Water Hammer from Toilet
 

I have read many posts about this problem and the answer is usually
"replace your ball valve washer". I have had a look in my toilet and
I do not exactly which part is the ball valve, although I do know
which part of the mechanism causes the water hammer. Also the parts
that causes the water hammer are made from plastic and do not have an
existing washer in the assembly.

I get water hammer through my pipes just as the cistern is at the end
of its refill. The long arm attached to the float has what looks like
a plastic screw mounted on it at the opposite end to the float. As
the float rises this screw pushes a "piston" into a "cylinder" (a
valve??) which eventually stops water flowing into the tank. If I
flush my toilet and push the piston with light pressure I can
reproduce the water hammer effect. The fact that the flowrate into
the tank slows as the piston is pushed in makes the water hammer noise
last longer.

The piston and cylinder (valve?) are made from a white plastic. The
piston fits loosely but I cannot pull it out of the cylinder. Does
the washer go into the cylinder before the piston, preventing the
piston from vibrating as it is slowly closed? B&Q have a ball valve
diaphragm washer for
98pence(http://www.diy.com/bq/category/categ...ml?CATID=86735. Is
this what I need?

Water Hammer from Toilet
 

On 2 Dec 2003 07:59:48 -0800, (anon) wrote:

I have read many posts about this problem and the answer is usually
"replace your ball valve washer". I have had a look in my toilet and
I do not exactly which part is the ball valve, although I do know
which part of the mechanism causes the water hammer. Also the parts
that causes the water hammer are made from plastic and do not have an
existing washer in the assembly.

I get water hammer through my pipes just as the cistern is at the end
of its refill. The long arm attached to the float has what looks like
a plastic screw mounted on it at the opposite end to the float. As
the float rises this screw pushes a "piston" into a "cylinder" (a
valve??) which eventually stops water flowing into the tank. If I
flush my toilet and push the piston with light pressure I can
reproduce the water hammer effect. The fact that the flowrate into
the tank slows as the piston is pushed in makes the water hammer noise
last longer.

The piston and cylinder (valve?) are made from a white plastic. The
piston fits loosely but I cannot pull it out of the cylinder. Does
the washer go into the cylinder before the piston, preventing the
piston from vibrating as it is slowly closed? B&Q have a ball valve
diaphragm washer for
98pence(http://www.diy.com/bq/category/categ...ml?CATID=86735. Is
this what I need?

You have identified the ball valve correctly.

Replacing the washer may help but generally the problem is due to
pressure/flow being too high.. You could try that first, and then
if not, fit some form of flow restrictor like a service valve in the
pipe. A more drastic solution is to replace the ball valve with a
Fluidmaster or Torbeck type. These come with a flow restrictor which
fits in the valve itself.





..andy

To email, substitute .nospam with .gl

Water Hammer from Toilet
 

"Andy Hall" wrote in message
...
On 2 Dec 2003 07:59:48 -0800, (anon) wrote:

I have read many posts about this problem and the answer is usually
"replace your ball valve washer". I have had a look in my toilet and
I do not exactly which part is the ball valve, although I do know
which part of the mechanism causes the water hammer. Also the parts
that causes the water hammer are made from plastic and do not have an
existing washer in the assembly.

I get water hammer through my pipes just as the cistern is at the end
of its refill. The long arm attached to the float has what looks like
a plastic screw mounted on it at the opposite end to the float. As
the float rises this screw pushes a "piston" into a "cylinder" (a
valve??) which eventually stops water flowing into the tank. If I
flush my toilet and push the piston with light pressure I can
reproduce the water hammer effect. The fact that the flowrate into
the tank slows as the piston is pushed in makes the water hammer noise
last longer.

The piston and cylinder (valve?) are made from a white plastic. The
piston fits loosely but I cannot pull it out of the cylinder. Does
the washer go into the cylinder before the piston, preventing the
piston from vibrating as it is slowly closed? B&Q have a ball valve
diaphragm washer for
98pence(http://www.diy.com/bq/category/categ...ml?CATID=86735. Is
this what I need?

You have identified the ball valve correctly.

Replacing the washer may help but generally the problem is due to
pressure/flow being too high.. You could try that first, and then
if not, fit some form of flow restrictor like a service valve in the
pipe. A more drastic solution is to replace the ball valve with a
Fluidmaster or Torbeck type. These come with a flow restrictor which
fits in the valve itself.

.andy



A torbeck valve has the added advantage that it operates over a very small
change in level - maintaining full flow until *just* before it shuts off.
This would be a direct replacement for your existing ball valve, and very
easy to fit - but the bit inside the cistern is much smaller than a
conventional ball valve.

Roger

Water Hammer from Toilet
 

The trouble with a Fluidmaster is that it cuts off the water very suddenly.
This could make water hammer even worse.
Isn't one cause of water hammer due to un-clipped pipes?

