Drawer runner choice for 'normally open' use?
 

Hi All
I have an office unit with a slide-out 'keyboard' shelf. This is just a piece of 18mm MDF with drawer runners on the side. The other part of the drawer runner is mounted to metal plates which 'hang' down from the body of the unit. Nothing fancy, and pretty cheap.

The runners have become pretty worn over the years and sliding the shelf in and out is now pretty 'graunchy'. I am thinking of replacing the runners. But in this application the forces are bit different to most drawer runner uses:

- most force is applied to the sliding shelf part when it is extended
- there is a larger degree of lateral 'tilt' force on the shelf than on most drawer situations

Any thoughts about the best kind of runners to fit as a replacement here?

Thanks a lot

Jon N

Drawer runner choice for 'normally open' use?
 

jkn wrote:
The runners have become pretty worn over the years and sliding the shelf in and out is now pretty 'graunchy'. I am thinking of replacing the runners. But in this application the forces are bit different to most drawer runner uses:

- most force is applied to the sliding shelf part when it is extended
- there is a larger degree of lateral 'tilt' force on the shelf than on most drawer situations

Any thoughts about the best kind of runners to fit as a replacement here?

You can get industrial slides - Accuride is a popular make:
https://uk.farnell.com/c/enclosures-...ssories/slides

There's all kinds of variations - removable/non removable, different depths
of pull-out, self-closing, locking in the out position, etc.

They aren't necessarily cheap but they're designed for things like having a
50kg server hang 1m out of a rack while someone tinkers with it, and then
push it back in. They definitely don't sag when that happens.

The only thing they aren't always good for is side-to-side forces - they're
designed to be attached to two rigid objects, but there can be side-to-side
wobble when the server/etc is fully pulled out. It's not a problem when
say 90% pulled out.

Theo

Drawer runner choice for 'normally open' use?
 

Theo wrote:
jkn wrote:
The runners have become pretty worn over the years and sliding the shelf
in and out is now pretty 'graunchy'. I am thinking of replacing the runners.
But in this application the forces are bit different to most drawer runner
uses:

- most force is applied to the sliding shelf part when it is extended
- there is a larger degree of lateral 'tilt' force on the shelf than on most drawer situations

Any thoughts about the best kind of runners to fit as a replacement here?

You can get industrial slides - Accuride is a popular make:
https://uk.farnell.com/c/enclosures-...ssories/slides

There's all kinds of variations - removable/non removable, different depths
of pull-out, self-closing, locking in the out position, etc.

They aren't necessarily cheap but they're designed for things like having a
50kg server hang 1m out of a rack while someone tinkers with it, and then
push it back in. They definitely don't sag when that happens.

The standard kitchen roller bearing runners from such as Blum and
Hettich can now be found with 30kg and 50kg ratings, they're not all
that expensive either, typically £5 to £10 per pair.

--
Chris Green
·

Drawer runner choice for 'normally open' use?
 

I was going to say, many moons ago when VCRs were big and heavy beasts there
were lots of cabinets with pull out shelves with runners that were really
solid and durable, and these were flatpack furniture. looking back they used
a lot of nylon rollers in the main, in a metal pressed steel section. No
obvious problem when mechanical keys were pressed or top loading covers
shut either.
Brian

--

This newsgroup posting comes to you directly from...
The Sofa of Brian Gaff...

Blind user, so no pictures please
Note this Signature is meaningless.!
"Chris Green" wrote in message
...
Theo wrote:
jkn wrote:
The runners have become pretty worn over the years and sliding the
shelf
in and out is now pretty 'graunchy'. I am thinking of replacing the
runners.
But in this application the forces are bit different to most drawer
runner
uses:

- most force is applied to the sliding shelf part when it is extended
- there is a larger degree of lateral 'tilt' force on the shelf than on
most drawer situations

Any thoughts about the best kind of runners to fit as a replacement
here?

You can get industrial slides - Accuride is a popular make:
https://uk.farnell.com/c/enclosures-...ssories/slides

There's all kinds of variations - removable/non removable, different
depths
of pull-out, self-closing, locking in the out position, etc.

They aren't necessarily cheap but they're designed for things like having
a
50kg server hang 1m out of a rack while someone tinkers with it, and then
push it back in. They definitely don't sag when that happens.

The standard kitchen roller bearing runners from such as Blum and
Hettich can now be found with 30kg and 50kg ratings, they're not all
that expensive either, typically £5 to £10 per pair.

--
Chris Green
·

Drawer runner choice for 'normally open' use?
 

In article ,
jkn wrote:
Hi All I have an office unit with a slide-out 'keyboard' shelf. This is
just a piece of 18mm MDF with drawer runners on the side. The other
part of the drawer runner is mounted to metal plates which 'hang'
down from the body of the unit. Nothing fancy, and pretty cheap.

The runners have become pretty worn over the years and sliding the shelf
in and out is now pretty 'graunchy'. I am thinking of replacing the
runners. But in this application the forces are bit different to most
drawer runner uses:

- most force is applied to the sliding shelf part when it is extended -
there is a larger degree of lateral 'tilt' force on the shelf than on
most drawer situations

Any thoughts about the best kind of runners to fit as a replacement here?

Thanks a lot

A keyboard shelf hardly needs to be engineered by Harland & Woolf.

You'll find roller bearing ones to do the job in most sheds.

--
*Work is for people who don't know how to fish.

Dave Plowman London SW
To e-mail, change noise into sound.

Drawer runner choice for 'normally open' use?
 

On Wednesday, 23 December 2020 at 18:49:25 UTC, jkn wrote:
Hi All
I have an office unit with a slide-out 'keyboard' shelf. This is just a piece of 18mm MDF with drawer runners on the side. The other part of the drawer runner is mounted to metal plates which 'hang' down from the body of the unit. Nothing fancy, and pretty cheap.

The runners have become pretty worn over the years and sliding the shelf in and out is now pretty 'graunchy'. I am thinking of replacing the runners.. But in this application the forces are bit different to most drawer runner uses:

- most force is applied to the sliding shelf part when it is extended
- there is a larger degree of lateral 'tilt' force on the shelf than on most drawer situations

Any thoughts about the best kind of runners to fit as a replacement here?

Thanks a lot

Jon N

There are 3 main types

1. Plastic bar. Not at all robust. Very cheap.

2. Metal strips with a wheel on, mount to underside. Not robust.

3. 2 Metal bars with ball bearings between. They can & do fail, but are at least a good bit more robust than the other types. As someone advised, go for high load rated ones, anything less doesn't last well long term. They normally run in slots, but I expect they could be mounted under if one had to..


NT