DIYbanter

DIYbanter (https://www.diybanter.com/)
-   Home Repair (https://www.diybanter.com/home-repair/)
-   -   radio (https://www.diybanter.com/home-repair/642171-radio.html)

[email protected] November 22nd 19 05:44 PM

radio
 
I`m looking for a radio that picks up audio T V signals. Where can I find one? Thanks for any info...Herb

micky November 22nd 19 06:04 PM

radio
 
In alt.home.repair, on Fri, 22 Nov 2019 09:44:23 -0800 (PST),
wrote:

I`m looking for a radio that picks up audio T V signals. Where can I find one? Thanks for any info...Herb


4 times. You're starting to get annoying.

But I'd like one too and I checked and surprisingly there are several
for sale.

One that google finds on Best Buy doesn't mention Tv.
Another has been sold since 2002, before TV was digital iirc.
Another looks just like the AM-FM-TV radio I have and used to like but
which doesn't know about digital.
One says TV in the heading but no mention in the specs.


These are all on Best Buy or Amazon. Maybe they should stop things that
don't have TV from saying TV!

[email protected] November 22nd 19 10:01 PM

radio
 
On Fri, 22 Nov 2019 13:04:35 -0500, micky
wrote:

In alt.home.repair, on Fri, 22 Nov 2019 09:44:23 -0800 (PST),
wrote:

I`m looking for a radio that picks up audio T V signals. Where can I find one? Thanks for any info...Herb


4 times. You're starting to get annoying.

But I'd like one too and I checked and surprisingly there are several
for sale.

One that google finds on Best Buy doesn't mention Tv.
Another has been sold since 2002, before TV was digital iirc.
Another looks just like the AM-FM-TV radio I have and used to like but
which doesn't know about digital.
One says TV in the heading but no mention in the specs.


These are all on Best Buy or Amazon. Maybe they should stop things that
don't have TV from saying TV!


Digital made that a lot more complicated. NTSC audio was just
broadcast in the clear on the FM band so it was trivial to put a TV
band tuner in an FM radio. Now you would need a digital tuner to get
the whole stream, this strip out the audio. You would also find out
pretty fast that the little whip antenna that worked great on analog
is not up to the digital world. As you know if you use an antenna, as
soon as that picture starts pixilating the audio drops out. It is all
part of the same stream.

[email protected] November 22nd 19 10:38 PM

radio
 
On Fri, 22 Nov 2019 17:01:17 -0500, wrote:

On Fri, 22 Nov 2019 13:04:35 -0500, micky
wrote:

In alt.home.repair, on Fri, 22 Nov 2019 09:44:23 -0800 (PST),
wrote:

I`m looking for a radio that picks up audio T V signals. Where can I find one? Thanks for any info...Herb


4 times. You're starting to get annoying.

But I'd like one too and I checked and surprisingly there are several
for sale.

One that google finds on Best Buy doesn't mention Tv.
Another has been sold since 2002, before TV was digital iirc.
Another looks just like the AM-FM-TV radio I have and used to like but
which doesn't know about digital.
One says TV in the heading but no mention in the specs.


These are all on Best Buy or Amazon. Maybe they should stop things that
don't have TV from saying TV!


Digital made that a lot more complicated. NTSC audio was just
broadcast in the clear on the FM band so it was trivial to put a TV
band tuner in an FM radio. Now you would need a digital tuner to get
the whole stream, this strip out the audio. You would also find out
pretty fast that the little whip antenna that worked great on analog
is not up to the digital world. As you know if you use an antenna, as
soon as that picture starts pixilating the audio drops out. It is all
part of the same stream.



The antenna isn't a problem - as long as the OP didn't want easy
portability. ? I used one of these fractal units for an elderly
friend, in the nursing home - to save him paying for cable TV -
when he only needed a few local stations anyway. It worked just fine
perched inside on his window sill. Minor position adjustments were
required to fine tune the TV signal.

https://www.leevalley.com/en-ca/shop...ractal-antenna

Finding a "radio" is another matter - I'd be tempted to get a used
cast-off 19 inch LED TV and use it . .
John T.


Ralph Mowery November 22nd 19 10:56 PM

radio
 
In article ,
says...

Finding a "radio" is another matter - I'd be tempted to get a used
cast-off 19 inch LED TV and use it . .



For the computer there are USB dongles that plug in.

You do have to be careful and make sure you get one for the US if thatis
where you live. There are many for the European stations for about 10
to 20 dollars. Most of the ones for the US seem to run slightly higher.

