Woodworking (rec.woodworking) Discussion forum covering all aspects of working with wood. All levels of expertise are encouraged to particiapte.

Reply
 
LinkBack Thread Tools Search this Thread Display Modes
  #1   Report Post  
Posted to rec.woodworking
external usenet poster
 
Posts: 5
Default Request help with bookcase

Folks, I need some help, and this newsgroup is as close as I could find
to the issue. I hope some of you can makes some time to read this and
give me your expert advice as woodworkers.

I recently purchased a replica bookcase made from solid mahogany. It's a
6 part bookcase, with a base that runs the entire length, 2 bottom units
with wooden doors, 2 top units with glass doors, and a crown that again
runs the full length.

Here's a picture. Note, this is not the store where I bought it from.
http://www.mrhiggins.nl/product.php?p=109


The bookcase is OK, but the guys that delivered it obviously weren't used
to placing these large pieces of furniture. They didn't bring any tools
at all.

They assembled the bookcase in the room, then pushed it against the wall
where it was supposed to stand, then asked for some little bits of wood
to put under one corner to straighten it (after I told them it was
hanging over to the front on one side). Then they left. They kinda looked
like amateurs.

The bookcase now slightly moves to the back if you push it on one corner,
it's not entirely supported. Also, and this is the bigger problem, the 2
bottom units no longer align, one is no longer standing straight in the
base. The company said just to fill it with books and it would move into
place by itself. The top units can be moved together (they're not locked
into place, their weight keeps them in place) but there's a gap at the
bottom where they meet. Looks like the case is sorta sagging in the
middle.

I am under the impression the base is actually no longer straight,
pressure from the weight seems to make the board move outwards.

The base is basically a rather thin board on its side running the four
sides. Not feet. But with the bit of wood under one corner, the entire
bookcase just rests on the four corners of the board, there's no support
in the middle whatsoever.

My questions:

- is this safe? If you'd design a base like this, isn't it supposed to be
supported over the entire length?

- is the company correct? Will it move into place by itself if it starts
carrying weight?

- if not, what is the proper way of setting up this type of furniture,
taking the uneven floor into account?

I'm a bit miffed at the company, since I'm alone,
disassembling/reassembling this won't be easy. Need to get some kind
neighbour to help. So if it has to be done, I want to make sure it's done
the right way first time.

All advice is very much appreciated!

Happy holidays all!

Neko



  #2   Report Post  
Posted to rec.woodworking
external usenet poster
 
Posts: 553
Default Request help with bookcase


"KuroNeko" wrote in message
...
Folks, I need some help, and this newsgroup is as close as I could find
to the issue. I hope some of you can makes some time to read this and
give me your expert advice as woodworkers.

I recently purchased a replica bookcase made from solid mahogany. It's a
6 part bookcase, with a base that runs the entire length, 2 bottom units
with wooden doors, 2 top units with glass doors, and a crown that again
runs the full length.

Here's a picture. Note, this is not the store where I bought it from.
http://www.mrhiggins.nl/product.php?p=109


The bookcase is OK, but the guys that delivered it obviously weren't used
to placing these large pieces of furniture. They didn't bring any tools
at all.

They assembled the bookcase in the room, then pushed it against the wall
where it was supposed to stand, then asked for some little bits of wood
to put under one corner to straighten it (after I told them it was
hanging over to the front on one side). Then they left. They kinda looked
like amateurs.

The bookcase now slightly moves to the back if you push it on one corner,
it's not entirely supported. Also, and this is the bigger problem, the 2
bottom units no longer align, one is no longer standing straight in the
base. The company said just to fill it with books and it would move into
place by itself. The top units can be moved together (they're not locked
into place, their weight keeps them in place) but there's a gap at the
bottom where they meet. Looks like the case is sorta sagging in the
middle.

I am under the impression the base is actually no longer straight,
pressure from the weight seems to make the board move outwards.

The base is basically a rather thin board on its side running the four
sides. Not feet. But with the bit of wood under one corner, the entire
bookcase just rests on the four corners of the board, there's no support
in the middle whatsoever.

My questions:

- is this safe? If you'd design a base like this, isn't it supposed to be
supported over the entire length?

- is the company correct? Will it move into place by itself if it starts
carrying weight?

