Woodworking (rec.woodworking) Discussion forum covering all aspects of working with wood. All levels of expertise are encouraged to particiapte.

Reply
 
LinkBack Thread Tools Search this Thread Display Modes
  #1   Report Post  
Jay Pique
 
Posts: n/a
Default REVIEW: PC 352VS 3x21 Belt Sander

Here goes:

I've been restoring a small old wooden building for the past few
weeks, and have been putting some pretty heavy hours on this Porter
Cable 3x21inch belt sander, model PC352VS. The bulk of it has been
removing paint from timber after having heat stripped it. I've also
done a couple of doors inside and out. Probably 30 hours or so on it
in the past couple of weeks I'd say.

Tracking Adjustment: sorta sucks - you kind of get the hang of it
after a while, but when you turn it a little the belt continues to
drift in/out after you've stopped turning so you have guesstimate how
much to twist the nob. Also, the belt seems to wander fairly easily -
requiring frequent readjustment of the tracking.....which sorta sucks.

Power cord: doesn't bother me at all coming out of the top like that.

Dust Collection: the location is not a problem at all - just spin it
around if you need to. Now the acutal efficiency of it is a bit
suspect. When you sand, for example, a table top, it seems to do
pretty well - I don't really notice too much flying dust/debris. I'd
say it probably only gets maybe half of the overall waste (maybe).
When you sand holding the sander above you or at shoulder level, you
really notice the sh** flying through the air, and it seems as though
it bags just a small fraction of the total waste. Overall though, if
you wear a good mask and eye-protection, I'm comfortable with the dust
collector. It's easy to pop on and off and easy to empty.

Overall Power: this is a tough one to answer, as I've definitely been
able to make it bog down when I really lean into it. However, when
you're belt sanding at chest/shoulder level for hours at a time, you'd
probably prefer not to be lugging *too* much weight around. This unit
weighs 10.75 pounds. I'm a pretty fit 5'10" 170 and believe me I feel
it after a while! The next step up (if you want variable speed) is
the 3x24inch 360VS at 13.5lbs. This has a 12amp motor vs. 8amps on
the 352. Not sure what it all means, but there are times when I'm
flat sanding when I wish the 352 had a little more oomph, but vertical
sanding it feels pretty good to me. You really need to figure out
what you'll be using it for mostly. If I were to have just one BS,
I'd think hard about a bigger unit.

Balance: I've heard some complaints about the motor placement, but
I've had no trouble keeping this unit flat. Even one handing it.

Size: I sort of feel like a longer platen would be much better for
flat sanding, as when you approach an edge you need to be pretty
careful of rocking. If the bulk of your use will be flat finish
sanding I'd go with a longer unit.

Belt Change: Simple and quick with one lever. Tracking is another
issue though.

FINAL THOUGHTS: If you only plan on getting one belt sander, I'd go
with a bigger unit. I'm happy overall with it, as it's serving a
purpose for me right now. But it's just a little small and a little
underpowered for me, and the tracking is annoying. My verdict is if
you're a smaller guy doing a bunch of vertical sanding, this is a good
unit. Otherwise I'd go bigger.

Jay Pique
  #2   Report Post  
George M. Kazaka
 
Posts: n/a
Default REVIEW: PC 352VS 3x21 Belt Sander

The 361 is a hog and will last for years.
I very rarely have to touch the tracking knob and then generally stays where
I leave it.
Also you should not be applying pressure with a belt sander it works at peak
efficiancy with its own weight.
Apply pressure and it will take off enough material to clog the paper.

"Jay Pique" wrote in message
...
Here goes:

I've been restoring a small old wooden building for the past few
weeks, and have been putting some pretty heavy hours on this Porter
Cable 3x21inch belt sander, model PC352VS. The bulk of it has been
removing paint from timber after having heat stripped it. I've also
done a couple of doors inside and out. Probably 30 hours or so on it
in the past couple of weeks I'd say.

Tracking Adjustment: sorta sucks - you kind of get the hang of it
after a while, but when you turn it a little the belt continues to
drift in/out after you've stopped turning so you have guesstimate how
much to twist the nob. Also, the belt seems to wander fairly easily -
requiring frequent readjustment of the tracking.....which sorta sucks.

