Woodworking (rec.woodworking) Discussion forum covering all aspects of working with wood. All levels of expertise are encouraged to particiapte.

Reply
 
LinkBack Thread Tools Search this Thread Display Modes
  #1   Report Post  
Posted to rec.woodworking
charlie b
 
Posts: n/a
Default Loose Tenon vs Mortise & Tenon AND/OR Who Do You Believe?

Loose Tenon vs Mortise & Tenon AND/OR Who Do You Believe?

In the Q&A section of the April 2006 issue of Popular Woodworking, a
reader asked if you could draw bore loose tenons. In his response, the
editor, Christopher Schwarz, states “Part of my problem ... Is that I’m
not a fan of loose tenons. They are a good option for some special
applications, but I really don’t see them as easier than the traditional
joint. Mortising that end grain is no small thing (in my opinion) and
the jiggery to mortise the ends of rails is sometimes complex.”

I guess he’s thinking in terms of mortising with a mortising chisel - it
ain’t
easy to do that without splitting the end grain part, or he’s thinking
of a vertical mortising machine, with square chisel and bit (now how the
hell do I get the end of this this bed rail up under that chisel and
bit?). But if he is referrring to a router jig and plunge router or a
horizontal boring/mortising machine, I’m not sure where the “complex”
comes in. You have to layout the mortise regardless of how they’re
going to be cut and the width of the mortise is pretty much defined by
the closest chisel, chisel/bit set or router bit (actually, end mills
work best) - so that’s a push. That leaves aligning the bit to a layout
line and setting the left and right stops for a jig - neither one being
“complex”.

Now consider making a table - the apron, a pair of stretchers between
the end legs and maybe a stretcher between the two end stretchers.
That’s fourteen mortises and fourteen tenons to cut. It’s the tenon
that are the higher risk operation, whether you do them by hand, on a
router table or with the table saw ( with or without a dado blade ).
It’s not the tenon that’s the problem, it’s the shoulders. Any tear out
or over cut will more than likely be on a visible face (see Murphy’s
Laws). That means either making another part or lowering the shoulders
- on ALL the matched parts. Not a problem with loose tenons. The
“shoulders” can be cut on a miter saw - the best way to insure the ends
are square. And if, for some reason, you cut a tenon long - then all
the rest must also be cut long OR you make another part to replace the
one you blew. By “cut long” I mean the tenon length. With loose tenons
this isn’t even an issue. If you cut the loose tenon too long you just
cut it shorter - or if it’s too short you cut another one - off a strip
of stock you’ve made. AND, with loose tenons, each part’s “visble
length” is the same as its “length” - no adding tenon lengthS (emphasis
on multiples - normally two per tenoned part) to the “visible length”.

Then there’s the Fixing F**K Ups. With loose tenons, you can tweek the
fit by tweeking both halves of the loose tenon, shave the front and
adding a piece of veneer to the back on one side, shave the back and
veneer the front on the other. Granted the joint will be a little
weaker - but not significantly weaker.

Ironically, Mr. Schwarz’s editorial page got into “who do you believe”,
noting that the earliest joinery “how to” book in english, which some
today take as The Bible of Joinery, was written by a printer / type
setter who may, or may not, have every cut a joint in his life. A
subsequent book, written by a Master Joiner, alas, is only available in
French. Who do you believe - the No First Hand Knowledge or the
Experienced Craftsman?

And that gets into another subject - the skills of a good author &
editor vs the skills of a good craftsman author and editor. A good
author, with no hands on experience with a subject, can often describe
the subject better than a person who has plenty of hands on experience
with the subject - but can’t write for spit. The best of both worlds is
the combination of someone who can write well but has no hands on
experience with a person who has plenty of hands on experience but
limited writing skills. The writer can ask questions and fill in
“common knowledge” gaps that the “hands on experienced” person may not
think worth noting. A keen observer will ask the “why did you”
questions that can fill in critical, but often not mentioned because of
the “common knowledge” thing gaps.