As mentioned, the antenna will be the thing. The whole signal is
digital unlike the older analog TV signal where there the audio was
transmitted at a slightly different frequency from the video and it did
not take all that much signal just for the audio.



[email protected] November 22nd 19 11:11 PM

radio
 
On Fri, 22 Nov 2019 17:56:57 -0500, Ralph Mowery
wrote:

In article ,
says...

Finding a "radio" is another matter - I'd be tempted to get a used
cast-off 19 inch LED TV and use it . .



For the computer there are USB dongles that plug in.

You do have to be careful and make sure you get one for the US if thatis
where you live. There are many for the European stations for about 10
to 20 dollars. Most of the ones for the US seem to run slightly higher.

As mentioned, the antenna will be the thing. The whole signal is
digital unlike the older analog TV signal where there the audio was
transmitted at a slightly different frequency from the video and it did
not take all that much signal just for the audio.


Fractal antrenna - build your own.

https://www.leevalley.com/en-ca/shop...ractal-antenna

John T.


Scott Lurndal November 22nd 19 11:32 PM

radio
 
writes:
On Fri, 22 Nov 2019 13:04:35 -0500, micky
wrote:

In alt.home.repair, on Fri, 22 Nov 2019 09:44:23 -0800 (PST),
wrote:

I`m looking for a radio that picks up audio T V signals. Where can I find one? Thanks for any info...Herb


4 times. You're starting to get annoying.

But I'd like one too and I checked and surprisingly there are several
for sale.

One that google finds on Best Buy doesn't mention Tv.
Another has been sold since 2002, before TV was digital iirc.
Another looks just like the AM-FM-TV radio I have and used to like but
which doesn't know about digital.
One says TV in the heading but no mention in the specs.


These are all on Best Buy or Amazon. Maybe they should stop things that
don't have TV from saying TV!


Digital made that a lot more complicated. NTSC audio was just
broadcast in the clear on the FM band so it was trivial to put a TV
band tuner in an FM radio.


You are correct that NTSC audio was a frequency modulated signal.

You are incorrect (with one minor caveat) that it was trival to
put a TV band tuner in an FM radio. The caveat being the frequency
allocation for channel 6 was just below the FM band, analog FM tuners
could tune low enough to pick up the audio for channel six.

The audio carriers for the remaining VHF channels were outside the broadcast
FM radio band and the UHF (14+) were way outside the broadcast FM
radio band. Adding circuitry to handle the wide VHF range required
along with the UHF to a standard Broadcast FM Radio-band receiver
in order to recieve audio from the NTSC channels other than six would
have to be recouped via higher cost to the buyer of the set.


[email protected] November 23rd 19 01:10 AM

radio
 
On Fri, 22 Nov 2019 17:38:22 -0500, wrote:

On Fri, 22 Nov 2019 17:01:17 -0500,
wrote:

On Fri, 22 Nov 2019 13:04:35 -0500, micky
wrote:

In alt.home.repair, on Fri, 22 Nov 2019 09:44:23 -0800 (PST),
wrote:

I`m looking for a radio that picks up audio T V signals. Where can I find one? Thanks for any info...Herb

4 times. You're starting to get annoying.

But I'd like one too and I checked and surprisingly there are several
for sale.

One that google finds on Best Buy doesn't mention Tv.
Another has been sold since 2002, before TV was digital iirc.
Another looks just like the AM-FM-TV radio I have and used to like but
which doesn't know about digital.
One says TV in the heading but no mention in the specs.


These are all on Best Buy or Amazon. Maybe they should stop things that
don't have TV from saying TV!


Digital made that a lot more complicated. NTSC audio was just
broadcast in the clear on the FM band so it was trivial to put a TV
band tuner in an FM radio. Now you would need a digital tuner to get
the whole stream, this strip out the audio. You would also find out
pretty fast that the little whip antenna that worked great on analog
is not up to the digital world. As you know if you use an antenna, as
soon as that picture starts pixilating the audio drops out. It is all
part of the same stream.



The antenna isn't a problem - as long as the OP didn't want easy
portability. ? I used one of these fractal units for an elderly
friend, in the nursing home - to save him paying for cable TV -
when he only needed a few local stations anyway. It worked just fine
perched inside on his window sill. Minor position adjustments were
required to fine tune the TV signal.

https://www.leevalley.com/en-ca/shop...ractal-antenna

Finding a "radio" is another matter - I'd be tempted to get a used
cast-off 19 inch LED TV and use it . .
John T.


