductor is your NEUTRAL. It must be totally white or grey in sizes 6 and smaller. My Home Depot carries 3 and usually 4 colors in sizes 6 - 14. The inspector is correct that you must replace the neutral, but to me this is a rather picky item if you've done a good job recoloring it. Equipment groundING conductors are bare, green, or green with a yellow stripe. If you ran a 3 wire feeder, you have no equipment grounding conductor in that feeder (assuming you have 120V loads). I don't know why he wants you to move your grounding electrode conductor to the other bus -- the busses are basically one and the same since you've got the bonding screw installed. Article 310-12(b) is for equipment grounding conductors, and *it* says the covering must have a continuous green covering or green stripe, and it has an exception allowing the just the ends to be taped green "where conditions of maintenance and supervision blah blah blah" He's trying to apply parts of article 310-12b that don't really apply to article 310-12a. 310-12a doesn't have an exception about taping the ends white under "conditions of maintenance and supervision" because no exception is necessary. Sounds like you both need to learn the difference between groundING and groundED. If you plan to have 120V loads in your panel, the wire must be white. It its 240V only, it can be green (and I'd remove the neutral bus to avoid any possible future confusion). You could also run a 4 wire feeder with 2 blacks, a white, and a green. Then, the green and white must terminate on isolated busses (with the green wire bus bonded to the panel chassis). This is a 120/240 three wire feeder. The neutral is groundED, and I make a new groundING conductor at the building. The wire has to be white (or gray, but *not* green), but unless 310-12(a) has been rewritten recently, it does not say the wire must be white continuous from end-to-end. Therefore taping the ends (which I did) should be OK. I only mentioned 310-12(b) because that's where it says a wire smaller than #4 must be continuous green or green striped from end-to-end; it has an exception for just marking the ends "under conditions of maintenence and supervision". Since Inspector said the wire could be white or green, I'd have to say he just barely knows what he's talking about (I'm being generous here) and he's making all this up as he goes. When I finish redoing everything that actually is wrong (the undersize boxes, replace the rest of the non-listed staples, install clamps instead of just plastic bushings where cables enter the panel), I'll call and ask for a supervisor to reinspect it. -Bob |
#15
|
|||
|
|||
Electrical inspector makes up new rules during inspection
"zxcvbob" wrote in message ...
This is a 120/240 three wire feeder. The neutral is groundED, and I make a new groundING conductor at the building. The wire has to be white (or gray, but *not* green), but unless 310-12(a) has been rewritten recently, it does not say the wire must be white continuous from end-to-end. Therefore taping the ends (which I did) should be OK. I only mentioned 310-12(b) because that's where it says a wire smaller than #4 must be continuous green or green striped from end-to-end; it has an exception for just marking the ends "under conditions of maintenence and supervision". I think you have an old code book. If you are under the 2002 NEC it must be continuously white. Here the applicable rule: 200.6 Means of Identifying Grounded Conductors. (A) Sizes 6 AWG or Smaller. An insulated grounded conductor of 6 AWG or smaller shall be identified by a continuous white or gray outer finish or by three continuous white stripes on other than green insulation along its entire length. Wires that have their outer covering finished to show a white or gray color but have colored tracer threads in the braid identifying the source of manufacture shall be considered as meeting the provisions of this section. Insulated grounded conductors shall also be permitted to be identified as follows: (1) The grounded conductor of a mineral-insulated, metal sheathed cable shall be identified at the time of installation by distinctive marking at its terminations. (2) A single-conductor, sunlight-resistant, outdoor-rated cable used as a grounded conductor in photovoltaic power systems as permitted by 690.31 shall be identified at the time of installation by distinctive white marking at all terminations. (3) Fixture wire shall comply with the requirements for grounded conductor identification as specified in 402.8 (4) For aerial cable, the identification shall be as above, or by means of a ridge located on the exterior of the cable so as to identify it. -- Mark Kent, WA |
#16
|
|||
|
|||
Electrical inspector makes up new rules during inspection
Mark or Sue wrote:
"zxcvbob" wrote in message ... This is a 120/240 three wire feeder. The neutral is groundED, and I make a new groundING conductor at the building. The wire has to be white (or gray, but *not* green), but unless 310-12(a) has been rewritten recently, it does not say the wire must be white continuous from end-to-end. Therefore taping the ends (which I did) should be OK. I only mentioned 310-12(b) because that's where it says a wire smaller than #4 must be continuous green or green striped from end-to-end; it has an exception for just marking the ends "under conditions of maintenence and supervision". I think you have an old code book. If you are under the 2002 NEC it must be continuously white. Here the applicable rule: 200.6 Means of Identifying Grounded Conductors. (A) Sizes 6 AWG or Smaller. An insulated grounded conductor of 6 AWG or smaller shall be identified by a continuous white or gray outer finish or by three continuous white stripes on other than green insulation along its entire length. Wires that have their outer covering finished to show a white or gray color but have colored tracer threads in the braid identifying the source of manufacture shall be considered as meeting the provisions of this section. Insulated grounded conductors shall also be permitted to be identified as follows: (1) The grounded conductor of a mineral-insulated, metal sheathed cable shall be identified at the time of installation by distinctive marking at its terminations. (2) A single-conductor, sunlight-resistant, outdoor-rated cable used as a grounded conductor in photovoltaic power systems as permitted by 690.31 shall be identified at the time of installation by distinctive white marking at all terminations. (3) Fixture wire shall comply with the requirements for grounded conductor identification as specified in 402.8 (4) For aerial cable, the identification shall be as above, or by means of a ridge located on the exterior of the cable so as to identify it. -- Mark Kent, WA My book is 1993. Also, I looked through a 1999 book last year and didn't see anything like what you just quoted. Maybe it's new for 2002. Is there an exception for "conditions of maintenence and supervision"? The exception wouldn't apply here, but it would indicate that the inspector has leeway when applying the rule and I could try asking politely about it. (I've just figured out tonight that the *real issue* is probably that he just doesn't like the overhead wiring method for feeder circuits, so he's gonna make it as hard as possible for me) When I showed him my plans last fall, he suggested that I run the feeder underground, even though I would have to run at least 50' more wire (times 4 conductors) and somehow trench under my back deck -- or else trench all the way around the house. If I have to, I can replace the wire with that scrap of #4 aluminum wire that I have (also black, but I *can* tape it). Thanks, regards, Bob |
