DIYbanter

DIYbanter (https://www.diybanter.com/)
-   UK diy (https://www.diybanter.com/uk-diy/)
-   -   GU10 bulb remover (https://www.diybanter.com/uk-diy/347793-gu10-bulb-remover.html)

fred[_8_] October 16th 12 11:44 AM

GU10 bulb remover
 
We have about 10 lights using these GU10 bulbs. They have to be twisted to remove. Problem is the only ones we can find are flush with the surface of the ceiling fitting. Original GE bulbs had small raised studs on the circumference of the glass surface. These aided the removal. Latest version has completely flat surface. Nothing to grip to help in twisting the bulb in its holder. Solution offered (Solution ? Dont make me laugh) is a suction cup, such as is found in a kiddies bow and arrow set, which is utterly useless. Now removing the bulb is a major operation involving pulling the whole fitting out of the ceiling.

Question 1 . Does anyone know where I could source the original type bulbs. I'e tried all the usual suspects, both local and ebay.

Question 2 Has anyone found a satisfactory way of removing these bulbs ? I'm getting too too old to be swaying about on a step ladder.

Grimly Curmudgeon[_3_] October 16th 12 11:55 AM

GU10 bulb remover
 
On Tue, 16 Oct 2012 03:44:34 -0700 (PDT), fred
wrote:

Question 2 Has anyone found a satisfactory way of removing these bulbs ?


Rubber sink plug.

Adam Aglionby October 16th 12 12:08 PM

GU10 bulb remover
 
On Oct 16, 11:44*am, fred wrote:
We have about 10 lights using these GU10 bulbs. They have to be twisted to remove. Problem is the only ones we can find are flush with the surface of the ceiling fitting. Original GE bulbs had small raised studs on the circumference of the glass surface. These aided the removal. Latest version has completely flat surface. Nothing to grip to help in twisting the bulb in its holder. Solution offered (Solution ? Dont make me laugh) is a suction cup, such as is found in a kiddies bow and arrow set, which is utterly useless. Now removing the bulb is a major operation involving pulling the whole fitting out of the ceiling.

Question 1 . Does anyone know where I could source the original type bulbs. I'e tried all the usual suspects, both local and ebay.

Question 2 Has anyone found a satisfactory way of removing these bulbs ? I'm getting too too old to be swaying about on a step ladder.


Remove fitting, replace with low voltage fitting , transformer and
lamp, fit and forget ;-)

Cheers
Adam

GB October 16th 12 12:09 PM

GU10 bulb remover
 
On 16/10/2012 11:44, fred wrote:
We have about 10 lights using these GU10 bulbs. They have to be twisted to remove. Problem is the only ones we can find are flush with the surface of the ceiling fitting. Original GE bulbs had small raised studs on the circumference of the glass surface. These aided the removal. Latest version has completely flat surface. Nothing to grip to help in twisting the bulb in its holder. Solution offered (Solution ? Dont make me laugh) is a suction cup, such as is found in a kiddies bow and arrow set, which is utterly useless. Now removing the bulb is a major operation involving pulling the whole fitting out of the ceiling.

Question 1 . Does anyone know where I could source the original type bulbs. I'e tried all the usual suspects, both local and ebay.

Question 2 Has anyone found a satisfactory way of removing these bulbs ? I'm getting too too old to be swaying about on a step ladder.

Rubber washing up gloves increase the friction substantially.

Mike Tomlinson October 16th 12 12:10 PM

GU10 bulb remover
 
In article , fred
writes

Question 2 Has anyone found a satisfactory way of removing these bulbs ?


Marigold gloves.

--
(\_/)
(='.'=)
(")_(")

fred[_8_] October 16th 12 12:21 PM

GU10 bulb remover
 
On Tuesday, October 16, 2012 12:10:40 PM UTC+1, Mike Tomlinson wrote:
In article , fred

writes



Question 2 Has anyone found a satisfactory way of removing these bulbs ?




Marigold gloves.