I suppose that depends on how far you are from the tower. I am using a
"75 mile deep fringe" Yagi antenna and it is barely enough to get
towers 30 miles away. Those little flat panels they sell on TV are
useless.

[email protected] November 23rd 19 01:14 AM

radio
 
On Fri, 22 Nov 2019 23:32:26 GMT, (Scott Lurndal)
wrote:

writes:
On Fri, 22 Nov 2019 13:04:35 -0500, micky
wrote:

In alt.home.repair, on Fri, 22 Nov 2019 09:44:23 -0800 (PST),
wrote:

I`m looking for a radio that picks up audio T V signals. Where can I find one? Thanks for any info...Herb

4 times. You're starting to get annoying.

But I'd like one too and I checked and surprisingly there are several
for sale.

One that google finds on Best Buy doesn't mention Tv.
Another has been sold since 2002, before TV was digital iirc.
Another looks just like the AM-FM-TV radio I have and used to like but
which doesn't know about digital.
One says TV in the heading but no mention in the specs.


These are all on Best Buy or Amazon. Maybe they should stop things that
don't have TV from saying TV!


Digital made that a lot more complicated. NTSC audio was just
broadcast in the clear on the FM band so it was trivial to put a TV
band tuner in an FM radio.


You are correct that NTSC audio was a frequency modulated signal.

You are incorrect (with one minor caveat) that it was trival to
put a TV band tuner in an FM radio. The caveat being the frequency
allocation for channel 6 was just below the FM band, analog FM tuners
could tune low enough to pick up the audio for channel six.

The audio carriers for the remaining VHF channels were outside the broadcast
FM radio band and the UHF (14+) were way outside the broadcast FM
radio band. Adding circuitry to handle the wide VHF range required
along with the UHF to a standard Broadcast FM Radio-band receiver
in order to recieve audio from the NTSC channels other than six would
have to be recouped via higher cost to the buyer of the set.


That is why I said TV Tuner. The rest of the radio was pretty much the
same, you just needed a tuner section with a wider mouth. I had one of
those little "TV Radios" for years. They were pretty cheap and battery
operated so if you were interested in a show where the script was more
interesting than the video it was OK.

gregz November 23rd 19 08:32 AM

radio
 
wrote:
On Fri, 22 Nov 2019 17:38:22 -0500, wrote:

On Fri, 22 Nov 2019 17:01:17 -0500,
wrote:

On Fri, 22 Nov 2019 13:04:35 -0500, micky
wrote:

In alt.home.repair, on Fri, 22 Nov 2019 09:44:23 -0800 (PST),
wrote:

I`m looking for a radio that picks up audio T V signals. Where can I
find one? Thanks for any info...Herb

4 times. You're starting to get annoying.

But I'd like one too and I checked and surprisingly there are several
for sale.

One that google finds on Best Buy doesn't mention Tv.
Another has been sold since 2002, before TV was digital iirc.
Another looks just like the AM-FM-TV radio I have and used to like but
which doesn't know about digital.
One says TV in the heading but no mention in the specs.


These are all on Best Buy or Amazon. Maybe they should stop things that
don't have TV from saying TV!

Digital made that a lot more complicated. NTSC audio was just
broadcast in the clear on the FM band so it was trivial to put a TV
band tuner in an FM radio. Now you would need a digital tuner to get
the whole stream, this strip out the audio. You would also find out
pretty fast that the little whip antenna that worked great on analog
is not up to the digital world. As you know if you use an antenna, as
soon as that picture starts pixilating the audio drops out. It is all
part of the same stream.



The antenna isn't a problem - as long as the OP didn't want easy
portability. ? I used one of these fractal units for an elderly
friend, in the nursing home - to save him paying for cable TV -
when he only needed a few local stations anyway. It worked just fine
perched inside on his window sill. Minor position adjustments were
required to fine tune the TV signal.

https://www.leevalley.com/en-ca/shop...ractal-antenna

Finding a "radio" is another matter - I'd be tempted to get a used
cast-off 19 inch LED TV and use it . .
John T.


I suppose that depends on how far you are from the tower. I am using a
"75 mile deep fringe" Yagi antenna and it is barely enough to get
towers 30 miles away. Those little flat panels they sell on TV are
useless.