Back in The Good Old Days, knowledge and skills were often passed on to
the next generation via apprenticeships. It was in the best interest of
the Master Craftsman to train his apprentice well, initially freeing him
from a great deal of grunt work (shop clean up, running errands, heavy
lifting, stock prep, ...) and over time, increasing the shop’s output -
and profit.

Then there’s Doug Stowe, Mark Adams, Tage Frid and Frank Klausz (ok so
Mr. Klausz does videos not books - but he and Mark Adams are great at
communicating - as was Tage Frid). Though I haven’t seen Charles Self’s
current book, I’m betting he’s a good combination of writing skills and
hands on experience. (Still looking for his bench reference book
though).

Two topics in one post - Loose vs Traditional M&T and/or Who Do You
Believe?

Charlie b

And now I’m going out to finish making a rabbit hutch for the kid on the
corner - appropriate for Easter Sunday yes?
  #2   Report Post  
Posted to rec.woodworking
Charley
 
Posts: n/a
Default Loose Tenon vs Mortise & Tenon AND/OR Who Do You Believe?

From one Charlie to another "Well Done". I think you have covered it all.

--
Charley

"charlie b" wrote in message
...
Loose Tenon vs Mortise & Tenon AND/OR Who Do You Believe?

In the Q&A section of the April 2006 issue of Popular Woodworking, a
reader asked if you could draw bore loose tenons. In his response, the
editor, Christopher Schwarz, states "Part of my problem ... Is that I'm
not a fan of loose tenons. They are a good option for some special
applications, but I really don't see them as easier than the traditional
joint. Mortising that end grain is no small thing (in my opinion) and
the jiggery to mortise the ends of rails is sometimes complex."

I guess he's thinking in terms of mortising with a mortising chisel - it
ain't
easy to do that without splitting the end grain part, or he's thinking
of a vertical mortising machine, with square chisel and bit (now how the
hell do I get the end of this this bed rail up under that chisel and
bit?). But if he is referrring to a router jig and plunge router or a
horizontal boring/mortising machine, I'm not sure where the "complex"
comes in. You have to layout the mortise regardless of how they're
going to be cut and the width of the mortise is pretty much defined by
the closest chisel, chisel/bit set or router bit (actually, end mills
work best) - so that's a push. That leaves aligning the bit to a layout
line and setting the left and right stops for a jig - neither one being
"complex".

Now consider making a table - the apron, a pair of stretchers between
the end legs and maybe a stretcher between the two end stretchers.
That's fourteen mortises and fourteen tenons to cut. It's the tenon
that are the higher risk operation, whether you do them by hand, on a
router table or with the table saw ( with or without a dado blade ).
It's not the tenon that's the problem, it's the shoulders. Any tear out
or over cut will more than likely be on a visible face (see Murphy's
Laws). That means either making another part or lowering the shoulders
- on ALL the matched parts. Not a problem with loose tenons. The
"shoulders" can be cut on a miter saw - the best way to insure the ends
are square. And if, for some reason, you cut a tenon long - then all
the rest must also be cut long OR you make another part to replace the
one you blew. By "cut long" I mean the tenon length. With loose tenons
this isn't even an issue. If you cut the loose tenon too long you just
cut it shorter - or if it's too short you cut another one - off a strip
of stock you've made. AND, with loose tenons, each part's "visble
length" is the same as its "length" - no adding tenon lengthS (emphasis
on multiples - normally two per tenoned part) to the "visible length".

Then there's the Fixing F**K Ups. With loose tenons, you can tweek the
fit by tweeking both halves of the loose tenon, shave the front and
adding a piece of veneer to the back on one side, shave the back and
veneer the front on the other. Granted the joint will be a little
weaker - but not significantly weaker.

