Woodworking (rec.woodworking) Discussion forum covering all aspects of working with wood. All levels of expertise are encouraged to particiapte.

Reply
 
LinkBack Thread Tools Search this Thread Display Modes
  #1   Report Post  
peter
 
Posts: n/a
Default Deck Decision Help



I have too little experience with IPE to comment intellegently
on it. I have built several wood and trex decks, one with cedar
rails. It looks and works well. The clients are happy with it.

Trex does have low maintenance and looks good. Make sure it
has enough support. Joists need to be 12 inches apart rather than the
16 or 24 inches you can use for wood. Same with the steps.

Also note that you would not want to put anything heavy on the
deck. If the planters you spoke of are larger than a couple of
gallons, put put a layer of wooden decking under the trex in those
spots to avoid sags. Don't expect to put anything on the deck for any
length of time of the mass and weight of a piano, freezer, or lawn
tractor. You don't usually have to worry about weighing it down with
too many people; they don't usually stay long enough to create sags.

Enjoy your new deck.


Peter



  #2   Report Post  
Leon
 
Posts: n/a
Default Deck Decision Help

With the small difference in price between the cheapest and the most
expensive, I would strongly suggest Ipe on top and PT on the bottom side.
IMHO none of the other products comes close to the beauty and rich look if
Ipe.
You seem to have all the specs before you about maintenance, go with what
looks good.





  #3   Report Post  
Rick Chamberlain
 
Posts: n/a
Default Deck Decision Help

snippage

After reasearching on the net, I was leaning towards the Ipe. Some of
the websites make it looks absolutely stunning. After seeing the Ipe
deck, I didn't really think it looked much better than cedar, but if it
really is much longer lasting and much lower maintanance than cedar,
it's still in the picture.

Any advice?

Anything I should check with the contractor so that I'm not surprised
about anything?

Thanks in advance!
David

David,

I built exactly the same deck. Used 1x4 and 1x6 Ipe for the decking, PT
for the structure, and WRC for the rail. I also had some of the 1x6 Ipe
resawn for skirting of the PT.

What is your contractor using for fasteners? Ask him if the quote
includes Eb-Ty clips.

BTW, I love the way the Ipe looks. It weathers well, or you can use
Penofin to help keep the Ipe looking new. It will outlast your deck
structure too.

Good luck,
Rick
  #4   Report Post  
Ed Angell
 
Posts: n/a
Default Deck Decision Help


"Rick Chamberlain" wrote in message
...
snippage

After reasearching on the net, I was leaning towards the Ipe. Some of
the websites make it looks absolutely stunning. After seeing the Ipe
deck, I didn't really think it looked much better than cedar, but if it
really is much longer lasting and much lower maintanance than cedar,
it's still in the picture.

Any advice?

If you live in the Northwest or any area where deck maintenance is a must,
Ipe is the only way to go. The Ipe will outlast the cedar hands down,
especially if you have to pressure wash every year or so.. Rick is right
about the penofin finish, it lightens, but keeps the Ipe looking really
nice. I built benches and a table out of Ipe, used the Penofin for exotic
woods and it looks like a million bucks.

Ed Angell


  #5   Report Post  
Ed G
 
Posts: n/a
Default Deck Decision Help

Fellas (and ladies where applicable) please excuse my ignorance, but why
would you make the structure of your deck with pressure treated wood and
then use Ipe for the rest of the deck? Wouldn't this mean that in a few
years, you'll have to remove the deck to replace the pressure-treated
structure? Sorry if this is a dumb question, but I'd like to know before I
re-do my deck next year. Thanks in advance.

Ed


"Rick Chamberlain" wrote in message
...
snippage

Thanks in advance!
David


snip

David,

I built exactly the same deck. Used 1x4 and 1x6 Ipe for the decking, PT
for the structure, and WRC for the rail. I also had


snip

Good luck,
Rick





  #7   Report Post  
Pat Barber
 
Posts: n/a
Default Deck Decision Help

Since most PT-SYP has a warranty that exceeds 40 years, I wouldn't
worry about who is gonna outlive the deck.... IPE is probably
going to last 50 years, soooo you will have a deck that outlives
the house...

The other reason is that IPE doesn't come in the larger framing
sizes as a general rule. The structure requires much larger
framing members by most regulations.

Ed G wrote:

Fellas (and ladies where applicable) please excuse my ignorance, but why
would you make the structure of your deck with pressure treated wood and
then use Ipe for the rest of the deck? Wouldn't this mean that in a few
years, you'll have to remove the deck to replace the pressure-treated
structure? Sorry if this is a dumb question, but I'd like to know before I
re-do my deck next year. Thanks in advance.

  #8   Report Post  
PC
 
Posts: n/a
Default Deck Decision Help

I have a 2,000 sq ft 5/4 v.g. cedar deck that has been in place for
about 12 years. All posts and railings are also cedar. The only
maintenance is to wash it down and restain (Cabots) every 2 to 3 years.
It still looks good even though it sees a fair amount of salt spray.

