Home |
Search |
Today's Posts |
|
Home Repair (alt.home.repair) For all homeowners and DIYers with many experienced tradesmen. Solve your toughest home fix-it problems. |
Reply |
|
LinkBack | Thread Tools | Display Modes |
#1
|
|||
|
|||
Mr. Clean Auto Dry - "sorta" good idea, lousy execution
I picked up one today, filled it with the detergent and had
a mess on my hands (literally). The flimsy cover for the detergent reservoir didn't prevent spillage of the expensive and messy concentrated detergent. I returned it to the store for a refund, after first ascertaining that another unit suffered from the same problem. I know the thing will leave a spotless finish, but after buying the unit, extra detergent and deionizer cartridge, I expect more quality for my money and less hassle from it's usage. I'll stick to conventional methods of wet, soap, rinse, towel dry. With my luck, I'd most likely drop the thing on the driveway and watch it burst into 500 pieces. Maybe Mr. Clean Auto Dry is a solution looking for a problem. If you have smallish hands, the handle will be uncomfortable. I wear extra large gloves, so for me it's not an issue, but folks with small to medium sized hands should give Auto Dry a "test drive" before wasting their money. BTW, they suggest you wash in the shade, and don't use any detergent but their super expensive concoction. AND you will not get much water flow when you use the deionized water for rinsing. If you are short and have a tall vehicle like a van or SUV, forget about getting the wimpy stream to reach the roof unless you are standing on a ladder. David |
#2
|
|||
|
|||
David wrote:
I picked up one today, filled it with the detergent and had a mess on my hands (literally). The flimsy cover for the detergent reservoir didn't prevent spillage of the expensive and messy concentrated detergent. I returned it to the store for a refund, after first ascertaining that another unit suffered from the same problem. I know the thing will leave a spotless finish, but after buying the unit, extra detergent and deionizer cartridge, I expect more quality for my money and less hassle from it's usage. I'll stick to conventional methods of wet, soap, rinse, towel dry. With my luck, I'd most likely drop the thing on the driveway and watch it burst into 500 pieces. Maybe Mr. Clean Auto Dry is a solution looking for a problem. I've never had much luck with any of those car wash gimmicks. Water powered spinning brushes or spinning felt pads, static brushes that attach to hoses, etc. All of which waste water (unless you don't attach the hose). Like you, I always go back to the basics. Wet down, wash with car wash soap and towel (or brush), rinse, and dry with chamois. I am still using a 10 year old chamois that is made by Speedo, and used by swimmers to dry off after swimming competitions. I still use the old Simonize paste car wax, which shine actually does last a whole year. If you have smallish hands, the handle will be uncomfortable. I wear extra large gloves, so for me it's not an issue, but folks with small to medium sized hands should give Auto Dry a "test drive" before wasting their money. BTW, they suggest you wash in the shade, and don't use any detergent but their super expensive concoction. AND you will not get much water flow when you use the deionized water for rinsing. If you are short and have a tall vehicle like a van or SUV, forget about getting the wimpy stream to reach the roof unless you are standing on a ladder. David |
#3
|
|||
|
|||
I worded this wrong: " I wear
extra large gloves, so for me it's not an issue, " I meant I have extra large HANDS--I don't wear gloves while washing my vehicles. David David wrote: If you have smallish hands, the handle will be uncomfortable. I wear extra large gloves, so for me it's not an issue, but folks with small to medium sized hands should give Auto Dry a "test drive" before wasting their money. |
#4
|
|||
|
|||
Bill, I didn't know that people used chamois's on themselves!
I like "KISS" methods too. Simoniz takes a lot of elbow grease; I use NuFinish and other easy to apply waxes. Most don't last long though. David Bill Schnakenberg wrote: I've never had much luck with any of those car wash gimmicks. Water powered spinning brushes or spinning felt pads, static brushes that attach to hoses, etc. All of which waste water (unless you don't attach the hose). Like you, I always go back to the basics. Wet down, wash with car wash soap and towel (or brush), rinse, and dry with chamois. I am still using a 10 year old chamois that is made by Speedo, and used by swimmers to dry off after swimming competitions. I still use the old Simonize paste car wax, which shine actually does last a whole year. |
#5
|
|||
|
|||
On Tue, 17 Aug 2004 21:03:04 -0700, David wrote:
I know the thing will leave a spotless finish, but after buying the unit, extra detergent and deionizer cartridge, I expect more quality for my money and less hassle from it's usage. I'll stick to conventional methods of wet, soap, rinse, towel dry. With my luck, I'd most likely drop the thing on the driveway and watch it burst into 500 pieces. Maybe Mr. Clean Auto Dry is a solution looking for a problem. snip BTW, they suggest you wash in the shade, and don't use any detergent but their super expensive concoction. AND you will not get much water flow when you use the deionized water for rinsing. If you are short and have a tall vehicle like a van or SUV, forget about getting the wimpy stream to reach the roof unless you are standing on a ladder. I'm having some luck with adding baking soda to the wash bucket before adding any detergent. I had expected it to only soften the water (exchange potassium- and calcium- junk for sodium- junk). I thought it would only help the detergent work a little better, but it seems to help lower the surface tension of the rinse water also, causing it to sheen a little more and form less droplets. Regards, Scott |
#6
|
|||
|
|||
Scott, I'd never heard of that. I'll look into it. Do you
