Home |
Search |
Today's Posts |
|
Metalworking (rec.crafts.metalworking) Discuss various aspects of working with metal, such as machining, welding, metal joining, screwing, casting, hardening/tempering, blacksmithing/forging, spinning and hammer work, sheet metal work. |
Reply |
|
LinkBack | Thread Tools | Display Modes |
#1
Posted to rec.crafts.metalworking
|
|||
|
|||
Machining plastics: UHMW, Nylon, etc
Forgive me for asking a plastic question in a metal newsgroup, but it
seemed to be the most applicable place. I have to machine some round bushing-like parts. The inner diameter of the bushing is going to hold a rubber packing seal (similar to a chevron or V seal). Fluid inside the mechanism will be low pressure water. One option I have is to machine these seals out of a metal like aluminum or brass. Another option is to machine them out of plastic. I'm thinking that for prototyping plastic is the way to go (presumably faster to work with than aluminum or brass). However, I've never worked with plastic before. So I'm looking to buy some plastic rod stock, in 3" diameter. Checking a few online merchants like OnlineMetals.Com, I see that Nylon is pretty pricey, about 25% more expensive than the same dimension of aluminum (this surprises me). UHMW is much cheaper, about 70% less than the same dimension of aluminum. Can someone give me some info on machining these plastics? Does UHMW machine fairly easily? Is there any reason why I should buy the significantly more expensive Nylon instead of UHMW? What about durability? I'd like the prototype to hold up to some hours of use. Thanks, Scott |
#2
Posted to rec.crafts.metalworking
|
|||
|
|||
Machining plastics: UHMW, Nylon, etc
On Sep 16, 4:37*pm, Scott wrote:
Forgive me for asking a plastic question in a metal newsgroup, but it seemed to be the most applicable place. I have to machine some round bushing-like parts. The inner diameter of the bushing is going to hold a rubber packing seal (similar to a chevron or V seal). Fluid inside the mechanism will be low pressure water. One option I have is to machine these seals out of a metal like aluminum or brass. Another option is to machine them out of plastic. I'm thinking that for prototyping plastic is the way to go (presumably faster to work with than aluminum or brass). However, I've never worked with plastic before. So I'm looking to buy some plastic rod stock, in 3" diameter. Checking a few online merchants like OnlineMetals.Com, I see that Nylon is pretty pricey, about 25% more expensive than the same dimension of aluminum (this surprises me). UHMW is much cheaper, about 70% less than the same dimension of aluminum. Can someone give me some info on machining these plastics? Does UHMW machine fairly easily? Is there any reason why I should buy the significantly more expensive Nylon instead of UHMW? What about durability? I'd like the prototype to hold up to some hours of use. Thanks, Scott Would help to know what the fluid is and it's highest operating temperature! Lots of fluids soften many types of plastics and temperature certainly does. Paul |
#3
Posted to rec.crafts.metalworking
|
|||
|
|||
Machining plastics: UHMW, Nylon, etc
Scott,
I have some plastic rod, it is supposed to be UHMW. UHMW is supposed to be good for bearings. I have good luck using: Sfpm, can be just about anything, up to 500. Tools, SHARP with high back and side rake, in excess of 15 degrees, diamond honed sharp, moderate radius. Feed, high feed rates. Coolant, none. Drilling, high feed rate. Accuracy, should be able to hold a few mills, but some have reported changes after machining. Chips, lathe chips will be stringy and stretchy, tangling in the chuck, and grabbing. Thin strings will wrap around the part, sometimes requiring removal. Heat, not a problem, as long as high feed rates are used. Dave J. On Sep 16, 4:37*pm, Scott wrote: Forgive me for asking a plastic question in a metal newsgroup, but it seemed to be the most applicable place. I have to machine some round bushing-like parts. The inner diameter of the bushing is going to hold a rubber packing seal (similar to a chevron or V seal). Fluid inside the mechanism will be low pressure water. One option I have is to machine these