Phil

David L wrote:
We are in the process having an approximately 450sq ft bi-level deck in
our Long Island, NY backyard built. There's a bench or 2 and some
flower boxes as well.

I've chosen the contractor and have narrowed the choice down to Trex and
Ipe.

I looked at both a trex and Ipe deck that this contractor built this
morning and was impressed with the quality of each.

He's quoted us $9,000 for high-grade cedar, $9,600 for trex and $10,500
for Ipe. The contractor suggested using PT for the support structure
and high-grade (architectural knotty) cedar for the rails and skirting.
With the trex option, he's quoted trex capping, with the Ipe option he's
quoted cedar capping and Ipe capping for another $150 or so. I'm not
quite sure of the reasoning of using cedar for the rails, capping and
skirting, but I pressume it's to keep the cost down some. I would guess
that it's ok to use cedar for the rails, capping and skitting because
those parts of the deck are less susceptible to normal problems with
wood such as splintering and warping. He said we can treat the parts
that are cedar every other year or so and we'll be fine. The contrast
of the cedar rails with both the trex and Ipe decking looked fine. I
think it was nice to have some "real" wood along with the trex decking.

Does that all make sense with the mix of cedar and trex or Ipe or should
I really pay more for it being all cedar or all Ipe (except the PT
support, obviously)?

I've seen other posts indicate a greater price difference between cedar
and trex. In fact, other contractors we priced out had a 50% higher
price for trex. The contractor we picked is listed as an authorized
contractor on trex.com and I've checked references, so I'm not really
worried about there being a problem with him. I just don't know why his
trex price was so "cheap".

One of our most important critera is low maintanance. I also want
something that will last a long time. I know trex has almost no
maintanance. I've read that Ipe also requires very little maintanance
and should not warp or splinter for 25+ years. I know that if I treat
the Ipe every year or so, it will stay brown and if I don't treat it, it
will turn silver, but maintain it's structural integrity.

After reasearching on the net, I was leaning towards the Ipe. Some of
the websites make it looks absolutely stunning. After seeing the Ipe
deck, I didn't really think it looked much better than cedar, but if it
really is much longer lasting and much lower maintanance than cedar,
it's still in the picture.

Any advice?

Anything I should check with the contractor so that I'm not surprised
about anything?

Thanks in advance!
David


  #9   Report Post  
Todd Stock
 
Posts: n/a
Default Deck Decision Help

Most framing members are vertically oriented and are somewhat sheltered from
direct weathering by the decking and skirting, so treated SYP will last much
longer in a framing application than as decking. In this area (VA/MD), treated
2x SYP decking lasts 15-20 years and 10-15 years on southfacing decks which
really get cooked. Pairing Ipe (durable 40-50 year decking) with SYP framing
(30-40 year life when somewhat protected) is a reasonable match. If you have the
presence of mind to end-seal all cut treated lumber ends, you'll probably get at
least 40 years of life out of the frame.

FYI - Advantage and most other wholesalers carry Ipe in framing sizes, and most
retail vendors sell at least the rail components (4x4, 2x4 etc.) - only problem
is cost and weight - a 2x10x16 is a two man carry - I went with SYP.

Pat Barber wrote:

Since most PT-SYP has a warranty that exceeds 40 years, I wouldn't
worry about who is gonna outlive the deck.... IPE is probably
going to last 50 years, soooo you will have a deck that outlives
the house...

The other reason is that IPE doesn't come in the larger framing
sizes as a general rule. The structure requires much larger
framing members by most regulations.

Ed G wrote:

Fellas (and ladies where applicable) please excuse my ignorance, but why
would you make the structure of your deck with pressure treated wood and
then use Ipe for the rest of the deck? Wouldn't this mean that in a few
years, you'll have to remove the deck to replace the pressure-treated
structure? Sorry if this is a dumb question, but I'd like to know before I
re-do my deck next year. Thanks in advance.


Reply
Thread Tools Search this Thread
Search this Thread:

Advanced Search
Display Modes

Posting Rules

Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off
Trackbacks are On
Pingbacks are On
Refbacks are On


Similar Threads
Thread Thread Starter Forum Replies Last Post
Deck: bearers or joists Rosie UK diy 4 May 28th 04 12:26 PM
Rhino Liner on a mower deck Roy Metalworking 11 December 15th 03 06:24 PM
Book about building your own deck Andy Dingley UK diy 2 August 7th 03 05:29 PM
Deck Construction ? KJR UK diy 3 July 19th 03 11:11 PM
Slightly OT - installing composite deck railing PC Woodworking 0 July 11th 03 01:02 PM


All times are GMT +1. The time now is 01:35 PM.

Powered by vBulletin® Copyright ©2000 - 2024, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Copyright ©2004-2024 DIYbanter.
The comments are property of their posters.
 

About Us

"It's about DIY & home improvement"