Since the FCC auctioned off the VHF high band, we now have a VHF low band
TV station around 60 mHz. A 5 foot rabbit ear is minimum requirement, and
that channel has at least 4 sub channels. People with little UHF antennas
are lost in the shuffle.

Greg

[email protected] November 23rd 19 10:39 AM

radio
 

The antenna isn't a problem - as long as the OP didn't want easy
portability. ? I used one of these fractal units for an elderly
friend, in the nursing home - to save him paying for cable TV -
when he only needed a few local stations anyway. It worked just fine
perched inside on his window sill. Minor position adjustments were
required to fine tune the TV signal.
https://www.leevalley.com/en-ca/shop...ractal-antenna
Finding a "radio" is another matter - I'd be tempted to get a used
cast-off 19 inch LED TV and use it . .
John T.


I suppose that depends on how far you are from the tower. I am using a
"75 mile deep fringe" Yagi antenna and it is barely enough to get
towers 30 miles away. Those little flat panels they sell on TV are
useless.


Since the FCC auctioned off the VHF high band, we now have a VHF low band
TV station around 60 mHz. A 5 foot rabbit ear is minimum requirement, and
that channel has at least 4 sub channels. People with little UHF antennas
are lost in the shuffle.
Greg


The home-made fractal antenna, linked above, picked up 3 - 4
TV stations. Location Brantford Ontario.
John T.


micky November 23rd 19 02:16 PM

radio
 
In alt.home.repair, on Fri, 22 Nov 2019 20:14:38 -0500,
wrote:

On Fri, 22 Nov 2019 23:32:26 GMT,
(Scott Lurndal)
wrote:
..............
You are correct that NTSC audio was a frequency modulated signal.

You are incorrect (with one minor caveat) that it was trival to
put a TV band tuner in an FM radio. The caveat being the frequency
allocation for channel 6 was just below the FM band, analog FM tuners
could tune low enough to pick up the audio for channel six.

The audio carriers for the remaining VHF channels were outside the broadcast
FM radio band and the UHF (14+) were way outside the broadcast FM
radio band. Adding circuitry to handle the wide VHF range required
along with the UHF to a standard Broadcast FM Radio-band receiver
in order to recieve audio from the NTSC channels other than six would
have to be recouped via higher cost to the buyer of the set.


That is why I said TV Tuner. The rest of the radio was pretty much the
same, you just needed a tuner section with a wider mouth. I had one of
those little "TV Radios" for years. They were pretty cheap and battery
operated so if you were interested in a show where the script was more
interesting than the video it was OK.


I never listened to more than a couple minutes, and it wasn't designed
for radio, but I think Law & Order would be a good show to listen to.

trader_4 November 23rd 19 03:20 PM

radio
 
On Friday, November 22, 2019 at 8:10:47 PM UTC-5, wrote:
On Fri, 22 Nov 2019 17:38:22 -0500, wrote:

On Fri, 22 Nov 2019 17:01:17 -0500,
wrote:

On Fri, 22 Nov 2019 13:04:35 -0500, micky
wrote:

In alt.home.repair, on Fri, 22 Nov 2019 09:44:23 -0800 (PST),
wrote:

I`m looking for a radio that picks up audio T V signals. Where can I find one? Thanks for any info...Herb

4 times. You're starting to get annoying.

But I'd like one too and I checked and surprisingly there are several
for sale.

One that google finds on Best Buy doesn't mention Tv.
Another has been sold since 2002, before TV was digital iirc.
Another looks just like the AM-FM-TV radio I have and used to like but
which doesn't know about digital.
One says TV in the heading but no mention in the specs.


These are all on Best Buy or Amazon. Maybe they should stop things that
don't have TV from saying TV!

Digital made that a lot more complicated. NTSC audio was just
broadcast in the clear on the FM band so it was trivial to put a TV
band tuner in an FM radio. Now you would need a digital tuner to get
the whole stream, this strip out the audio. You would also find out
pretty fast that the little whip antenna that worked great on analog
is not up to the digital world. As you know if you use an antenna, as
soon as that picture starts pixilating the audio drops out. It is all
part of the same stream.



The antenna isn't a problem - as long as the OP didn't want easy
portability. ? I used one of these fractal units for an elderly
friend, in the nursing home - to save him paying for cable TV -
when he only needed a few local stations anyway. It worked just fine
perched inside on his window sill. Minor position adjustments were
required to fine tune the TV signal.

https://www.leevalley.com/en-ca/shop...ractal-antenna

Finding a "radio" is another matter - I'd be tempted to get a used
cast-off 19 inch LED TV and use it . .
John T.