Ironically, Mr. Schwarz's editorial page got into "who do you believe",
noting that the earliest joinery "how to" book in english, which some
today take as The Bible of Joinery, was written by a printer / type
setter who may, or may not, have every cut a joint in his life. A
subsequent book, written by a Master Joiner, alas, is only available in
French. Who do you believe - the No First Hand Knowledge or the
Experienced Craftsman?

And that gets into another subject - the skills of a good author &
editor vs the skills of a good craftsman author and editor. A good
author, with no hands on experience with a subject, can often describe
the subject better than a person who has plenty of hands on experience
with the subject - but can't write for spit. The best of both worlds is
the combination of someone who can write well but has no hands on
experience with a person who has plenty of hands on experience but
limited writing skills. The writer can ask questions and fill in
"common knowledge" gaps that the "hands on experienced" person may not
think worth noting. A keen observer will ask the "why did you"
questions that can fill in critical, but often not mentioned because of
the "common knowledge" thing gaps.

Back in The Good Old Days, knowledge and skills were often passed on to
the next generation via apprenticeships. It was in the best interest of
the Master Craftsman to train his apprentice well, initially freeing him
from a great deal of grunt work (shop clean up, running errands, heavy
lifting, stock prep, ...) and over time, increasing the shop's output -
and profit.

Then there's Doug Stowe, Mark Adams, Tage Frid and Frank Klausz (ok so
Mr. Klausz does videos not books - but he and Mark Adams are great at
communicating - as was Tage Frid). Though I haven't seen Charles Self's
current book, I'm betting he's a good combination of writing skills and
hands on experience. (Still looking for his bench reference book
though).

Two topics in one post - Loose vs Traditional M&T and/or Who Do You
Believe?

Charlie b

And now I'm going out to finish making a rabbit hutch for the kid on the
corner - appropriate for Easter Sunday yes?



  #3   Report Post  
Posted to rec.woodworking
Swingman
 
Posts: n/a
Default Loose Tenon vs Mortise & Tenon AND/OR Who Do You Believe?

"charlie b" wrote in message

I guess he's thinking in terms of mortising with a mortising chisel - it
ain't
easy to do that without splitting the end grain part, or he's thinking
of a vertical mortising machine, with square chisel and bit (now how the
hell do I get the end of this this bed rail up under that chisel and
bit?). But if he is referrring to a router jig and plunge router or a
horizontal boring/mortising machine, I'm not sure where the "complex"
comes in. You have to layout the mortise regardless of how they're
going to be cut and the width of the mortise is pretty much defined by
the closest chisel, chisel/bit set or router bit (actually, end mills
work best) - so that's a push. That leaves aligning the bit to a layout
line and setting the left and right stops for a jig - neither one being
"complex".


I haven't seen the article, but just to add a couple of cents ... loose
tenon joinery is often preferred by many on compound angled joints, like
those found in chair components, as a good case can be made that, depending
upon the piece of wood, you can often get a stronger joint with loose tenons
due to grain direction/aberrations on tenons if cut in a more traditional
manner.

--
www.e-woodshop.net
Last update: 12/13/05





Reply
Thread Tools Search this Thread
Search this Thread:

Advanced Search
Display Modes

Posting Rules

Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off
Trackbacks are On
Pingbacks are On
Refbacks are On


Similar Threads
Thread Thread Starter Forum Replies Last Post
Loose tenon materials John Eppley Woodworking 5 March 7th 06 02:44 AM
Angled mortise and tenon joints Mark Nudelman Woodworking 3 March 18th 05 02:52 AM
How to fix old chair with worn mortise and tenon joints? Scott Duncan Woodworking 5 May 9th 04 03:31 PM
mortise and tenon dimension guidelines Chris Carruth Woodworking 2 April 27th 04 12:00 AM
Mortise & Tenon help Mike W. Woodworking 18 September 20th 03 02:18 PM


All times are GMT +1. The time now is 12:16 AM.

Powered by vBulletin® Copyright ©2000 - 2024, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Copyright ©2004-2024 DIYbanter.
The comments are property of their posters.
 

About Us

"It's about DIY & home improvement"