--

(\_/)

(='.'=)

(")_(")


Rubber gloves sound good. Will give them a try. Who designs these things

Adrian Brentnall[_2_] October 16th 12 01:36 PM

GU10 bulb remover
 
On 16/10/2012 12:36, Malcolm G wrote:
On 16/10/2012 11:44, fred wrote:
We have about 10 lights using these GU10 bulbs. They have to be twisted to remove. Problem is the only ones we can find are flush with the surface of the ceiling fitting. Original GE bulbs had small raised studs on the circumference of the glass surface. These aided the removal. Latest version has completely flat surface. Nothing to grip to help in twisting the bulb in its holder. Solution offered (Solution ? Dont make me laugh) is a suction cup, such as is found in a kiddies bow and arrow set, which is utterly useless. Now removing the bulb is a major operation involving pulling the whole fitting out of the ceiling.


I can well imagine the right suction cup working - given that we use
them here from time to time to lift floor panels which are not exactly
light weight.

Amazon sell this one specifically for GU10 removal
http://www.amazon.co.uk/Wolfcraft-54.../dp/B0027J282A
and there seem to be lots of other ones out there.

That's the same one that CPC do - it works very well.

It's not clear from the instructions online, but the green handle cranks
over to 90-degrees. You then offer it up to the front surface of the
bulb, and move the handle into the vertical position, which creates the
suction.

Then un-bayonet (!) the bulb, using the handle.
To insert a new bulb - same process in reverse.

As I say - works well...

Adrian

[email protected] October 16th 12 01:58 PM

GU10 bulb remover
 
在 2012年10月16日星期二UTC+8下午6时44分34 ,fred写道:
We have about 10 lights using these GU10 bulbs. They have to be twisted to remove. Problem is the only ones we can find are flush with the surface of the ceiling fitting. Original GE bulbs had small raised studs on the circumference of the glass surface. These aided the removal. Latest version has completely flat surface. Nothing to grip to help in twisting the bulb in its holder. Solution offered (Solution ? Dont make me laugh) is a suction cup, such as is found in a kiddies bow and arrow set, which is utterly useless. Now removing the bulb is a major operation involving pulling the whole fitting out of the ceiling.



Question 1 . Does anyone know where I could source the original type bulbs. I'e tried all the usual suspects, both local and ebay.


http://www.newuggaustraliasale.co.uk/


[email protected] October 16th 12 02:05 PM

GU10 bulb remover
 
在 2012年10月16日星期二UTC+8下午6时44分34 ,fred写道:
We have about 10 lights using these GU10 bulbs. They have to be twisted to remove. Problem is the only ones we can find are flush with the surface of the ceiling fitting. Original GE bulbs had small raised studs on the circumference of the glass surface. These aided the removal. Latest version has completely flat surface. Nothing to grip to help in twisting the bulb in its holder. Solution offered (Solution ? Dont make me laugh) is a suction cup, such as is found in a kiddies bow and arrow set, which is utterly useless. Now removing the bulb is a major operation involving pulling the whole fitting out of the ceiling.



Question 1 . Does anyone know where I could source the original type bulbs. I'e tried all the usual suspects, both local and ebay.



Question 2 Has anyone found a satisfactory way of removing these bulbs ? I'm getting too too old to be swaying about on a step ladder.

http://www.newuggaustraliasale.co.uk/

The Medway Handyman October 16th 12 03:56 PM

GU10 bulb remover
 
On 16/10/2012 11:44, fred wrote:
We have about 10 lights using these GU10 bulbs. They have to be twisted to remove. Problem is the only ones we can find are flush with the surface of the ceiling fitting. Original GE bulbs had small raised studs on the circumference of the glass surface. These aided the removal. Latest version has completely flat surface. Nothing to grip to help in twisting the bulb in its holder. Solution offered (Solution ? Dont make me laugh) is a suction cup, such as is found in a kiddies bow and arrow set, which is utterly useless. Now removing the bulb is a major operation involving pulling the whole fitting out of the ceiling.

Question 1 . Does anyone know where I could source the original type bulbs. I'e tried all the usual suspects, both local and ebay.