I suppose that depends on how far you are from the tower. I am using a
"75 mile deep fringe" Yagi antenna and it is barely enough to get
towers 30 miles away. Those little flat panels they sell on TV are
useless.


I fooled around with it a bit too. I'm about the same distance, 35 miles,
flat terrain. I borrowed one of those panel antennas. I didn't expect
it would receive anything. But it did pick up NBC and CBS plus a few of
the lesser channels sometime. At good times, it was rock steady. At
bad times one or the other or both would be either not there at all or
breaking up so bad it was unwatchable. I figured if that worked at
ground level, if I put a real antenna in the attic, it would probably
work much better. Which proved true, to some extent. Since I wasn't
committed to really using it, I opted for a cheap $15 Chinese, Yagi
style one from Ebay. It was supposed to be outdoors, included a rotor
and amplifier for $15. ROFL. I knew it was going to be flimsy, but
then an antenna is just some pieces of metal and I was going to try it
in the attic. So, it worked much better, but still not so great.
ABC was still mostly not there, even CBS and NBC while better, were not
improved as much as you'd think you'd get by raising it 15 ft higher
and having that better antenna. (It was about 3ft long, 2 ft wide)
It did pick up a lot more of the other channels, with some stuff of
interest. But even with NBC and CBS there were great periods and crap
periods. And the weird thing that I haven't seen anyone explain is
how it goes from one to the other, within minutes.

I can understand if it's raining or windy that it would decline. But
it also went from great to really bad or gone with no change in the
weather, at least not that I could tell. And it wasn't like it was
a passing cloud or something either. It could be a calm evening,
suddenly it starts going from great to problems and within 15 mins
it was either unwatchable or gone altogether. And then it would
be kaput for a a long time, like the rest of the night. I have no
clue what causes this, I've seen lots of people experiencing the
same thing, no one has any credible explanation. One guy thought it
was related to humidity, that might be a partial factor, but the
humidity doesn't change drastically in 15 mins and from my limited
experience, there was no correlation with anything. Sometimes it
could be raining heavily and it was working fine.

The next step would have been to spend $75 for real antenna but I
concluded that since I had cable, there wasn't enough other stuff there
to make it worthwhile. And I'm not sure if that would work really
well either. With NTSC and a decent outdoor antenna it was easy
to get reliable reception here.

That Ebay antenna was really something. It was for outdoors, but it
wouldn't last a month here. Very flimsy, a bird could bust it. It
had an amplifier on the antenna, not potted, just a circuit board
with a plastic cover over it. Cheap little motor. No indication
on the inside unit as to which way it's pointed. Wire from the
amp to antenna was broken off, had to solder that back on.

Then there are the TV ad guys selling antennas that are not even the
panel that goes in the window, just a little one that screws on the
coax jack and has two little 6" extendible ears. The guy hawking it
is down there by you, he shows it working on a boat a mile offshore.
It even works here, offshore. BFD. They probably picked a spot
5 miles from the transmitter and it's over water, completely
unobstructed. I'm still left wondering how well a large antenna would
work here. I don't know anyone that has one, IDK anyone here that
is doing OTA at all. Maybe ATSC was the best thing that ever happened
to the cable companies.






[email protected] November 23rd 19 06:39 PM

radio
 
On Sat, 23 Nov 2019 09:16:02 -0500, micky
wrote:

In alt.home.repair, on Fri, 22 Nov 2019 20:14:38 -0500,
wrote:

On Fri, 22 Nov 2019 23:32:26 GMT, (Scott Lurndal)
wrote:
..............
You are correct that NTSC audio was a frequency modulated signal.

You are incorrect (with one minor caveat) that it was trival to
put a TV band tuner in an FM radio. The caveat being the frequency
allocation for channel 6 was just below the FM band, analog FM tuners
could tune low enough to pick up the audio for channel six.

The audio carriers for the remaining VHF channels were outside the broadcast
FM radio band and the UHF (14+) were way outside the broadcast FM
radio band. Adding circuitry to handle the wide VHF range required
along with the UHF to a standard Broadcast FM Radio-band receiver
in order to recieve audio from the NTSC channels other than six would
have to be recouped via higher cost to the buyer of the set.