think it will affect the wax? Thanks. David Scott Packard wrote: On Tue, 17 Aug 2004 21:03:04 -0700, David wrote: I know the thing will leave a spotless finish, but after buying the unit, extra detergent and deionizer cartridge, I expect more quality for my money and less hassle from it's usage. I'll stick to conventional methods of wet, soap, rinse, towel dry. With my luck, I'd most likely drop the thing on the driveway and watch it burst into 500 pieces. Maybe Mr. Clean Auto Dry is a solution looking for a problem. snip BTW, they suggest you wash in the shade, and don't use any detergent but their super expensive concoction. AND you will not get much water flow when you use the deionized water for rinsing. If you are short and have a tall vehicle like a van or SUV, forget about getting the wimpy stream to reach the roof unless you are standing on a ladder. I'm having some luck with adding baking soda to the wash bucket before adding any detergent. I had expected it to only soften the water (exchange potassium- and calcium- junk for sodium- junk). I thought it would only help the detergent work a little better, but it seems to help lower the surface tension of the rinse water also, causing it to sheen a little more and form less droplets. Regards, Scott |
#7
|
|||
|
|||
David wrote:
Bill, I didn't know that people used chamois's on themselves! My daughter was on the swim team in HS. We bought it at a local sports store that specialized in competitive swimming attire and equipment. After she graduated, the Speedo went into the garage with the other car care stuff. Maybe it wasn't chamois, but it looked, acted, and felt like it. Not like that imitation crap that is sold in auto parts stores that sheds after a few uses, and you then have to dust off all those orange flakes. I like "KISS" methods too. Simoniz takes a lot of elbow grease; I use NuFinish and other easy to apply waxes. Most don't last long though. That's why I use Simonize. Applied once a year, rather than 2 or 3 times a year with the other quick stuff. I Simonized my truck last summer, and a quick summer shower just passed through here. The water on the hood on my truck (which is the first place for the wax to disappear) is still beading and running off. David Bill Schnakenberg wrote: I've never had much luck with any of those car wash gimmicks. Water powered spinning brushes or spinning felt pads, static brushes that attach to hoses, etc. All of which waste water (unless you don't attach the hose). Like you, I always go back to the basics. Wet down, wash with car wash soap and towel (or brush), rinse, and dry with chamois. I am still using a 10 year old chamois that is made by Speedo, and used by swimmers to dry off after swimming competitions. I still use the old Simonize paste car wax, which shine actually does last a whole year. |
#8
|
|||
|
|||
On Wed, 18 Aug 2004 11:28:37 -0700, David wrote:
Scott, I'd never heard of that. I'll look into it. Do you think it will affect the wax? Thanks. I don't think it will. I'm adding it for the purpose of softening the hard water here. I find I have to wax with 3M automotive wax about every 3 or 4 months without adding the baking soda. I haven't been using it long enough to know by experience if it affects the wax. Mostly, I think my wax is rubbed off during the weekly wash and dry anyway. Another thing I like is the microfiber towels. They sell them at Costco now. Use one to do the first pass when drying, and a second one to follow right after the first one. Ring the first one out when it leaves water behind. I can dry two cars with just the two towels. It used to take me about eight cotton bar towels. Regards, Scott |
#9
|
|||
|
|||
I have bought all of the piece of **** "car wash" items over the yrs
trying to make the job easier...Bottom line...Hand wash your car (if you care about it) hand dry with soft cloths or towels and hand wax. Ok, to wax with a buffer if you know what you are doing.....orbitals are the best....They are cheap at Sears, come in a bucket with carwash, wax, and pads. |
#10
|
|||
|
|||
David wrote in :
I picked up one today, filled it with the detergent and had a mess on my hands (literally). The flimsy cover for the We bought one and tried it this past weekend. We liked it! -- Wayne in Phoenix unmunge as w-e-b *If there's a nit to pick, some nitwit will pick it. *A mind is a terrible thing to lose. |
#11
|
|||
|
|||
It didn't leak detergent from the reservoir? I looked at a
couple of them and can say that the lids wouldn't stay on either. If you Google on the subject you'll see plenty of other complaints along the same line. David Wayne wrote: David wrote in : I picked up one today, filled it with the detergent and had a mess on my hands (literally). The flimsy cover for the We bought one and tried it this past weekend. We liked it! |
#12
|
|||
|
|||
We bought two of them..One for us, loved it and bought one for my
mom..Neither one of them have the problem you mention..It doesn't replace the action of washing the car, just the tedious job of drying..We have two dark colored cars and they both come out perfect...Maybe yours was from a bad batch? I too have tried a lot of those "gimmicky" washers in the past and they all ended up in the trash but I think the Mr. Clean one is good..Even though you have to replace the filter and use the soap they sell, I find the soap works very well... John "David" wrote in message ... It didn't leak detergent from the reservoir? I looked at a couple of them and can say that the lids wouldn't stay on either. If you Google on the subject you'll see plenty of other complaints along the same line. David Wayne wrote: David wrote in : I picked up one today, filled it with the detergent and had a mess on my hands (literally). The flimsy cover for the We bought one and tried it this past weekend. We liked it! |
Reply |
Thread Tools | Search this Thread |
Display Modes | |
|
|
Similar Threads | ||||
Thread | Forum | |||
External CH drain cocks - a good idea? | UK diy | |||
YAGI: Yet Another Good Idea! | UK diy | |||
using 30A cable to supply 5A lighting circuit: good idea? | UK diy | |||
YAGI: Yet Another Good Idea! | UK diy |