- if not, what is the proper way of setting up this type of furniture,
taking the uneven floor into account?

I'm a bit miffed at the company, since I'm alone,
disassembling/reassembling this won't be easy. Need to get some kind
neighbour to help. So if it has to be done, I want to make sure it's done
the right way first time.

All advice is very much appreciated!

Happy holidays all!

Neko

This is a large unit and because it is in six pieces, any unevenness
in the base is going to only get worse as you add height and
pieces.

The bookcase needs to be unstacked and the base piece shimmed
to the uneven floor to bring it to flat and level with full lenght bearing
on the floor then as the pieces are added they need to be lined up
and connected with screws in inconspicous places. Somewhere
out of sight and along the top edge it would be useful to connect the
unit to the wall with brackets.

If delivery and setup was included in the deal, I would make an effort
to get this redone by the company that sold you the bookcase.

basilisk




  #3   Report Post  
Posted to rec.woodworking
external usenet poster
 
Posts: 2,804
Default Request help with bookcase

I agree with basilisk. By your description of work, seems the
purchase included delivery and set-up, so the company is obligated to
supply competent installers. Have them come back and install it
correctly. A competent installer would be aware that not all homes
are perfectly level and would come equipted to install correctly in
any situation. A competent company would hire or train competent
installers, also.

replica competent company with replica competent installers

Sonny
  #4   Report Post  
Posted to rec.woodworking
external usenet poster
 
Posts: 4,207
Default Request help with bookcase

KuroNeko wrote:
Folks, I need some help, and this newsgroup is as close as I could
find to the issue. I hope some of you can makes some time to read
this and give me your expert advice as woodworkers.

I recently purchased a replica bookcase made from solid mahogany.
It's a 6 part bookcase, with a base that runs the entire length, 2
bottom units with wooden doors, 2 top units with glass doors, and a
crown that again runs the full length.

Here's a picture. Note, this is not the store where I bought it from.
http://www.mrhiggins.nl/product.php?p=109


The bookcase is OK, but the guys that delivered it obviously weren't
used to placing these large pieces of furniture. They didn't bring
any tools at all.

They assembled the bookcase in the room, then pushed it against the
wall where it was supposed to stand, then asked for some little bits
of wood to put under one corner to straighten it (after I told them
it was hanging over to the front on one side). Then they left. They
kinda looked like amateurs.

The bookcase now slightly moves to the back if you push it on one
corner, it's not entirely supported. Also, and this is the bigger
problem, the 2 bottom units no longer align, one is no longer
standing straight in the base. The company said just to fill it with
books and it would move into place by itself. The top units can be
moved together (they're not locked into place, their weight keeps
them in place) but there's a gap at the bottom where they meet. Looks
like the case is sorta sagging in the middle.

I am under the impression the base is actually no longer straight,
pressure from the weight seems to make the board move outwards.

The base is basically a rather thin board on its side running the four
sides. Not feet. But with the bit of wood under one corner, the entire
bookcase just rests on the four corners of the board, there's no
support in the middle whatsoever.

My questions:

- is this safe? If you'd design a base like this, isn't it supposed
to be supported over the entire length?

- is the company correct? Will it move into place by itself if it
starts carrying weight?

- if not, what is the proper way of setting up this type of furniture,
taking the uneven floor into account?

I'm a bit miffed at the company, since I'm alone,
disassembling/reassembling this won't be easy. Need to get some kind
neighbour to help. So if it has to be done, I want to make sure it's
done the right way first time.

All advice is very much appreciated!

Happy holidays all!


Before you do anything else, check to make sure that they actually assembled
the units so that they were square. If they didn't then until you correct
that you're going to be fighting an uphill battle.

To check, just measure the diagonals going both ways and make sure they're
the same--you can do this with a piece of string--pull it tight along one
diagonal, mark the string at the outside corners, then pull it along the
other and see if the marks match--if they don't then it's out of square and
you need to fix that.

Next set the base in place and level and shim it. You're going to need some
kind of level to do that--one that's a little longer than the longest
dimension will let you not only level it but also use the level as a
reference surface so you can be sure the base is flat enough along the top.