That is why I said TV Tuner. The rest of the radio was pretty much the
same, you just needed a tuner section with a wider mouth. I had one of
those little "TV Radios" for years. They were pretty cheap and battery
operated so if you were interested in a show where the script was more
interesting than the video it was OK.


I never listened to more than a couple minutes, and it wasn't designed
for radio, but I think Law & Order would be a good show to listen to.


I listen to TV a lot. If a shows writing is so bad that it is
dependent on sight gags I don't want to watch it anyway. I outgrew the
3 stooges when I was about 6.
I have an RF headset and I walk around doing things more productive
when the TV is on. I am finding just turning the damned thing off is
better most of the time. I will crank up my tunes if I need something
to listen to.

[email protected] November 23rd 19 06:49 PM

radio
 
On Sat, 23 Nov 2019 07:20:20 -0800 (PST), trader_4
wrote:

On Friday, November 22, 2019 at 8:10:47 PM UTC-5, wrote:
On Fri, 22 Nov 2019 17:38:22 -0500, wrote:

On Fri, 22 Nov 2019 17:01:17 -0500,
wrote:

On Fri, 22 Nov 2019 13:04:35 -0500, micky
wrote:

In alt.home.repair, on Fri, 22 Nov 2019 09:44:23 -0800 (PST),
wrote:

I`m looking for a radio that picks up audio T V signals. Where can I find one? Thanks for any info...Herb

4 times. You're starting to get annoying.

But I'd like one too and I checked and surprisingly there are several
for sale.

One that google finds on Best Buy doesn't mention Tv.
Another has been sold since 2002, before TV was digital iirc.
Another looks just like the AM-FM-TV radio I have and used to like but
which doesn't know about digital.
One says TV in the heading but no mention in the specs.


These are all on Best Buy or Amazon. Maybe they should stop things that
don't have TV from saying TV!

Digital made that a lot more complicated. NTSC audio was just
broadcast in the clear on the FM band so it was trivial to put a TV
band tuner in an FM radio. Now you would need a digital tuner to get
the whole stream, this strip out the audio. You would also find out
pretty fast that the little whip antenna that worked great on analog
is not up to the digital world. As you know if you use an antenna, as
soon as that picture starts pixilating the audio drops out. It is all
part of the same stream.



The antenna isn't a problem - as long as the OP didn't want easy
portability. ? I used one of these fractal units for an elderly
friend, in the nursing home - to save him paying for cable TV -
when he only needed a few local stations anyway. It worked just fine
perched inside on his window sill. Minor position adjustments were
required to fine tune the TV signal.

https://www.leevalley.com/en-ca/shop...ractal-antenna

Finding a "radio" is another matter - I'd be tempted to get a used
cast-off 19 inch LED TV and use it . .
John T.


I suppose that depends on how far you are from the tower. I am using a
"75 mile deep fringe" Yagi antenna and it is barely enough to get
towers 30 miles away. Those little flat panels they sell on TV are
useless.


I fooled around with it a bit too. I'm about the same distance, 35 miles,
flat terrain. I borrowed one of those panel antennas. I didn't expect
it would receive anything. But it did pick up NBC and CBS plus a few of
the lesser channels sometime. At good times, it was rock steady. At
bad times one or the other or both would be either not there at all or
breaking up so bad it was unwatchable. I figured if that worked at
ground level, if I put a real antenna in the attic, it would probably
work much better. Which proved true, to some extent. Since I wasn't
committed to really using it, I opted for a cheap $15 Chinese, Yagi
style one from Ebay. It was supposed to be outdoors, included a rotor
and amplifier for $15. ROFL. I knew it was going to be flimsy, but
then an antenna is just some pieces of metal and I was going to try it
in the attic. So, it worked much better, but still not so great.
ABC was still mostly not there, even CBS and NBC while better, were not
improved as much as you'd think you'd get by raising it 15 ft higher
and having that better antenna. (It was about 3ft long, 2 ft wide)
It did pick up a lot more of the other channels, with some stuff of
interest. But even with NBC and CBS there were great periods and crap
periods. And the weird thing that I haven't seen anyone explain is
how it goes from one to the other, within minutes.

I can understand if it's raining or windy that it would decline. But
it also went from great to really bad or gone with no change in the
weather, at least not that I could tell. And it wasn't like it was
a passing cloud or something either. It could be a calm evening,
suddenly it starts going from great to problems and within 15 mins
it was either unwatchable or gone altogether. And then it would
be kaput for a a long time, like the rest of the night. I have no
clue what causes this, I've seen lots of people experiencing the
same thing, no one has any credible explanation. One guy thought it
was related to humidity, that might be a partial factor, but the
humidity doesn't change drastically in 15 mins and from my limited
experience, there was no correlation with anything. Sometimes it
could be raining heavily and it was working fine.