Power cord: doesn't bother me at all coming out of the top like that.

Dust Collection: the location is not a problem at all - just spin it
around if you need to. Now the acutal efficiency of it is a bit
suspect. When you sand, for example, a table top, it seems to do
pretty well - I don't really notice too much flying dust/debris. I'd
say it probably only gets maybe half of the overall waste (maybe).
When you sand holding the sander above you or at shoulder level, you
really notice the sh** flying through the air, and it seems as though
it bags just a small fraction of the total waste. Overall though, if
you wear a good mask and eye-protection, I'm comfortable with the dust
collector. It's easy to pop on and off and easy to empty.

Overall Power: this is a tough one to answer, as I've definitely been
able to make it bog down when I really lean into it. However, when
you're belt sanding at chest/shoulder level for hours at a time, you'd
probably prefer not to be lugging *too* much weight around. This unit
weighs 10.75 pounds. I'm a pretty fit 5'10" 170 and believe me I feel
it after a while! The next step up (if you want variable speed) is
the 3x24inch 360VS at 13.5lbs. This has a 12amp motor vs. 8amps on
the 352. Not sure what it all means, but there are times when I'm
flat sanding when I wish the 352 had a little more oomph, but vertical
sanding it feels pretty good to me. You really need to figure out
what you'll be using it for mostly. If I were to have just one BS,
I'd think hard about a bigger unit.

Balance: I've heard some complaints about the motor placement, but
I've had no trouble keeping this unit flat. Even one handing it.

Size: I sort of feel like a longer platen would be much better for
flat sanding, as when you approach an edge you need to be pretty
careful of rocking. If the bulk of your use will be flat finish
sanding I'd go with a longer unit.

Belt Change: Simple and quick with one lever. Tracking is another
issue though.

FINAL THOUGHTS: If you only plan on getting one belt sander, I'd go
with a bigger unit. I'm happy overall with it, as it's serving a
purpose for me right now. But it's just a little small and a little
underpowered for me, and the tracking is annoying. My verdict is if
you're a smaller guy doing a bunch of vertical sanding, this is a good
unit. Otherwise I'd go bigger.

Jay Pique



  #3   Report Post  
Jay Pique
 
Posts: n/a
Default REVIEW: PC 352VS 3x21 Belt Sander

On Fri, 14 Nov 2003 19:44:27 -0700, "George M. Kazaka"
wrote:

The 361 is a hog and will last for years.
I very rarely have to touch the tracking knob and then generally stays where
I leave it.
Also you should not be applying pressure with a belt sander it works at peak
efficiancy with its own weight.
Apply pressure and it will take off enough material to clog the paper.


Yeah - that sounds about right. grumble When vertical sanding,
though, you do need to lean into it a *little*.

Forgot this one last time....

Trigger Lock: The conspiracy against lefties continues.... And, also,
when you accidentally yank the power cord out you may want to think
about disengaging the lock before you plug the thing back in.
DAMHIKT.

JP
*********************
HEADS UP!


"Jay Pique" wrote in message
.. .
Here goes:

I've been restoring a small old wooden building for the past few
weeks, and have been putting some pretty heavy hours on this Porter
Cable 3x21inch belt sander, model PC352VS. The bulk of it has been
removing paint from timber after having heat stripped it. I've also
done a couple of doors inside and out. Probably 30 hours or so on it
in the past couple of weeks I'd say.

Tracking Adjustment: sorta sucks - you kind of get the hang of it
after a while, but when you turn it a little the belt continues to
drift in/out after you've stopped turning so you have guesstimate how
much to twist the nob. Also, the belt seems to wander fairly easily -
requiring frequent readjustment of the tracking.....which sorta sucks.

Power cord: doesn't bother me at all coming out of the top like that.