I fitted a Fluidmaster with some difficulty. It is a bottom fill cistern and
the valve needed to be at the same end as the handle / siphon which limited
space. I also had difficulty adjusting the height of the water without the
valve body preventing the lid from fitting properly.

--


Regards

John

I have read many posts about this problem and the answer is usually
"replace your ball valve washer". I have had a look in my toilet and
I do not exactly which part is the ball valve, although I do know
which part of the mechanism causes the water hammer. Also the parts
that causes the water hammer are made from plastic and do not have an
existing washer in the assembly.

I get water hammer through my pipes just as the cistern is at the end
of its refill. The long arm attached to the float has what looks like
a plastic screw mounted on it at the opposite end to the float. As
the float rises this screw pushes a "piston" into a "cylinder" (a
valve??) which eventually stops water flowing into the tank. If I
flush my toilet and push the piston with light pressure I can
reproduce the water hammer effect. The fact that the flowrate into
the tank slows as the piston is pushed in makes the water hammer noise
last longer.

The piston and cylinder (valve?) are made from a white plastic. The
piston fits loosely but I cannot pull it out of the cylinder. Does
the washer go into the cylinder before the piston, preventing the
piston from vibrating as it is slowly closed? B&Q have a ball valve
diaphragm washer for
98pence(http://www.diy.com/bq/category/categ...ml?CATID=86735. Is
this what I need?

You have identified the ball valve correctly.

Replacing the washer may help but generally the problem is due to
pressure/flow being too high.. You could try that first, and then
if not, fit some form of flow restrictor like a service valve in the
pipe. A more drastic solution is to replace the ball valve with a
Fluidmaster or Torbeck type. These come with a flow restrictor which
fits in the valve itself.

.andy



A torbeck valve has the added advantage that it operates over a very small
change in level - maintaining full flow until *just* before it shuts off.
This would be a direct replacement for your existing ball valve, and very
easy to fit - but the bit inside the cistern is much smaller than a
conventional ball valve.

Roger




---
All of my outgoing mail is certified Virus Free.
Checked by AVG anti-virus system (http://www.grisoft.com).
Version: 6.0.545 / Virus Database: 339 - Release Date: 27/11/2003

Water Hammer from Toilet
 

Water Hammer from Toilet
 

Water Hammer from Toilet
 

"anon" wrote in message
om...
(Zymurgy) wrote in message
. com...
(anon) wrote
I have read many posts about this problem and the answer
snipped


Thanks for all the replies. Everything moves smoothly until the water
level is nearly full and the ball valve starts to close. The piston
part vibrates inside the cylinder part which is what causes the water
hammer. This loud humming noise goes on for about 20 seconds until
the valve finally closes. I expect that the vibrations of the valve
cause the flow to be started and stopped repeatedly at high frequency,
causing the hum.

There doesn't appear to be a washer inside the assembly, so maybe the
valve has become loose allowing it to vibrate. If I push the valve
with my finger, partially closing it I can cause the humming noise.

Have a look on the pipe feeding the cistern to see if there is a service
valve. It looks very like a straight plumbing connection, but it has a
small slot on a circular shaped piece in the middle.

This service valve will allow you turn down the water flow which reaches the
cistern, and will also reduce some of the pressure being placed on the float
valve inside.

Flush the loo and then put a screwdriver in the slot on the service valve.
When the hammering begins, turn the screwdriver slowly until it stops.
Flush the loo again and make sure the water is still flowing fast enough to
fill the cistern quickly, but not under to much pressure that it causes the
hammering.

Water Hammer from Toilet
 

"BigWallop" wrote in message
...

"anon" wrote in message
om...
(Zymurgy) wrote in message
. com...
(anon) wrote
I have read many posts about this problem and the answer
snipped


Thanks for all the replies. Everything moves smoothly until the water
level is nearly full and the ball valve starts to close. The piston
part vibrates inside the cylinder part which is what causes the water
hammer. This loud humming noise goes on for about 20 seconds until
the valve finally closes. I expect that the vibrations of the valve
cause the flow to be started and stopped repeatedly at high frequency,
causing the hum.

There doesn't appear to be a washer inside the assembly, so maybe the
valve has become loose allowing it to vibrate. If I push the valve
with my finger, partially closing it I can cause the humming noise.

Have a look on the pipe feeding the cistern to see if there is a service
valve. It looks very like a straight plumbing connection, but it has a
small slot on a circular shaped piece in the middle.

This service valve will allow you turn down the water flow which reaches
the
cistern, and will also reduce some of the pressure being placed on the
float
valve inside.

Flush the loo and then put a screwdriver in the slot on the service valve.
When the hammering begins, turn the screwdriver slowly until it stops.

SORRY !!! I mean till the hammering stops, not the screwdriver.


Flush the loo again and make sure the water is still flowing fast enough
to
fill the cistern quickly, but not under to much pressure that it causes
the
hammering.