The next step would have been to spend $75 for real antenna but I
concluded that since I had cable, there wasn't enough other stuff there
to make it worthwhile. And I'm not sure if that would work really
well either. With NTSC and a decent outdoor antenna it was easy
to get reliable reception here.

That Ebay antenna was really something. It was for outdoors, but it
wouldn't last a month here. Very flimsy, a bird could bust it. It
had an amplifier on the antenna, not potted, just a circuit board
with a plastic cover over it. Cheap little motor. No indication
on the inside unit as to which way it's pointed. Wire from the
amp to antenna was broken off, had to solder that back on.

Then there are the TV ad guys selling antennas that are not even the
panel that goes in the window, just a little one that screws on the
coax jack and has two little 6" extendible ears. The guy hawking it
is down there by you, he shows it working on a boat a mile offshore.
It even works here, offshore. BFD. They probably picked a spot
5 miles from the transmitter and it's over water, completely
unobstructed. I'm still left wondering how well a large antenna would
work here. I don't know anyone that has one, IDK anyone here that
is doing OTA at all. Maybe ATSC was the best thing that ever happened
to the cable companies.

They couldn't have sold ATSC to the public if cable/satellite wasn't
so pervasive. I am really determined to get this OTA thing working
because I really only need it for the local channels and PBS. The sub
channels with all of the old shows on them is just a bonus. Other than
that we stream. Right now the only bad channel is CBS. I may be able
to play with the aiming a little and get that. We really only have 2
towers here and they are both in the same basic direction. I tuned
this for the one with PBS that gets me NBC, ABC (the same company) and
Fox. I haven't looked at antenna web but I bet CBS is on the other
tower. They are doing a channel shuffle here as we speak so I am
waiting until the dust settle before I get to serious about it. I do
have an amp I can throw at it as soon as I feel like dragging out the
ladder.

Mark Lloyd[_12_] November 23rd 19 08:13 PM

radio
 
On 11/22/19 5:32 PM, Scott Lurndal wrote:

[snip]

You are incorrect (with one minor caveat) that it was trival to
put a TV band tuner in an FM radio. The caveat being the frequency
allocation for channel 6 was just below the FM band, analog FM tuners
could tune low enough to pick up the audio for channel six.


I have known people who listened to channel 6 on their FM radios (in 1978).

BTW, cable channel 22 is located just below channel 7, and you could get
22 on an old (non cable-ready) TV by adjusting the fine tuning.

[snip]

--
32 days until the winter celebration (Wed, Dec 25, 2019 12:00:00 AM for
1 day).

Mark Lloyd
http://notstupid.us/

"...in matters of faith, inconvenient evidence is always suppressed
while contradictions go unnoticed." Gore Vidal

Mark Lloyd[_12_] November 23rd 19 08:18 PM

radio
 
On 11/22/19 5:32 PM, Scott Lurndal wrote:

[snip]

The audio carriers for the remaining VHF channels were outside the broadcast
FM radio band and the UHF (14+) were way outside the broadcast FM
radio band. Adding circuitry to handle the wide VHF range required
along with the UHF to a standard Broadcast FM Radio-band receiver
in order to recieve audio from the NTSC channels other than six would
have to be recouped via higher cost to the buyer of the set.


A friend used to have one of those TV-band radios. It had 2 additional
bands, one for TV-Lo (2-6) and the other for TV-Hi (7-13). No UHF, maybe
it was too expensive to add circuitry for such hig frequencies.

--
32 days until the winter celebration (Wed, Dec 25, 2019 12:00:00 AM for
1 day).

Mark Lloyd
http://notstupid.us/

"...in matters of faith, inconvenient evidence is always suppressed
while contradictions go unnoticed." Gore Vidal

Mark Lloyd[_12_] November 23rd 19 08:21 PM

radio
 
On 11/22/19 7:10 PM, wrote:

[snip]

I suppose that depends on how far you are from the tower. I am using a
"75 mile deep fringe" Yagi antenna and it is barely enough to get
towers 30 miles away. Those little flat panels they sell on TV are
useless.


I have an antenna like that. Although it claims to work on VHF-Hi, it
won't get channel 7 from a city 30 miles away (it does really use
channel 7).