Dust Collection: the location is not a problem at all - just spin it
around if you need to. Now the acutal efficiency of it is a bit
suspect. When you sand, for example, a table top, it seems to do
pretty well - I don't really notice too much flying dust/debris. I'd
say it probably only gets maybe half of the overall waste (maybe).
When you sand holding the sander above you or at shoulder level, you
really notice the sh** flying through the air, and it seems as though
it bags just a small fraction of the total waste. Overall though, if
you wear a good mask and eye-protection, I'm comfortable with the dust
collector. It's easy to pop on and off and easy to empty.

Overall Power: this is a tough one to answer, as I've definitely been
able to make it bog down when I really lean into it. However, when
you're belt sanding at chest/shoulder level for hours at a time, you'd
probably prefer not to be lugging *too* much weight around. This unit
weighs 10.75 pounds. I'm a pretty fit 5'10" 170 and believe me I feel
it after a while! The next step up (if you want variable speed) is
the 3x24inch 360VS at 13.5lbs. This has a 12amp motor vs. 8amps on
the 352. Not sure what it all means, but there are times when I'm
flat sanding when I wish the 352 had a little more oomph, but vertical
sanding it feels pretty good to me. You really need to figure out
what you'll be using it for mostly. If I were to have just one BS,
I'd think hard about a bigger unit.

Balance: I've heard some complaints about the motor placement, but
I've had no trouble keeping this unit flat. Even one handing it.

Size: I sort of feel like a longer platen would be much better for
flat sanding, as when you approach an edge you need to be pretty
careful of rocking. If the bulk of your use will be flat finish
sanding I'd go with a longer unit.

Belt Change: Simple and quick with one lever. Tracking is another
issue though.

FINAL THOUGHTS: If you only plan on getting one belt sander, I'd go
with a bigger unit. I'm happy overall with it, as it's serving a
purpose for me right now. But it's just a little small and a little
underpowered for me, and the tracking is annoying. My verdict is if
you're a smaller guy doing a bunch of vertical sanding, this is a good
unit. Otherwise I'd go bigger.

Jay Pique



  #4   Report Post  
George M. Kazaka
 
Posts: n/a
Default REVIEW: PC 352VS 3x21 Belt Sander

I try not to use the trigger lock for that one reason,
"Jay Pique" wrote in message
...
On Fri, 14 Nov 2003 19:44:27 -0700, "George M. Kazaka"
wrote:

The 361 is a hog and will last for years.
I very rarely have to touch the tracking knob and then generally stays

where
I leave it.
Also you should not be applying pressure with a belt sander it works at

peak
efficiancy with its own weight.
Apply pressure and it will take off enough material to clog the paper.


Yeah - that sounds about right. grumble When vertical sanding,
though, you do need to lean into it a *little*.

Forgot this one last time....

Trigger Lock: The conspiracy against lefties continues.... And, also,
when you accidentally yank the power cord out you may want to think
about disengaging the lock before you plug the thing back in.
DAMHIKT.

JP
*********************
HEADS UP!


"Jay Pique" wrote in message
.. .
Here goes:

I've been restoring a small old wooden building for the past few
weeks, and have been putting some pretty heavy hours on this Porter
Cable 3x21inch belt sander, model PC352VS. The bulk of it has been
removing paint from timber after having heat stripped it. I've also
done a couple of doors inside and out. Probably 30 hours or so on it
in the past couple of weeks I'd say.

Tracking Adjustment: sorta sucks - you kind of get the hang of it
after a while, but when you turn it a little the belt continues to
drift in/out after you've stopped turning so you have guesstimate how
much to twist the nob. Also, the belt seems to wander fairly easily -
requiring frequent readjustment of the tracking.....which sorta sucks.

Power cord: doesn't bother me at all coming out of the top like that.

Dust Collection: the location is not a problem at all - just spin it
around if you need to. Now the acutal efficiency of it is a bit
suspect. When you sand, for example, a table top, it seems to do
pretty well - I don't really notice too much flying dust/debris. I'd
say it probably only gets maybe half of the overall waste (maybe).
When you sand holding the sander above you or at shoulder level, you
really notice the sh** flying through the air, and it seems as though
it bags just a small fraction of the total waste. Overall though, if
you wear a good mask and eye-protection, I'm comfortable with the dust
collector. It's easy to pop on and off and easy to empty.

