DIYbanter

DIYbanter (https://www.diybanter.com/)
-   Woodturning (https://www.diybanter.com/woodturning/)
-   -   Axminster starter chisel set (https://www.diybanter.com/woodturning/140488-axminster-starter-chisel-set.html)

Andy Dingley January 16th 06 02:08 PM

Axminster starter chisel set
 
http://www.axminster.co.uk/recno/1/p...-Set-21761.htm

"What chisels to get" is a perennial question and the usual answer is to
avoid sets because they're a bad choice. Here's a set that's a good
selection, good quality, and a decent price (for the UK) - £62.

3/4" Roughing gouge
3/8" Bowl gouge
3/8" Spindle gouge
1" Oval skew
Diamond parter
3/4" Round nose scraper

Handles are nicely shaped ash and the tools are a good length. Gouge
grinds are less than perfect (competent, but simple) and you'll probably
benefit from re-shaping the wings to personal taste.

The "bowl" gouge is a particularly nice hefty tool, some inches longer
than the spindle gouge. Axminster also sell these as separate chisels
and IMHO it's worth buying a second one of them. Sharpen one as a bowl
gouge, the other as a finger-ground spindle gouge and you have an
excellent large spindle for turning chairlegs and similar sized pieces.

The downside of some cheap sets is too many useless scrapers. This one
just gives you the one, that's OK for bowl work. For box hollowing
though you might find a square-ended scraper useful too.

The skew is something of a compromise. It's a fine tool, but a 1" oval
isn't the most commonly useful size. Perhaps this would be better as a
3/4" ? The oval shaping is nicely done and makes it much more flexible
for rolling large beads - however 1" is big and there just aren't that
many things you really need it for. For big cylinders a flat 1" skew is
a bit more stable to use. For most beads a 3/4" or 1/2" is easier to
handle.

Geoff Beale January 16th 06 05:23 PM

Axminster starter chisel set
 
Andy Dingley wrote:


http://www.axminster.co.uk/recno/1/p...-Set-21761.htm

"What chisels to get" is a perennial question and the usual answer is
to
avoid sets because they're a bad choice. Here's a set that's a good
selection, good quality, and a decent price (for the UK) - £62.

3/4" Roughing gouge
3/8" Bowl gouge
3/8" Spindle gouge
1" Oval skew
Diamond parter
3/4" Round nose scraper



There may be some small differences, but this set looks remarkably like
an unbranded set I bought on eBay for about £20 when I first started
turning a couple of years ago. They may have been cheap and cheerful
but they served me well as a starter set. Why pay more until you know
whether turning is for you?

--
Geoff Beale
Extract digit to email

George January 17th 06 03:36 PM

Axminster starter chisel set
 

"Moro Grubb of Little Delving" wrote in
message news:W_7zf.254090$2k.140984@pd7tw1no...

The only questionable one was the spindle
gouge which has a wide, very shallow flute, and this an awkward profile in
use...


Not at all. Absolutely useful if you become familiar with it. It will peel
effortlessly and with great safety on spindles and bowls. My favorite
"finisher" gouge. Closest you can get to an inside skew.

http://photobucket.com/albums/d160/G...t=639fb765.jpg
In use for interrupted edges.

http://photobucket.com/albums/d160/G...t=7c6d6541.jpg

The surface it leaves. Doesn't even pull spalted edges much.




All times are GMT +1. The time now is 12:47 AM.

Powered by vBulletin® Copyright ©2000 - 2024, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Copyright ©2004 - 2014 DIYbanter