Question 2 Has anyone found a satisfactory way of removing these bulbs ? I'm getting too too old to be swaying about on a step ladder.

These work and are cheap as chips
http://www.tlc-direct.co.uk/Products/GURS.html

--
Dave - The Medway Handyman www.medwayhandyman.co.uk

Roger Mills[_2_] October 16th 12 05:41 PM

GU10 bulb remover
 
On 16/10/2012 15:56, The Medway Handyman wrote:
On 16/10/2012 11:44, fred wrote:
We have about 10 lights using these GU10 bulbs. They have to be
twisted to remove. Problem is the only ones we can find are flush with
the surface of the ceiling fitting. Original GE bulbs had small raised
studs on the circumference of the glass surface. These aided the
removal. Latest version has completely flat surface. Nothing to grip
to help in twisting the bulb in its holder. Solution offered (Solution
? Dont make me laugh) is a suction cup, such as is found in a kiddies
bow and arrow set, which is utterly useless. Now removing the bulb is
a major operation involving pulling the whole fitting out of the ceiling.

Question 1 . Does anyone know where I could source the original type
bulbs. I'e tried all the usual suspects, both local and ebay.

Question 2 Has anyone found a satisfactory way of removing these bulbs
? I'm getting too too old to be swaying about on a step ladder.

These work and are cheap as chips
http://www.tlc-direct.co.uk/Products/GURS.html


I've got a similar one which came with a 4-lamp bar bought from Argos.
It *does* work - most of the time - but it feels as if the handle bit
will twist off the sucker before I've generated enough torque to rotate
the bulb. There was one occasion when the front glass came off, and left
the rest of the bulb in situ!

The one from Amazon - suggested by someone else - looks like a better bet.

Oh, and don't make the same mistake as I did when I changed a bulb with
the power on. The new bulb got very hot pretty damn quick, and nigh-on
melted the sucker before I could remove it!
--
Cheers,
Roger
____________
Please reply to Newsgroup. Whilst email address is valid, it is seldom
checked.

DerbyBorn[_3_] October 16th 12 06:09 PM

GU10 bulb remover
 
any thoughts on applying a little smear of something on the pins of a new
bulb (Copperslip??)


ARW October 16th 12 06:20 PM

GU10 bulb remover
 
fred wrote:
We have about 10 lights using these GU10 bulbs. They have to be
twisted to remove. Problem is the only ones we can find are flush
with the surface of the ceiling fitting. Original GE bulbs had small
raised studs on the circumference of the glass surface. These aided
the removal. Latest version has completely flat surface. Nothing to
grip to help in twisting the bulb in its holder. Solution offered
(Solution ? Dont make me laugh) is a suction cup, such as is found in
a kiddies bow and arrow set, which is utterly useless. Now removing
the bulb is a major operation involving pulling the whole fitting out
of the ceiling.

Question 1 . Does anyone know where I could source the original type
bulbs. I'e tried all the usual suspects, both local and ebay.

Question 2 Has anyone found a satisfactory way of removing these
bulbs ? I'm getting too too old to be swaying about on a step ladder.


As long as the sucker is wet when applied to the lamp then it will work (ie
gob on the sucker when you get to the top of the step ladder)

Having swapped/installed many thousands of them I know it works, although I
usually just use my fingers and just let friction do the work.

--
Adam



ARW October 16th 12 06:20 PM

GU10 bulb remover
 
fred wrote:
We have about 10 lights using these GU10 bulbs. They have to be
twisted to remove. Problem is the only ones we can find are flush
with the surface of the ceiling fitting. Original GE bulbs had small
raised studs on the circumference of the glass surface. These aided
the removal. Latest version has completely flat surface. Nothing to
grip to help in twisting the bulb in its holder. Solution offered
(Solution ? Dont make me laugh) is a suction cup, such as is found in
a kiddies bow and arrow set, which is utterly useless. Now removing
the bulb is a major operation involving pulling the whole fitting out
of the ceiling.

Question 1 . Does anyone know where I could source the original type
bulbs. I'e tried all the usual suspects, both local and ebay.