--
32 days until the winter celebration (Wed, Dec 25, 2019 12:00:00 AM for
1 day).

Mark Lloyd
http://notstupid.us/

"...in matters of faith, inconvenient evidence is always suppressed
while contradictions go unnoticed." Gore Vidal

Mark Lloyd[_12_] November 23rd 19 08:29 PM

radio
 
On 11/23/19 2:32 AM, gregz wrote:

[snip]

Since the FCC auctioned off the VHF high band,


Did they? I always thought it was UHF channels 38-51 that are no longer
used for TV.

we now have a VHF low band
TV station around 60 mHz.


IIRC, that would be channel 3.

A 5 foot rabbit ear is minimum requirement, and
that channel has at least 4 sub channels. People with little UHF antennas
are lost in the shuffle.

Greg


One of the channels here is on VHF-Hi (7). The others are UHF. Note that
two of those recently changed frequencies.

--
32 days until the winter celebration (Wed, Dec 25, 2019 12:00:00 AM for
1 day).

Mark Lloyd
http://notstupid.us/

"...in matters of faith, inconvenient evidence is always suppressed
while contradictions go unnoticed." Gore Vidal

Ralph Mowery November 23rd 19 10:56 PM

radio
 
In article ,
says...
They couldn't have sold ATSC to the public if cable/satellite wasn't
so pervasive. I am really determined to get this OTA thing working
because I really only need it for the local channels and PBS. The sub
channels with all of the old shows on them is just a bonus. Other than
that we stream. Right now the only bad channel is CBS. I may be able
to play with the aiming a little and get that. We really only have 2
towers here and they are both in the same basic direction. I tuned
this for the one with PBS that gets me NBC, ABC (the same company) and
Fox. I haven't looked at antenna web but I bet CBS is on the other
tower. They are doing a channel shuffle here as we speak so I am
waiting until the dust settle before I get to serious about it. I do
have an amp I can throw at it as soon as I feel like dragging out the
ladder.



I live about 40 miles from two major transmitting areas. One is just
about opposit of the other. Hooked to my ham antenna that is tuned for
about 445 HHz and is up about 70 feet on a tower I get around 43
chanels. I know some of them are really 3 or so from the same
transmitter. They have lots of stuff that is not on my Direct tV or
could even be had on DTV if I had their largest package.
They have lots of old shows and movies on them.



[email protected] November 27th 19 05:26 PM

radio
 
And the weird thing that I haven't seen anyone explain is
how it goes from one to the other, within minutes.



The weakness of the ATSC digital TV system used in the US is multipath.

Multipath simply causes ghosts on analog TV.

But digital TV will crash from too much multipath.


You can have a strong signal strength, but if there is too much multipath it still won't work. Unfortunately, it is hard to diagnose because you cannot see the problem on a TV.

You CAN (sometimes) see the problem on an RF Spectrum analyzer. If are are really into it, you can by a low cost USB dongle RF spectrum analyzer and look at the digital TV signal. You can then see SOME, but not all multipath.

Google key words for the gory details would be "ATSC, Adaptive Equalizer" , multipath, 8VSB vs OFDM, .

M





[email protected] November 27th 19 07:36 PM

radio
 
On Wed, 27 Nov 2019 09:26:43 -0800 (PST), wrote:

And the weird thing that I haven't seen anyone explain is
how it goes from one to the other, within minutes.



The weakness of the ATSC digital TV system used in the US is multipath.

Multipath simply causes ghosts on analog TV.

But digital TV will crash from too much multipath.


You can have a strong signal strength, but if there is too much multipath it still won't work. Unfortunately, it is hard to diagnose because you cannot see the problem on a TV.

You CAN (sometimes) see the problem on an RF Spectrum analyzer. If are are really into it, you can by a low cost USB dongle RF spectrum analyzer and look at the digital TV signal. You can then see SOME, but not all multipath.

Google key words for the gory details would be "ATSC, Adaptive Equalizer" , multipath, 8VSB vs OFDM, .

M

That may be a big part of it. I know if there is a tree in front of
your antenna the signal goes to hell pretty quickly, even with decent
signal strength. I assume that could be scattering the bits.
I do have a fairly directional antenna that should help with reflected
signals far away.


All times are GMT +1. The time now is 05:27 PM.

Powered by vBulletin® Copyright ©2000 - 2024, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Copyright ©2004 - 2014 DIYbanter