Here's an illustrated description of the shimming process and an alternative
scribing process,
http://books.google.com/books?id=9pG...20base&f=false
or http://tinyurl.com/ykpmmgw . You want to shim, not scribe, unless you're
_sure_ that the bookcase will never be moved. At a minimun you want solid
support (either shim or floor) under each corner and under the center in
front and back and you may want more. You can find premade shimming wedges
at a building supply store.

Once the shims are in place you'll want to cut them off flush with the
front--some blue painters' tape on the front of the base will protect it
from getting scarred by the saw or chisel you use to do that (if you don't
have a good sharpening setup then go with a saw--you want one purpose-made
for flush cutting such as
http://www.leevalley.com/wood/page.a...28&cat=1,42884, or a Fein
Multimaster or one of its clones if you happen to have one).

Now assemble the bookcase and it should sit level and be well supported.
You may have unsightly gaps under it though--if so, you can get some molding
and mahogany stain and use the molding to cover the gaps.

  #5   Report Post  
Posted to rec.woodworking
external usenet poster
 
Posts: 10,043
Default Request help with bookcase

KuroNeko wrote:

I'm a bit miffed at the company, since I'm alone,
disassembling/reassembling this won't be easy. Need to get some kind
neighbour to help. So if it has to be done, I want to make sure it's done
the right way first time.


The retailer is at fault for not installing the product properly.

Do the doors open and close without trouble in the bottom unit? If the
base is not level and the bottom unit is sagging in the middle, the
doors not working properly would be another indication of that.

"fill it with books" to make it sit properly?? That is nonsense and the
sign of poor design.

From your description, the picture, and having built many similar
units, I suspect that you've bought a poorly designed/built unit that
will give you problems and would advise that you consider trying to get
it replaced.

Short of that, find someone to install it properly and insure that it is
well built enough to stand up to the task.

BTW, if you do install levelers, you would be best with six instead of
the usual four; one on each corner, and two in the middle, front and back.

--
www.e-woodshop.net
Last update: 10/22/08
KarlC@ (the obvious)


  #6   Report Post  
Posted to rec.woodworking
external usenet poster
 
Posts: 5
Default Request help with bookcase

Thanks very much for the detailed reply! Excellent guide on how to do it.

The assembly is pretty straighforward, they didn't really mess that up.
These guys simply didn't have experience in doing this. They didn't check
if it was level, just shoved it against the wall and put some wood under a
corner to keep it from leaning over. That's maybe good enough if your
bookcase is on 4 feet, but with this construction it doesn't work so it
seems.

Thanks for all the clarification and help. I'm more confindent I can fix
this now

I've asked a co-worker with lots of muscle to come and help :-)

Have a merry Xmas!

Neko


  #7   Report Post  
Posted to rec.woodworking
external usenet poster
 
Posts: 5
Default Request help with bookcase

Swingman divulged in
:

The retailer is at fault for not installing the product properly.


So they are. In their defence, they're friendly enough and try their best
as far as their knowledge goes. But they're a small start-up outfit
that's more into the importing and selecting (of which they do a good
enough job) but less in the installation. Once they get going I'm sure
they'll get people for that. But that doesn't excuse the shoddy job now.


Do the doors open and close without trouble in the bottom unit? If the
base is not level and the bottom unit is sagging in the middle, the
doors not working properly would be another indication of that.


They open OK, but I noticed the right bottom doors don't close flush,
they're a bit open at the bottom. I removed the bit of wood under the
right corner (the only shim they placed) and now the doors' close better.
So yes, it would seem you are right and the problem is indeed that the
base is not level.

"fill it with books" to make it sit properly?? That is nonsense and
the sign of poor design.


Nah, just "I don't really know how to solve this so I'll just make
something up" reply. The bookcase is built the old fashioned way, pretty
solid construction.

From your description, the picture, and having built many similar
units, I suspect that you've bought a poorly designed/built unit that
will give you problems and would advise that you consider trying to
get it replaced.


Not really an option. I think the build quality and design is OK, perhaps
they should have used a thicker board to make the base of, but according
to a local timbershop, it should really be fine. Just not on REALLY
unlevel floors like in my old house.

Short of that, find someone to install it properly and insure that it
is well built enough to stand up to the task.


I've read the advice of another poster on how to properly shim it and
have asked a strong co-worker to come over and help.

BTW, if you do install levelers, you would be best with six instead of
the usual four; one on each corner, and two in the middle, front and
back.