Question 2 Has anyone found a satisfactory way of removing these
bulbs ? I'm getting too too old to be swaying about on a step ladder.


As long as the sucker is wet when applied to the lamp then it will work (ie
gob on the sucker when you get to the top of the step ladder)

Having swapped/installed many thousands of them I know it works, although I
usually just use my fingers and just let friction do the work.

--
Adam



The Natural Philosopher[_2_] October 16th 12 06:37 PM

GU10 bulb remover
 
ARW wrote:
fred wrote:
We have about 10 lights using these GU10 bulbs. They have to be
twisted to remove. Problem is the only ones we can find are flush
with the surface of the ceiling fitting. Original GE bulbs had small
raised studs on the circumference of the glass surface. These aided
the removal. Latest version has completely flat surface. Nothing to
grip to help in twisting the bulb in its holder. Solution offered
(Solution ? Dont make me laugh) is a suction cup, such as is found in
a kiddies bow and arrow set, which is utterly useless. Now removing
the bulb is a major operation involving pulling the whole fitting out
of the ceiling.

Question 1 . Does anyone know where I could source the original type
bulbs. I'e tried all the usual suspects, both local and ebay.

Question 2 Has anyone found a satisfactory way of removing these
bulbs ? I'm getting too too old to be swaying about on a step ladder.


As long as the sucker is wet when applied to the lamp then it will work (ie
gob on the sucker when you get to the top of the step ladder)

Having swapped/installed many thousands of them I know it works, although I
usually just use my fingers and just let friction do the work.

Considerr using e.g hot glue to glue on a handle. It ruins the bulb..but
then its already ruined..

Like the days when we used to weld things onto stuck nuts to get them
undone when they were well rounded off..



--
Ineptocracy

(in-ep-toc-ra-cy) a system of government where the least capable to
lead are elected by the least capable of producing, and where the
members of society least likely to sustain themselves or succeed, are
rewarded with goods and services paid for by the confiscated wealth of a
diminishing number of producers.

Mark[_30_] October 17th 12 10:15 AM

GU10 bulb remover
 
On Tue, 16 Oct 2012 18:37:22 +0100, The Natural Philosopher
wrote:

ARW wrote:
fred wrote:
We have about 10 lights using these GU10 bulbs. They have to be
twisted to remove. Problem is the only ones we can find are flush
with the surface of the ceiling fitting. Original GE bulbs had small
raised studs on the circumference of the glass surface. These aided
the removal. Latest version has completely flat surface. Nothing to
grip to help in twisting the bulb in its holder. Solution offered
(Solution ? Dont make me laugh) is a suction cup, such as is found in
a kiddies bow and arrow set, which is utterly useless. Now removing
the bulb is a major operation involving pulling the whole fitting out
of the ceiling.

Question 1 . Does anyone know where I could source the original type
bulbs. I'e tried all the usual suspects, both local and ebay.

Question 2 Has anyone found a satisfactory way of removing these
bulbs ? I'm getting too too old to be swaying about on a step ladder.


As long as the sucker is wet when applied to the lamp then it will work (ie
gob on the sucker when you get to the top of the step ladder)

Having swapped/installed many thousands of them I know it works, although I
usually just use my fingers and just let friction do the work.

Considerr using e.g hot glue to glue on a handle. It ruins the bulb..but
then its already ruined..

Like the days when we used to weld things onto stuck nuts to get them
undone when they were well rounded off..


I don't have too much trouble removing them with just fingers. It's
getting a new one in that takes the time.
--
(\__/) M.
(='.'=) If a man stands in a forest and no woman is around
(")_(") is he still wrong?


fred[_8_] October 17th 12 10:20 AM

GU10 bulb remover
 
On Tuesday, October 16, 2012 3:56:20 PM UTC+1, The Medway Handyman wrote:
On 16/10/2012 11:44, fred wrote:

We have about 10 lights using these GU10 bulbs. They have to be twisted to remove. Problem is the only ones we can find are flush with the surface of the ceiling fitting. Original GE bulbs had small raised studs on the circumference of the glass surface. These aided the removal. Latest version has completely flat surface. Nothing to grip to help in twisting the bulb in its holder. Solution offered (Solution ? Dont make me laugh) is a suction cup, such as is found in a kiddies bow and arrow set, which is utterly useless. Now removing the bulb is a major operation involving pulling the whole fitting out of the ceiling.