seals out of a metal like aluminum or brass. Another option is to machine them out of plastic. I'm thinking that for prototyping plastic is the way to go (presumably faster to work with than aluminum or brass). However, I've never worked with plastic before. So I'm looking to buy some plastic rod stock, in 3" diameter. Checking a few online merchants like OnlineMetals.Com, I see that Nylon is pretty pricey, about 25% more expensive than the same dimension of aluminum (this surprises me). UHMW is much cheaper, about 70% less than the same dimension of aluminum. Can someone give me some info on machining these plastics? Does UHMW machine fairly easily? Is there any reason why I should buy the significantly more expensive Nylon instead of UHMW? What about durability? I'd like the prototype to hold up to some hours of use. Thanks, Scott |
#4
Posted to rec.crafts.metalworking
|
|||
|
|||
Machining plastics: UHMW, Nylon, etc
Chips, lathe chips will be stringy and stretchy, tangling in the chuck, and grabbing. Thin strings will wrap around the part, sometimes requiring removal. Heat, not a problem, as long as high feed rates are used. The trick here is to use a shop vac. Aim it right at the cutting tool. Karl |
#5
Posted to rec.crafts.metalworking
|
|||
|
|||
Machining plastics: UHMW, Nylon, etc
"Mechanical Magic" wrote in message ... Scott, I have some plastic rod, it is supposed to be UHMW. UHMW is supposed to be good for bearings. I have good luck using: Sfpm, can be just about anything, up to 500. Tools, SHARP with high back and side rake, in excess of 15 degrees, diamond honed sharp, moderate radius. Feed, high feed rates. Coolant, none. Drilling, high feed rate. Accuracy, should be able to hold a few mills, but some have reported changes after machining. Chips, lathe chips will be stringy and stretchy, tangling in the chuck, and grabbing. Thin strings will wrap around the part, sometimes requiring removal. Heat, not a problem, as long as high feed rates are used. Dave J. Use high speed steel, Dave didn't say it, only implyed. |
#6
Posted to rec.crafts.metalworking
|
|||
|
|||
Machining plastics: UHMW, Nylon, etc
On Tue, 16 Sep 2008 16:37:05 -0700 (PDT), Scott
wrote: Forgive me for asking a plastic question in a metal newsgroup, but it seemed to be the most applicable place. I have to machine some round bushing-like parts. The inner diameter of the bushing is going to hold a rubber packing seal (similar to a chevron or V seal). Fluid inside the mechanism will be low pressure water. One option I have is to machine these seals out of a metal like aluminum or brass. Another option is to machine them out of plastic. I'm thinking that for prototyping plastic is the way to go (presumably faster to work with than aluminum or brass). However, I've never worked with plastic before. So I'm looking to buy some plastic rod stock, in 3" diameter. Checking a few online merchants like OnlineMetals.Com, I see that Nylon is pretty pricey, about 25% more expensive than the same dimension of aluminum (this surprises me). UHMW is much cheaper, about 70% less than the same dimension of aluminum. Can someone give me some info on machining these plastics? Does UHMW machine fairly easily? Is there any reason why I should buy the significantly more expensive Nylon instead of UHMW? What about durability? I'd like the prototype to hold up to some hours of use. Thanks, Scott What Dave said, but you might want to try acetal (Delrin). Holds dimension, and is more rigid than UHMW and nylon. Bob |
#7
Posted to rec.crafts.metalworking
|
|||
|
|||
Machining plastics: UHMW, Nylon, etc
Bob wrote:
On Tue, 16 Sep 2008 16:37:05 -0700 (PDT), Scott wrote: Forgive me for asking a plastic question in a metal newsgroup, but it seemed to be the most applicable place. I have to machine some round bushing-like parts. The inner diameter of the bushing is going to hold a rubber packing seal (similar to a chevron or V seal). Fluid inside the mechanism will be low pressure water. One option I have is to machine these seals out of a metal like aluminum or brass. Another option is to machine them out of plastic. I'm thinking that for prototyping plastic is the way to go (presumably faster to work with than aluminum or brass). However, I've never worked with plastic before. So I'm looking to buy some plastic rod stock, in 3" diameter. Checking a few online merchants like OnlineMetals.Com, I see that Nylon is pretty pricey, about 25% more expensive than the same dimension of aluminum (this surprises me). UHMW is much cheaper, about 70% less than the same dimension of aluminum. Can someone give me some info on machining these plastics? Does UHMW machine fairly easily? Is there any reason why I should buy the significantly more expensive Nylon instead of UHMW? What about durability? I'd like the prototype to hold up to some hours of use. Thanks, Scott What Dave said, but you might want to try acetal (Delrin). Holds dimension, and is more rigid than UHMW and nylon. Bob Also IIRC acetal has very low water absorption whereas for nylon it can be significant and causing dimensional swelling. I have been told of one case where this caused seizure of a bearing when the nylon bearing equipped machine was left in a damp atmosphere. The OP mentioned water immersion so it needs to be considered. |
#8
Posted to rec.crafts.metalworking
|
|||
|
|||
Machining plastics: UHMW, Nylon, etc
David Billington fired this volley
in : Also IIRC acetal has very low water absorption whereas for nylon it can be significant and causing dimensional swelling. I have been told of one case where this caused seizure of a bearing when the nylon bearing equipped machine was left in a damp atmosphere. The OP mentioned water immersion so it needs to be considered. About 75% of all the machining I do is plastics, just by the nature of the tools we need. I'd recommend not using UHMW polyethylene for bearings/bushings unless they are only lightly loaded. Polyethylene compresses easily, and "crawls" or "creeps" under even moderate loads. As said here, nylon has its own problems, but is probably the most stable and strongest plastic you can use, presuming you allow for moisture expansion. For moderate loads, I'd recommend Acetal, perhaps filled with PTFE or Molybdenum disulphide. Even unfilled acetal is a good choice except for high loads or high speeds. And you'll really like the way acetal machines -- it has none of the bad habits of "fuzzing" like nylon and polyethylene do. Clean, attractive finishes can be had in a single pass with a sharp tool. Fine feed rates don't punish you, either. So taking down that last half-thou is easy. The belt tensioner on my old F.E. Reed lathe has an acetal bearing cut with enough clearance to slide easily across the face of the jackshaft arm. It's got probably 1000 hours of actual run time on it, and I can discern no significant wear to it or the shaft on which it runs (dry). LLoyd |
#9
Posted to rec.crafts.metalworking
|
|||
|
|||
Machining plastics: UHMW, Nylon, etc
On Tue, 16 Sep 2008 16:37:05 -0700 (PDT), the renowned Scott
wrote: Forgive me for asking a plastic question in a metal newsgroup, but it seemed to be the most applicable place. I have to machine some round bushing-like parts. The inner diameter of the bushing is going to hold a rubber packing seal (similar to a chevron or V seal). Fluid inside the mechanism will be low pressure water. One option I have is to machine these seals out of a metal like aluminum or brass. Another option is to machine them out of plastic. I'm thinking that for prototyping plastic is the way to go (presumably faster to work with than aluminum or brass). However, I've never worked with plastic before. So I'm looking to buy some plastic rod stock, in 3" diameter. Checking a few online merchants like OnlineMetals.Com, I see that Nylon is pretty pricey, about 25% more expensive than the same dimension of aluminum (this surprises me). UHMW is much cheaper, about 70% less than the same dimension of aluminum. Can someone give me some info on machining these plastics? Does UHMW machine fairly easily? Is there any reason why I should buy the significantly more expensive Nylon instead of UHMW? What about durability? I'd like the prototype to hold up to some hours of use. Thanks, Scott Suggest you avoid nylon- it's quite hygroscopic and changes dimension significantly with moisture changes. Second the suggestion for Acetal (Delrin). 3" diameter rod is $36/ft at mcmaster, which should be at the high end of the price range (try a plastics distributor). Best regards, Spehro Pefhany -- "it's the network..." "The Journey is the reward" Info for manufacturers: http://www.trexon.com Embedded software/hardware/analog Info for designers: http://www.speff.com |