I hear you! Thanks very much for all the good advice! Have a great Xmas!

Neko

  #8   Report Post  
Posted to rec.woodworking
external usenet poster
 
Posts: 5
Default Request help with bookcase

This is a large unit and because it is in six pieces, any unevenness
in the base is going to only get worse as you add height and
pieces.


That's what I figured and why I posted here for advice, before I started
doing all that work and having to empty it again later :-)

The bookcase needs to be unstacked and the base piece shimmed
to the uneven floor to bring it to flat and level with full lenght
bearing on the floor then as the pieces are added they need to be
lined up


Got it. Another poster posted a guide, I'll take care to follow it.

and connected with screws in inconspicous places. Somewhere
out of sight and along the top edge it would be useful to connect the
unit to the wall with brackets.


I can screw the two bottom units together if needed. Do you feel securing
the top to the wall is really necessary? I don't have kids who'd go
climbing up the bookcase. I can do this if necessary though.

If delivery and setup was included in the deal, I would make an effort
to get this redone by the company that sold you the bookcase.


I could call and ask them to come again. But since they clearly didn't know
what they were doing the first time round, I rather do it myself according
to the excellent advice given by all you guys. Thanks again for that!

Have a great Xmas!

Neko
  #9   Report Post  
Posted to rec.woodworking
external usenet poster
 
Posts: 5
Default Request help with bookcase

Hi Sonny,

I agree with basilisk. By your description of work, seems the
purchase included delivery and set-up, so the company is obligated to
supply competent installers. Have them come back and install it
correctly. A competent installer would be aware that not all homes

^^^^^^^^^^^^
There's the problem :-) Having them come again wouldn't really solve
anything.

are perfectly level and would come equipted to install correctly in
any situation. A competent company would hire or train competent
installers, also.


Yes indeed it would. My guess is, they will as soon as they can afford it.
Being a two person start-up means they probably can't afford it now. If I
ever buy a bookcase or large piece of furniture from them again, I'll have
to add the cost of a pro installer as extra :-/

The quality of what they sell isn't top level (but I could never afford an
English bookcase actually made by traditional English furniture makers) but
it is solid wood, nicely enough crafted, and very affordable (the guy I
linked to sells from the same Indonesian manufacturer, at more than double
the prices. Paying more doesn't always get you better quality). I searched
for a long time to find a seller of solid wood furniture here, all chipwood
and Ikea stuff here. People don't seem to like lcassic style here, they're
all Ikea fanatics. So apart from the installation troubles I'm pretty happy
with these replacements for my old Ikea junk :-)

Thanks for your advice! Have a merry Xmas!

Neko

  #10   Report Post  
Posted to rec.woodworking
external usenet poster
 
Posts: 3,848
Default Request help with bookcase

KuroNeko wrote:

I can screw the two bottom units together if needed. Do you feel
securing the top to the wall is really necessary? I don't have kids
who'd go climbing up the bookcase. I can do this if necessary though.


You don't *have* to but it is a good idea. Another way to secure it is by
fixing a block of 2x4 to the wall so it is tight against the unit.

--

dadiOH
____________________________

dadiOH's dandies v3.06...
....a help file of info about MP3s, recording from
LP/cassette and tips & tricks on this and that.
Get it at http://mysite.verizon.net/xico



Reply
Thread Tools Search this Thread
Search this Thread:

Advanced Search
Display Modes

Posting Rules

Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off
Trackbacks are On
Pingbacks are On
Refbacks are On


Similar Threads
Thread Thread Starter Forum Replies Last Post
COFFIN - OR BOOKCASE J T Woodworking 0 October 22nd 06 07:58 PM
BOOKCASE. J T Woodworking 0 March 11th 06 08:10 PM
Aargh! Please, Need help with Bookcase 1_Patriotic_Guy Home Repair 17 September 30th 05 07:16 PM
Bookcase help needed 1_Patriotic_Guy Home Repair 3 September 30th 05 05:26 AM
bookcase help George Snyder Woodworking 2 April 3rd 05 10:21 PM


All times are GMT +1. The time now is 09:44 AM.

Powered by vBulletin® Copyright ©2000 - 2024, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Copyright ©2004-2024 DIYbanter.
The comments are property of their posters.
 

About Us

"It's about DIY & home improvement"