Overall Power: this is a tough one to answer, as I've definitely been
able to make it bog down when I really lean into it. However, when
you're belt sanding at chest/shoulder level for hours at a time, you'd
probably prefer not to be lugging *too* much weight around. This unit
weighs 10.75 pounds. I'm a pretty fit 5'10" 170 and believe me I feel
it after a while! The next step up (if you want variable speed) is
the 3x24inch 360VS at 13.5lbs. This has a 12amp motor vs. 8amps on
the 352. Not sure what it all means, but there are times when I'm
flat sanding when I wish the 352 had a little more oomph, but vertical
sanding it feels pretty good to me. You really need to figure out
what you'll be using it for mostly. If I were to have just one BS,
I'd think hard about a bigger unit.

Balance: I've heard some complaints about the motor placement, but
I've had no trouble keeping this unit flat. Even one handing it.

Size: I sort of feel like a longer platen would be much better for
flat sanding, as when you approach an edge you need to be pretty
careful of rocking. If the bulk of your use will be flat finish
sanding I'd go with a longer unit.

Belt Change: Simple and quick with one lever. Tracking is another
issue though.

FINAL THOUGHTS: If you only plan on getting one belt sander, I'd go
with a bigger unit. I'm happy overall with it, as it's serving a
purpose for me right now. But it's just a little small and a little
underpowered for me, and the tracking is annoying. My verdict is if
you're a smaller guy doing a bunch of vertical sanding, this is a good
unit. Otherwise I'd go bigger.

Jay Pique





  #5   Report Post  
Pat James
 
Posts: n/a
Default REVIEW: PC 352VS 3x21 Belt Sander

"Trent©" wrote in message
...
I'm in the process of refinishing our kitchen cabinets.

I took the doors outside...and used the RotoMate on them.


Curious -- what is a RotoMate? Tried Google and came up dry.




  #6   Report Post  
Jay Pique
 
Posts: n/a
Default REVIEW: PC 352VS 3x21 Belt Sander

On Sun, 23 Nov 2003 19:12:15 -0500, Trent©
wrote:

snip
Yer might be using the wrong tool(s)...and/or procedure...to
accomplish what you want to do.

I'm in the process of refinishing our kitchen cabinets.

I took the doors outside...and used the RotoMate on them. I did 4
large doors...both sides...in 1 hour. Each door had about 6-10 layers
of oil base and latex paint...and it came off with no effort at all.
Used 1 sanding disc for all this...and its still not worn out. All
the doors were then 60 grit sanded (another 8-10 minutes per
door)...then 220 sanded (less than 5 minutes per door).

The inside frames my wife did with ReadyStrip. No fumes...no mess (it
comes off dry)...but it did take 2 coats. Afterward, it took a quick
hit with 220 paper...and was ready for the linseed oil.

For anyone lurking...just another way to skin a cat.

With all the new advances in woodworking technology, I think a belt
sander has pretty much become obsolete...at least for me.


This particular belt sander is starting to become a PITA for me. The
tracking adjustment REALLY won't stay put - especially when you try to
use an oval shaped sanding pattern.

Were I to do it over, I'd definitely consider some of the chemical
strippers out there, followed by some sanding for sure.

JP
Reply
Thread Tools Search this Thread
Search this Thread:

Advanced Search
Display Modes

Posting Rules

Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off
Trackbacks are On
Pingbacks are On
Refbacks are On


Similar Threads
Thread Thread Starter Forum Replies Last Post
Belt sander clogging Ernie Jurick Woodworking 6 November 4th 03 09:45 PM
Hand belt sander converts to stationary table sander? Les Fingers Woodworking 2 September 4th 03 02:37 PM
Want to surprise my husband with a belt sander, but WHICH ONE??? Edwin Pawlowski Woodworking 13 July 16th 03 04:11 AM


All times are GMT +1. The time now is 01:40 PM.

Powered by vBulletin® Copyright ©2000 - 2024, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Copyright ©2004-2024 DIYbanter.
The comments are property of their posters.
 

About Us

"It's about DIY & home improvement"