#17
|
|||
|
|||
Electrical inspector makes up new rules during inspection
"zxcvbob" wrote in message
My book is 1993. Also, I looked through a 1999 book last year and didn't see anything like what you just quoted... Cough Cough! Before you go accusing the building inspector of anything, filing a grievance, etc., I would read the newest code book, see if there are any addendums/updates to that book *and* see if your local governing body has any local modifications to the electrical code (not unusual). The local guys have the final say on this stuff. Also before installing your aluminum wire, which I assume you will be running with copper wire, I would ask a local electrical inspector if this would be OK. (In my area you can go to their office during certain hours and ask questions before doing the work.) These inspectors know a lot of electrical theory and I would not be surprised if there was some reason for overhead lines to be the same type wire due to inductance (electrical interaction between wires) or whatever. (I don't know, but best to ask ahead of time.) For example of weird situations which can occur: They had me install ground lugs on both ends of a conduit carrying only a ground wire to prevent a possible "choke" condition. This is where the conduit could act as a "coil" in the way it interacts with the ground wire [were it not grounded at both ends]. (Advanced electrician stuff.) |
#18
|
|||
|
|||
Electrical inspector makes up new rules during inspection
Reminds me of a story of my own. I bought a new house and was moving a
small portable spa to it. I knew a guy who was a part time electrician, so I asked him to install a sub panel and run a 40 AMP GFCI circuit to the outside location. He wanted to do it the right way and take out a permit. I was very reluctant, figuring we could be in for lots of trouble, but finally I agreed. He goes over to the building dept and gets an education. The building inspector gave him a copy of a proposed BOCA code that requires SPAs to have a cover that is strong enough to support rescue workers walking on it. Can you believe it? For a small 2 to3 person SPA? And it was only a proposed code. Virtually every spa I ever saw doesn't have a cover that would meet this. Needless to say, he was now in agreement with my point of view. |
#19
|
|||
|
|||
Electrical inspector makes up new rules during inspection
On Thu, 11 Mar 2004 16:50:46 GMT, "Horizon99"
wrote: Reminds me of a story of my own. I bought a new house and was moving a small portable spa to it. I knew a guy who was a part time electrician, so I asked him to install a sub panel and run a 40 AMP GFCI circuit to the outside location. He wanted to do it the right way and take out a permit. I was very reluctant, figuring we could be in for lots of trouble, but finally I agreed. He goes over to the building dept and gets an education. The building inspector gave him a copy of a proposed BOCA code that requires SPAs to have a cover that is strong enough to support rescue workers walking on it. Can you believe it? For a small 2 to3 person SPA? And it was only a proposed code. Virtually every spa I ever saw doesn't have a cover that would meet this. Needless to say, he was now in agreement with my point of view. Well, there you go. |
#20
|
|||
|
|||
Electrical inspector makes up new rules during inspection
PJx wrote:
I just did a bunch of work on my house including a new roof. I though about getting a permit, which is required by law, but decided against it. I've saved myself some money and feel good about it. Yeah? Well, when you sell the house you might have to get a permit and get it inspected or else remove it. That happens around here all the time, at least. -- I know God will not give me anything I can't handle. I just wish that He didn't trust me so much. - Mother Teresa |
#21
|
|||
|
|||
Electrical inspector makes up new rules during inspection
On Thu, 11 Mar 2004 20:07:35 GMT, Melinda Meahan - remove TRASH to
reply wrote: PJx wrote: I just did a bunch of work on my house including a new roof. I though about getting a permit, which is required by law, but decided against it. I've saved myself some money and feel good about it. Yeah? Well, when you sell the house you might have to get a permit and get it inspected or else remove it. That happens around here all the time, at least. You have some 'big brothers' that are spying on you up there? We don't allow that here in Texas. We shoot em. Pj |
#22
|
|||
|
|||
Electrical inspector makes up new rules during inspection
When I lived in Texas we all knew that the way to pass an elctrical
inspection was to leave at least a $20 bill in the entrance panel. Green bill begets green tag. RB PJx wrote: On Thu, 11 Mar 2004 20:07:35 GMT, Melinda Meahan - remove TRASH to reply wrote: PJx wrote: I just did a bunch of work on my house including a new roof. I though about getting a permit, which is required by law, but decided against it. I've saved myself some money and feel good about it. Yeah? Well, when you sell the house you might have to get a permit and get it inspected or else remove it. That happens around here all the time, at least. You have some 'big brothers' that are spying on you up there? We don't allow that here in Texas. We shoot em. Pj |
#23
|
|||
|
|||
Electrical inspector makes up new rules during inspection
RB wrote:
When I lived in Texas we all knew that the way to pass an elctrical inspection was to leave at least a $20 bill in the entrance panel. Green bill begets green tag. Damn! I've been away from Texas *way* too long, and I forgot all about that. Coulda saved myself a lot of rework.... -Bob |
Reply |
Thread Tools | Search this Thread |
Display Modes | |
|
|
Similar Threads | ||||
Thread | Forum | |||
Overhead electrical service to a storage shed | Home Repair |