#10
Posted to rec.crafts.metalworking
|
|||
|
|||
Machining plastics: UHMW, Nylon, etc
Scott,
All plastics are somewhat hygroscopic, some are worse than others. For that reason alone, never use a coolant, as the dimension you cut to will not remain in time. Delrin is better than nylon, but there are plastics that will swell only slightly, check with the manufacturer for swelling specs when submerged. Marine bearings are typically clearanced .002 to .003" per inch of diameter to compensate for absorbtion. Steve "Scott" wrote in message ... Forgive me for asking a plastic question in a metal newsgroup, but it seemed to be the most applicable place. I have to machine some round bushing-like parts. The inner diameter of the bushing is going to hold a rubber packing seal (similar to a chevron or V seal). Fluid inside the mechanism will be low pressure water. One option I have is to machine these seals out of a metal like aluminum or brass. Another option is to machine them out of plastic. I'm thinking that for prototyping plastic is the way to go (presumably faster to work with than aluminum or brass). However, I've never worked with plastic before. So I'm looking to buy some plastic rod stock, in 3" diameter. Checking a few online merchants like OnlineMetals.Com, I see that Nylon is pretty pricey, about 25% more expensive than the same dimension of aluminum (this surprises me). UHMW is much cheaper, about 70% less than the same dimension of aluminum. Can someone give me some info on machining these plastics? Does UHMW machine fairly easily? Is there any reason why I should buy the significantly more expensive Nylon instead of UHMW? What about durability? I'd like the prototype to hold up to some hours of use. Thanks, Scott |
#11
Posted to rec.crafts.metalworking
|
|||
|
|||
Machining plastics: UHMW, Nylon, etc
On Sep 16, 7:37*pm, Scott wrote:
Forgive me for asking a plastic question in a metal newsgroup, but it seemed to be the most applicable place. I have to machine some round bushing-like parts. The inner diameter of the bushing is going to hold a rubber packing seal (similar to a chevron or V seal). Fluid inside the mechanism will be low pressure water. One option I have is to machine these seals out of a metal like aluminum or brass. Another option is to machine them out of plastic. I'm thinking that for prototyping plastic is the way to go (presumably faster to work with than aluminum or brass). However, I've never worked with plastic before. So I'm looking to buy some plastic rod stock, in 3" diameter. Checking a few online merchants like OnlineMetals.Com, I see that Nylon is pretty pricey, about 25% more expensive than the same dimension of aluminum (this surprises me).UHMWis much cheaper, about 70% less than the same dimension of aluminum. Can someone give me some info on machining these plastics? DoesUHMW machine fairly easily? Is there any reason why I should buy the significantly more expensive Nylon instead ofUHMW? What about durability? I'd like the prototype to hold up to some hours of use. Thanks, Scott Hi Scott, I sell various plastics and have put a "Help center" on Google groups for UHMW; http://groups.google.com/group/uhmwtips UHMW is a pretty easy plastic to machine, but you won't get a high level of accuracy from machining because it moves. It's also only suitable for low-speed bushings - it melts at even moderate speeds. Delrin is usually preferred for its ability to be machined to exact specifications and it's a lot slipprier than UHMW. Nylon is also a good alternative, but it's very brittle - you might look into an oil-filled Nylon like Nylon GS or GSM. Eric |
Reply |
Thread Tools | Search this Thread |
Display Modes | |
|
|
Similar Threads | ||||
Thread | Forum | |||
A new cheap source for Delrin, UHMW, Teflon and Nylon | Metalworking | |||
What kind of grease for nylon/nylon and nylon/metal lubrication? | UK diy |