Question 1 . Does anyone know where I could source the original type bulbs. I'e tried all the usual suspects, both local and ebay.




Question 2 Has anyone found a satisfactory way of removing these bulbs ? I'm getting too too old to be swaying about on a step ladder.




These work and are cheap as chips

http://www.tlc-direct.co.uk/Products/GURS.html



--

Dave - The Medway Handyman www.medwayhandyman.co.uk


No. We have one of those and it was useless. Not enough resistance to the twisting of the stem.

fred[_8_] October 17th 12 10:24 AM

GU10 bulb remover
 
On Tuesday, October 16, 2012 12:36:27 PM UTC+1, Malcolm G wrote:
On 16/10/2012 11:44, fred wrote:

We have about 10 lights using these GU10 bulbs. They have to be twisted to remove. Problem is the only ones we can find are flush with the surface of the ceiling fitting. Original GE bulbs had small raised studs on the circumference of the glass surface. These aided the removal. Latest version has completely flat surface. Nothing to grip to help in twisting the bulb in its holder. Solution offered (Solution ? Dont make me laugh) is a suction cup, such as is found in a kiddies bow and arrow set, which is utterly useless. Now removing the bulb is a major operation involving pulling the whole fitting out of the ceiling.




I can well imagine the right suction cup working - given that we use

them here from time to time to lift floor panels which are not exactly

light weight.



Amazon sell this one specifically for GU10 removal

http://www.amazon.co.uk/Wolfcraft-54.../dp/B0027J282A

and there seem to be lots of other ones out there.


That looks like the db. Found one a bit cheaper of flea bay. If the rubber gloves previously suggested don't do the trick I'll try one of these.

Many thanks to all for their suggestions


Andy Dingley October 17th 12 11:31 AM

GU10 bulb remover
 
On Tuesday, 16 October 2012 11:44:34 UTC+1, fred wrote:
We have about 10 lights using these GU10 bulbs.


The knobbly surface of 60 LEDs gives plenty of grip, and you don't need to change them often.

If you haven't yet got 60 LEDs in your GU10s, then replace them. Maybe use an angle grinder to get the old ones out.

fred[_8_] October 17th 12 12:51 PM

GU10 bulb remover
 
On Wednesday, October 17, 2012 11:31:52 AM UTC+1, Andy Dingley wrote:
On Tuesday, 16 October 2012 11:44:34 UTC+1, fred wrote:

We have about 10 lights using these GU10 bulbs.




The knobbly surface of 60 LEDs gives plenty of grip, and you don't need to change them often.



If you haven't yet got 60 LEDs in your GU10s, then replace them. Maybe use an angle grinder to get the old ones out.


I read bad reports about GU10 leds. Short life etc. True ?

[email protected] October 17th 12 01:37 PM

GU10 bulb remover
 
fred wrote:
I read bad reports about GU10 leds. Short life etc. True ?


Life was shorter than you'd want for payback.
The payback time was long. It's now shorter.
I understand tungsten bulbs cost ~10 per year to run. LED bulbs are becoming mainstream - I have several and they're good.


http://www.wickes.co.uk/light-bulbs/...icat/ledbulbs/

http://www.ikea.com/gb/en/search/?qu...category=20515

Steve Firth October 17th 12 02:47 PM

GU10 bulb remover
 
wrote:
fred wrote:
I read bad reports about GU10 leds. Short life etc. True ?


Life was shorter than you'd want for payback.
The payback time was long. It's now shorter.
I understand tungsten bulbs cost ~£10 per year to run. LED bulbs are
becoming mainstream - I have several and they're good.


http://www.wickes.co.uk/light-bulbs/...icat/ledbulbs/


Bloody hell, no wonder some are complaining about price. I just bought a
load of R50 and GU10 LED bulbs for a fiver each. Charging £22 each is a bit
of a **** take.

--
DarWin|
_/ _/

Mark[_30_] October 17th 12 04:37 PM

GU10 bulb remover
 
On Wed, 17 Oct 2012 04:51:49 -0700 (PDT), fred
wrote:

On Wednesday, October 17, 2012 11:31:52 AM UTC+1, Andy Dingley wrote:
On Tuesday, 16 October 2012 11:44:34 UTC+1, fred wrote:

We have about 10 lights using these GU10 bulbs.




The knobbly surface of 60 LEDs gives plenty of grip, and you don't need to change them often.



If you haven't yet got 60 LEDs in your GU10s, then replace them. Maybe use an angle grinder to get the old ones out.


I read bad reports about GU10 leds. Short life etc. True ?


The ones I had, certainly. They lasted between 6-24 months.
I've now gone back to halogen.
--
(\__/) M.
(='.'=) If a man stands in a forest and no woman is around
(")_(") is he still wrong?


MaRKg123 October 17th 12 04:51 PM

GU10 bulb remover
 
On Wed, 17 Oct 2012 12:51:49 +0100, fred wrote:

On Wednesday, October 17, 2012 11:31:52 AM UTC+1, Andy Dingley wrote:
On Tuesday, 16 October 2012 11:44:34 UTC+1, fred wrote:

We have about 10 lights using these GU10 bulbs.




The knobbly surface of 60 LEDs gives plenty of grip, and you don't need
to change them often.



If you haven't yet got 60 LEDs in your GU10s, then replace them. Maybe
use an angle grinder to get the old ones out.


I read bad reports about GU10 leds. Short life etc. True ?


That's the least of your worries. I know plenty of horror stories of
people cheapskating on GU10 LED bulbs, getting them from ebay, and they
catch fire.

Really, don't cheapskate on cheap Chinese made LED lighting... Stick to
the brands you know (OSRAM etc...)



--
Using Opera's mail client: http://www.opera.com/mail/

ARW October 17th 12 08:06 PM

GU10 bulb remover
 
fred wrote:
On Wednesday, October 17, 2012 11:31:52 AM UTC+1, Andy Dingley wrote:
On Tuesday, 16 October 2012 11:44:34 UTC+1, fred wrote:

We have about 10 lights using these GU10 bulbs.




The knobbly surface of 60 LEDs gives plenty of grip, and you don't
need to change them often.



If you haven't yet got 60 LEDs in your GU10s, then replace them.
Maybe use an angle grinder to get the old ones out.


I read bad reports about GU10 leds. Short life etc. True ?


Semi true.

1 in 10 will fail within a week or so based on the last 2000 or so that I
fitted or was involved with fitting.

Send them back to the retailer and get a new one. The ones that do work seem
to work for quite a while.


--
Adam



Jim Hawkins October 19th 12 09:40 AM

GU10 bulb remover
 
fred wrote:
We have about 10 lights using these GU10 bulbs. They have to be
twisted to remove. Problem is the only ones we can find are flush
with the surface of the ceiling fitting. Original GE bulbs had small
raised studs on the circumference of the glass surface. These aided
the removal. Latest version has completely flat surface. Nothing to
grip to help in twisting the bulb in its holder. Solution offered
(Solution ? Dont make me laugh) is a suction cup, such as is found in
a kiddies bow and arrow set, which is utterly useless. Now removing
the bulb is a major operation involving pulling the whole fitting out
of the ceiling.

Question 1 . Does anyone know where I could source the original type
bulbs. I'e tried all the usual suspects, both local and ebay.

Question 2 Has anyone found a satisfactory way of removing these
bulbs ? I'm getting too too old to be swaying about on a step ladder.


I use my car engine valve grinding-in tool. Gives good suction - and a
very useful 25cm overhead reach too.




All times are GMT +1. The time now is 09:53 PM.

Powered by vBulletin® Copyright ©2000 - 2024, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Copyright 2004 - 2014 DIYbanter